The attacks on trans people coming from center-left and "centrist" media sources like the NYT is very much part of the bigger plan by the right. The goal is to undercut any potential resistance to what comes next. 1/n
For years, people on the right like Jordan Peterson and Tucker Carlson have banged away at the idea that trans people have gone too far, and as a result fascists will take over and commit a new Holocaust against trans people and won't that be so sad (wink wink not really) 2/n
Now, with the entire right wing apparatus behind them in the US, and all of the media in the UK, they're moving on to the next target: center-left US media and heretofore supportive people on the left. The goal is to convince them of the same things the right already is: 3/n
Namely that trans people are a threat to women, children, and civilization, they've gone too far, and they must be stopped lest we get fascism. (Key difference in audiences is that center-left doesn't want fascism, and the right pretends it doesn't). 4/n
It's all couched in "reasonable concerns", "worried parents," and agitprop meant to enrage people on the left who don't know more than the surface details. For example, Pamela Paul's article treats health care providers using language inclusive of trans men 5/n
as worse than the fall of Roe v. Wade. She ignores the fact that trans men often skip gynecological care because of a lack of sensitive treatment, and are thus less likely to get things like PAP smears, and thus have higher mortality. 6/n
The inclusive language she rails against is meant to improve care for people who are reluctant to seek it, not to exclude or erase women. And you can still say woman.

But it's anti-trans agitprop for the left, the same as Fox News is for the right. 7/n
With SCOTUS on the verge of handing over the US to fascism via a ruling in Moore v. North Carolina sometime next year, the right is counting on having permanent control over all three branches, and they're laying the groundwork for what comes next. 8/n
And that's an America with no visible LGBT people, starting with trans folks first. Sure, they're not saying it TOO loudly, but when you look at what they're saying and doing, it's pretty clear where this ends up: namely that you can't even be trans in your own home. 9/n
Lawrence v Texas is going down. They're planning on eliminating health care for all trans folks. They want to treat trans people in public as obscenity. The threats of violence via paramilitaries like the Proud Boys is ramping up quickly. Police are aligned with the PBs. 10/n
The hammer will drop once democracy is gone. All of these entries in the NYT and other pubs are essentially preparation of the battlespace by the right: they intend to make sure as few people as possible have significant objections to what they do to trans people next. 11/n
The goal is 100% desistance, or 100% have fled to other countries (or perhaps just blue states). But they'll come for those in California eventually too, given the chance. 12/n
One of the more haunting things I've read is how important it was systematically to keep people from panicking, or realizing how much danger they're in. It was in part possible because sustained propaganda had reduced sympathy for targeted groups to zero among the population 13/n
We're in the preparatory phase for the remaking of America by the far right that is the modern GOP. They intend to remake it into something they think their God will bless. They believe God will not bless this country while it tolerates the existence of LGBT people. 14/n
Whenever your read something accusing trans people of being awful, (pedophiles, groomers, child mutilators, sex fiends, a danger to women, extremists run amuck), remember that it's in the interests of the actual fascists to ensure as few people say anything as possible. 15/n
Pay heed to Martin Niemoller. Recognize the modern GOP for what it is: a party that regards dead children as an acceptable price for fondling AR-15s like cosplay Rambos, and that is fine with women dying in childbirth to satisfy their religious beliefs. 16/n
If you think that a party that is fine with the butchery of women and children is suddenly going to grow a conscience regarding the basic human dignity of the people it hates most and sees as an existential threat, you need to think again. 17/n
Sadly, they're largely succeeding. The polling data just keeps getting worse and worse. I believe more firmly every day that the danger to LGBT people is real, and there is a growing threat of genocide. 18/n
Given the power of the US, and how fascist movements have successfully leveraged scare tactics, agitprop, massive amounts of money, and access to the Murdoch media empire globally, we're likely to see escape routes to other countries get shut down quickly post-2024. 19/n
Anyway, think before you post or like another "both sides", "concerned parents with anecdotes", or "the trans have gone too far" articles: the fascists know exactly what they're doing in making sure there's no one left to speak out when they come for you. 20/n

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Brynn Tannehill

Brynn Tannehill Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @BrynnTannehill

Jun 30
SCOTUS has opened Pandora's box. They've reverted to an extreme "states' rights" position that allows red states to end civil rights and oversight of corporations. Blue states like CA are going to try to drive the market with sanctuary laws and their own regs. 1/n
We're heading precisely towards the next phase of the American implosion: Two Americas, like in post-reconstruction and Jim Crow. What will (likely) determine if we move on to the next phase of dystopia is (again) the courts. 2/n
If SCOTUS allows Texas to prosecute women who leave the state for abortions, and to prosecute doctors who perform abortions outside the state (or provide medications like Plan B), that ignites the next crisis: 3/n
Read 13 tweets
Jun 27
This is a really good article. But, I covered the exact same things a year ago at smaller outlets. Receipts in the thread: 1/n

independent.co.uk/news/world/ame…
First one with DAME: 2/n
damemagazine.com/2021/06/24/the…
Next with the LA Blade (2 years ago): 3/n

losangelesblade.com/2020/08/28/qan…
Read 6 tweets
Jun 26
With the end of Roe v. Wade, and access to abortion disappearing in half the US, let's talk about the law of unintended consequences: namely, the awful downstream effects of this ruling. 1/n
First, there's maternal mortality. Poland has gone down this road, and the result is doctors who will let a woman die rather than going to jail for performing an abortion. With US states making it punishable by life in prison, many women will die. 2/n
nytimes.com/2022/06/12/wor…
Then there's infant mortality. Most later-term abortions are due to discovering fetal abnormalities inconsistent with life. Women will be forced to carry fetuses to term that won't make it to their 1st or 5th birthday, regardless of medical intervention. 3/n
Read 18 tweets
Jun 25
Here's what I'm hearing regarding Obergefell:

* It seems that at least one of Kavanaugh or Gorsuch really does believe that Obergefell is different because it doesn't involve "life". Votes to overturn it may not be there.

* Same with Griswold, Eisenstadt, & Lawrence. 1/n
* There has been internal debate w/in GOP whether or not to go after Lawrence before the mid-terms.

* GOP concerned that it would hurt them at polls

* ADF pushing to go immediately b/c they did a lot of legwork beforehand. And they're religious zealots. 2/n
* GOP coming around to the opinion that with all the anti-LGBT stuff firing up the base that going after Obergefell will keep the base fired up, while LGBT community is small, and most straights don't vote based on LGBT issues. Thus, targeting Obergefell is a net win. 3/n
Read 9 tweets
Jun 24
I long ago abandoned any belief that marches have any effect on modern fascists and theocrats. See: Poland, Belarus. I mean sure, if it makes you feel better to engage in some primal scream therapy, great. But it won't actually have any effect on a congress where 92% are safe.
It won't have any effect on SCOTUS justices who have jobs for life and top-end 24/7 security for the rest of their lives. It won't change the theocrats minds: they just love watching you impotently yell and wave signs about.
Everyone in this process is insulated from any consequences. You can't unelect 92% of them because they're in deep red states or their districts have been gerrymandered to hell. Maybe you'll convince some Democrats to get a little more creative, but did you see the response today
Read 6 tweets
Jun 23
Yes, let's talk about what happens when trans people lose the debate on "the transgender question", or the US slides into theocratic fascism.

Keep in mind, every one of these things have either been proposed by the GOP, or I've seen their base suggest. 1/n
* Banned from all single sex bathrooms. Going out in public becomes much more difficult

* Banned from sports. Get your own league isn't viable, because there's so few of us

* Obtaining transition related healthcare becomes illegal. Suicides soar. 2/n
* Providing transition related healthcare becomes illegal, meaning even those of us who transitioned long ago can't get HRT.

* Trans people have their children taken away

* Cis people have their trans children taken away by the state if they are in any way affirmed 3/n
Read 14 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(