Most Americans want some trans protections in law but an increasing number think “gender” is determined by sex
If gender here is only meant to mean “being a man or a woman” it might suggest critical thinking is kicking back in
There’s more uncertainty around whether or not society has gone far enough in accepting trans people with a tiny bit more, overall saying things have gone too far.
18-29 year olds are most likely to say American society hasn’t gone far enough.
Black people are more likely to believe sex determines “gender” followed closely by white people
When it comes to education a majority at all levels believe this, as well,but those with a Bachelor’s degree are a bit less likely to
Being Dem is most linked to thinking otherwise
Science has been the biggest influence on people’s views. This makes sense as people trust science.
So it’s important science remains science&doesn’t turn into “science”
I think this underscores the medical profession does have culpability for how derailed things have become
Most Americans think discrimination is an issue in the US which, given there is housing&employment discrimination against those who identify as trans in America,seems spot on
A plurality believe social acceptance of trans people is low.
More ppl think it’s important to use a name chosen during transition than the number who think its important to use new pronouns
A majority are more ambivalent
Knowing a trans person makes someone more likely to say it matters but still less than half think pronouns are crucial
Most people are not paying close attention to bills around this issue. This is quite the problem for those of us trying to point out how stealthily sex is being rewritten in policy, and law, and how much harm is being done as a result of gender identity ideology.
There’s huge public support for trans protections in jobs,housing&public space
A majority think sports should be sex based
There’s some support for banning childhood transition but less for investigating parents
&more people than not think public bathrooms should be sex based
Some mixed opinions on whether children should be learning about trans issues in schools but a more people hold the idea it shouldn’t be taught in elementary schools and there are still some objections when it comes to teaching this in middle school.
As with most serious looks at what people think this shows those yelling we’re fascists are an over-represented group trying to force everyone to go along with their ideas
That theyre succeeding is mainly because they’ve frightened many into silence&others arent paying attention
Most people care about trans people but don’t seem to believe the tenets of the current ideology around them.
There’s some uncertainty about what “gender” means to the people who answer these questions.
Sex, on the other hand, is clearly still significant to most people.
A thread of mine is currently going round one of my social circles.
Given my face is linked to this account, I suspect more people I know will come and look at what I say here
If so, hello ❤️
You already know I’m a heretic on these issues but here I talk about them more fully:
I’ve been lucky enough to speak to women from so many different lands. All of whom are worried about the rise of an ideology that so casually renames us as bodies with vaginas or womb carriers. As terfs, too, if we don’t like that.
One which takes away our power to name male violence whenever it is perpetrated by a man who no longer calls himself one. That isn’t a hypothetical. It isn’t denying someone’s identity. It’s dealing with a reality many women have already experienced.
The professor who wrote this begins “As a straight, white, middle-aged, college-educated, settled-community, cisgender man” and we already know he sold his sense for magic beans down at the market.
He opines that calling us “terfs” hurts our feelings&our threshold for pain is low. But calling us “terfs” doesn’t hurt our feelings. It tells us about your woman-hatred. Using a word that dehumanises us& is often accompanied with threats of violence only says something about you
It’s notable the first “transphobes” mentioned are women who say no to this regressive nonsense rather than the men murdering trans people.Dissenting women are so often considered a much bigger problem than male violence.Even though male violence is central to these discussions
I said I’d tell you how it was going with my lifelong friend. The one who wanted to talk to me about all this. She decided she would prefer text over a phone call which made me quite nervous as we’ve been thick as thieves on the phone in the past. Her opening text message also
talked about her priority of being against trans exclusion which is a very specific framing. She’s my friend, but she is like family for various reasons and my heart fell to my boots at the idea that I was about to be rewritten as cruel or a villain (again). I thought
I was about to lose someone who is such a part of my growing up. Someone who is in or related to so many of my dearest memories.
It isn’t going how I feared though.
Things do feel rather tentative but we are talking
She is asking questions&being thoughtful. I am being honest
No idea what prompted this memory today,but at the 2019 general election before suffragette colours became so officially terfy I wore a suffragette sash with “votes for women” on it, &a matching rosette, out to vote. I hadn’t been well enough to go out to vote my whole adult life
I’d relied on postal votes. So I felt this immense pride and camaraderie with women, &with those who gave me this gift of being able to participate in politics. I was happy, and the sash only increased my joy.
It was interesting to see the reactions I got.
On the way to vote a neighbour came over to me and shook me by the hand twice. He seemed to think it was a wonderful thing. When I got to the polling station, however, one of the people who greeted voters and checked their names off was angry. He said “it’s NOT the day for that”
I’ve just finished reading a new memoir by Katy Tur, called Rough Draft.
It talks a lot about Zoey Tur, who is her father.
You likely remember this clip of Zoey telling Ben Shapiro if he doesn’t “cut it out” he’ll go home in an ambulance.
I want to tell you about the book🧵
The most striking thing is how much it reminds the reader of Susan Faludi’s (also excellent) book “In the Dark Room”.
Both are written by compassionate and successful women.
Both feature violent, abusive and misogynist fathers who go on to “identify as women”.
We are first introduced to Zoey as Bob Tur, a maverick journalist at the top of his game and married to Marika, a woman so intrepid she hangs out of a helicopter to get good footage for their work. They’re newly rich and up and coming