1/ Pleasing to wake up this morning to news that - FINALLY - were hearing about the NHS in the leadership contest for our next PM. Similarly pleasing to see the word crisis. As for the NHS, crisis is very much where we are. Some tips @RishiSunak
2/ Lets look in a bit more detail. "From day one of being in office I'm going to put us on a crisis footing." - OK as above - this is a welcome step. Snr NHS leaders have been reluctant to use the word "crisis" when asked in recent weeks by @Jeremy_Hunt
3/ Now onto the detail. @RishiSunak "promise to accelerate NHS targets to cut waiting lists". Great, but the problem is not a lack of targets. We have targets we are not acheiving. These are predicted to get *very* much worse, perhaps reaching 14.6m👇
4/ We need to acknowledge this is *not* a "covid backlog". Its been building for a decade, worsened by COVID. It was the main reason, for example, an AA compensation scheme was needed in 19/20.
as doctors were rightly worried about "paying to work"
5/ But rising waiting lists are in no small part due to workforce issues. We absolutely need to train more doctors (and keep them in the UK), but we can *only* solve waiting lists in the short & medium term by *RETAINING* the existing workforce.
6/ Biggest driver out of the workforce is ill conceived pension taxation. This *wasnt* solved by the "taper tweak" in March 20, & indeed is now very much worse since the freezing of lifetime allowance in March 21 (& high inflation). Key additional driver out of the workforce
7/ is the general "annual allowance". With rapidly rising inflation, it is now the case that this is a very urgent threat to there being a huge exodus in 22/23, as the Finance Act is longer operating as intended measuring growth *above* inflation 👇
8/ Please urgently - take the time to review the debate brought by your colleague @DrDanPoulter 2 weeks ago & the suggested emergency solutions to Finance Act / Compensation Scheme, and also long term solutions fair to the taxpayer, like offered to judges
9/ Returning to your suggestions- making it easier to get scans without going to the hospital. Increasing diagnostic capacity is of course paramount to helping the waiting lists, however it requires capital investment in kit & enough people to scan/report @RCRadiologists
10/ Despite proclamations from government that the pay award are "the highest uplifts in nearly 20 years" you will be well aware that the 1%,2% or up to 4.5% given to doctors, versus inflation predicted at 11%, are in fact the biggest pay cuts on record.
11/ Whats more, disgracefully, is that departments are expected to fund these pay awards (aka huge pay cuts) from existing budgets awarded before the inflationary surge. This has led @NHSEngland to stating the very diagnostics you refer to being at risk
12/ Psl be aware of huge role of unprecedented pay cuts will have on workforce, specifically retention. Please be aware that subinflationary pay awards, combined with the Finance Act issue (CPI disconnect, negative PIAs) will hugely accelerate retirement
13/ The NHS is quite literally on the brink of collapse as reported in yesterday's @FT .
To fix this we must fix waiting lists, and do this we *must* fix retention. To fix retention we *must* fix punitive pension tax #taxunregistered#FixFinanceAct
14/ Its great @RishiSunak wants to make waiting lists his "number one public service priority" and I hope @trussliz does too. Please listen to experts @TheBMA@bma_pensions to understand the root cause of problems. p.s its not lack of targets.
Pls share/RT if you agree
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
"Its a NATIONAL SCANDAL that senior doctors are being forced to reduce their working contribution to the NHS or to leave it entirely because of NHS pension arrangements"
Highlights & my analysis. Pls read to end & share/RT👇.
2/30 A huge thanks to @Jeremy_Hunt@drlukeevans@rosie4westlancs & colleagues at @CommonsHealth for this really important report released today. Some vital recognition of problems relating to punitive pension tax & recommendations re pensions. Please read all carefully to end.
3/30 First & foremost is recognition that
1) Its a "national scandal" doctors forced to reduce hours or leave it because of NHS pension taxation 2) Crucially, the problem persists *despite* changing the taper rate of the annual allowance.
“Despite what the Government says, this is not a pay rise, but a more than 6pc real-terms pay cut, & this will have a significant impact on final salary pensions” said @Vish_Sharm@BMA_Pensions
A consultant could be worse off by £124,000 over the course of their retirement by delaying retirement for a single year"
"Clearly it's not fair or reasonable to expect workers to continue working, having given a lifetime of service, to receive a considerably lower pension,"
( & that doesnt include the £11-19k AA tax charge the consultant would need to pay due to #CPIdisconnect & #NegPIAs)
There would be an exodus of the country’s most skilled doctors. “It will be an absolute car crash if the Government continues to ignore this problem said @gdcuk
1️⃣ vital issue needing 4 nation solutions @BMACymru@BMAScotland@BMA_NI
2️⃣AA is the wrong tax for the wrong group of people & its destroying the NHS
3/26 A further intervention from Northern Ireland's @JimShannonMP again pointing out the 4 nation problem and large rise in retirements in the NHS since April (my prediction - unless this fixed very urgently, retirements will increase +++ in 22/23)
@DrDanPoulter MP "“punitive & unfair interplay between longstanding government pension taxation policies and the NHS pension scheme” for forcing many senior doctors to consider taking these “drastic steps.”
He warned that, with inflation at more than 9% this year, the penalties faced by doctors will be much higher, so the rules needed to be looked at “urgently, or we will see a reduction in the NHS workforce at the very time we can least afford it.
Responding the minister said any changes would affect "all pension savers"
However this is not correct as S235 of Finance Act only affects DB pension savers
1/ BREAKING NEWS: Ahead of this evenings debate @RCPhysicians ask government to "The temporary measures put in place for the 2019/20 tax year to enable additional work before the pandemic were an acceptable solution [AA compensatin scheme].
2/We recommend that this temporary measure is extended over the next 2 to 3 years until more formal changes to legislation are achieved. The increase in activity needed to overcome the backlog will be impossible without such a step.
3/ MP @drlukeevans had only yesterday challened Matt Styles & other NHS leaders @NHSEngland about "mandation" of such policies in @CommonsHealth eunquiry into retention