1)On @UN World Day Against Drowning it is clear that Mr Mnangwagwa & his Central Bank Governor Panonetsa John Mangudhla remain resolute in their quest to see Zim totally drown Today s launch of their gold coin is a case in point.
2)Like everything else they touch the gold coin will fail .Like everything they pursue coin will be an instrument of arbitrage &extraction .For starters it will not control or restrain inflation, exchange rate collapse or money supply.Broad money needs to be controlled at source
3)The source is of course the Central Bank itself whose appetite for quasi fiscal activities is unprecedented. It’s foreign auction system creates millions of US$ that are fueling the parallel market weekly. It’s Treasury Bills ,it’s retention of Export Surrender Requirements ..
4)..it’s external sovereign debt ( particularly its exposure to @afreximbank ), its overdraft to the Central Gvt are all creating money.Month on month growth in broad money since April has been 33% whilst for the year ending May 2022 it grew by 245%.The printing press is busy
6) Beyond the Bank s criminal omissions,has been Treasury’s irresponsible&corrupt expansionary fiscal policy.Despite the facade of “surplus” Mthuli has been spending money as if it grows on trees .In 2019 he spend US$6.9 beyond Parliament s Budget In 2020 he spent ZWL$102 billion
7) The 2021 Audit is not out but truth is deficit will be worse than previous years . In real terms since assuming office in Sept 2018 Mthuli has a run deficits which were at least 25% of GDP. So in fact “Mr Surplus” is in fact “Mr Deficit” & only this week he will bring …
8)…..a Supplementary Budget confirming gross over expenditure in first half of the year. The gold coin therefore can not stem the money creation caprice of the regime . Rather it will exarcabate the problem .It’s US$ price is US$1 823.80 or ZWL$805745.35 underpins the challenge
9)Selling the coin in local currency at an exchange rate that is almost 50 % parallel rate simply means that cartels have a new source of arbitrage.The gold coin,just like the auction will be a target by ZANU cartels&mafia Like the auction ,the coin will lead to money creation
10) Rather than address inflation the coin will thus be driver of inflation. Further it will be a key tool of money laundering . Zim is already a big washing machine with international criminals smuggling US$ into Zim then used to purchase gold which is then exported .
11) The coin is thus chlorinating billions of dirty money out in Middle East&Asia desperate for legitimacyTo the majority of Zimbabweans ,95% of whom are unemployed & many earning less thanUS$100 in RTGS$ anyway , the coin is a mirage . A gimmick created to steal their wealth
12) The gold coin ultimately is an act of desperation.A country without any reserves & with a tattered currency can’t sell its gold .But there is logic in the madness .That logic is corruption ,self enrichment ,greed & caprice . That regrettably is the DNA of this regime #SHAME
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1) The Minister of Finance has presented his 2022 mid term review & budget statement . It was painful to indulge in an hour of a pointless,tired monologue .An absolute damp squib.A huge opportunity was missed to address fundamental disequilibrium in the economy centered around …
2) 7 key issues that are 1) hyperinflation 2) exchange rate collapse 3) collapse in public sector wages 4) collapse of the social sector 5) low out put 6) deficit financing & the national debt 7) tax reform .Sadly the gvt missed a glorious opportunity of addressing key issues
3) Failing to address the key challenges of the day was a cowardly criminal omission that in any event has been the hallmark of Mthuli s tenure. To compound matters Mthuli then proceeded to make shocking announcements on a supplementary budget & some tax increases .
1) Tomorrow the Minister of Finance presents a mid term review and a Supplementary Budget . The Review comes in the backdrop of an economy arrested by headwinds contradictions&policy distortions. It comes in environment dominated by hyperinflation, exchange rate collapse &poverty
2) The Review must address the issue of money creation so key to the crises of over accumulation that has taken Zim back to 2008. It must address issue of a falling Zim $ &a collapsed exchange rate It must address collapsed public sector wages that has crippled the public sector
3)We expect the Review to come up with extremely populist but costly fiscal measures as 2023 draws closure . We expect some nominal relief on tax brackets & rates of taxes in other sectors . But truth is the Review will not touch on key structural issues arresting this economy
1)The regime has announced a potpourri of contradictory, self defeating , punitive & vindictive measures with the intended aim of stopping or reversing the dramatic& rambacious free fall of the Zimbabwean $ &the consequential inflationary spike experienced in the last two weeks
2)Truth is the measures are I’ll thought& reflective of a paranoid moribund incompetent regime that believes everything&everyone is an enemy&a saboteurA regime that blames everyone except itself for the humongous mess it has plunged Zim intoA regime that sees shadows everywhere
3) The dramatic fall of the exchange rate stems from the introduction of the Zim$ when the necessary preconditions were absent . It stems from a huge mismatch between supply & demand . It stems from the failure of the Dutch auction system. It stems from a huge budget deficit ..
In the afternoon I pulled down a tweet made in connection with ProfMaduku’s interpretation of section 96(2) of the constitution.The context of that tweet is explained below. Clearly in my banter with Lovemore , whom I have known for over 20 years & worked with very closely ...
...in the law , in the struggle & in personal spaces I overlooked the huge extent of the fragile national question marginalization alienation and exclusion of certain communities in Zimbabwe.I have lived with this discrimination & exclusion throughout my life. I have recently ..
...seen this isolation & disillusionment on our recent visit to Chilonga. Chipinge is no different. Ironically like Chiredzi it was part of the Gaza State established by Soshangaan &his descendant Ngungunyana With the fall of the Gaza State colonial Rhodesia plundered Gazaland
1)We have spent a few days in the Chiredzi #Chilonga area visiting & listening to compatriots in Chiredzi South&East.We have met with ordinary citizens, community leaders&traditional leadersWe have travelled huge distances to places such as Chikombedzi,Malipati Boli,Gonarezhou
2)We have seen & heard from a tortured, insecure &angry citizen in the Shangani communities so dominant in this part of the Lowveld.This is a community that has suffered displacements twice beforeIn the 60sthey were removed from the Hippo Valley area to make way for sugar estates
3)They were then ejected to pave way for huge eco reserves , Gona Rezhou National Park & Malilangwe Reserve. They subsequently rebuilt their lives in South Eastern Lowveld in areas mulcted by tsetse fly, high temperatures, wild animals, poverty & infrastructure deficits
1) The House that Emmerson built is a ramshackle hotbed of misrule mis governance &repression characterized by four definitioning anchors of failure. Ist is economic misrule & lack of craft competence . Emmerson has taken Zim to depths of economic melt down & poverty unheard of .
2)Thanks to policy missteps the economy has been plunged into a huge recession characterized by hyperinflation, zero productivity & poverty .More than anything else the mismanagement of the exchange rate&runaway FX rates have defined Emmerson s criminal incompetence & nakedness
3) Second is State Capture& corruption .Emmerson & his brood have taken corruption to new lows .Leakages have been created in 8Commanding Heights of Capture viz Fuel,FX Allocations ,Command Agriculture,Minerals , Procurement,Subsidies & RBZ QF activities .Cartels now run economy