Earlier this week, @artstuffmatters, @WTFAnthro, & others spread news of the disturbingly hidden "public notice" which the University of Pennsylvania had posted, seeking to bury "at least 13" skulls in the Morton Cranial Collection. (thread) marketplace.inquirer.com/pa/legal/notic…
2) This "notice" hits me so incredibly hard.
But I wasn't surprised.
Not cuz Penn's past behavior has trained me not to be surprised, but because, I actually had a bit more notice, kind of.
I was told about this Orphans Court petition back on April 15.
3) Many of you know that I have studied, written about, given talks on, and taught about Samuel George Morton and the mid-19th-century Racial Science that is the root of so much. I've lived with him and his collaborators and students for some 15 years now. intersectionist.medium.com/american-power…
4) & more recently, I've been spending a lot of time in Philly. This is why.
So this "notice" hits me so incredibly hard. Like, I'm speechless.
But not surprised. I had a bit more notice, kind of.
While I was researching my article, I met with @PennMuseum Director Chris Woods.
@pennmuseum 5) Woods mentioned the petition twice, and I did not realize what it meant, to be honest--but now that I do, I am physically ill.
I spoke of this in my objection to @Penn's petition. And since that means it's a matter of public record, I want to make it public here, now, too:
6) "I object on the basis of my meeting with Chris Woods, the Director of the Penn Museum, on April 15, 2021, who made clear to me that he was eager to “deal with” the “immediate issue” of the Black Philadelphians as soon as possible, so that he can deal with the Cuban crania...
7)...in the collection, next. While he has publicly claimed to care about "accountability,” “working toward repair,” and also professed to me that “doing the right thing is a good thing,” this secretive Petition itself, and the actions leading up to it and that it seeks the ...
8) ...court’s approval to perform, are an egregious display of disregard for community. Dr. Woods even mentioned this Orphan’s Court petition to me in that
meeting–reflecting his disproportionate openness with an academic colleague, in contrast to the actual members of the...
9) ...descendant community. I am even more dismayed now that I’ve seen that the petition seeks to bury the remains without any prior public discussion, ceremony, or even a truly public announcement and invitation for those who identify as the descendant community for these...
10) ...Black Philadelphians to attend the burial at Eden Cemetery."
I lack the capacity to spell out more, right now. But this all hits me so hard. I'm already haunted by imagining what happens if the judge approves @pennmuseum's petition.
I'm already grieving. & I'm scared.
11) here’s some more of what I said—most of which boils down to my rejection of the idea that just because they have considered our ancestors their property for decades, the Penn Museum gets to decide what happens to them: #museumsarenotneutral
It’s 2022, ffs.
12) Sending love to all who are also hurting this week, from this and other white supremacist attacks.
I got to go take care of myself for a bit now, and I hope y’all can take time for that, too.
13) Part of taking care of myself was spending more time with the people in question--or, at least, our best guess at who those people are--the ones Penn want to bury. They don't even think it's important to tell the court--the people--who they are.
Violence upon violence.
14) "Black Philadelphians in the Samuel George Morton Cranial Collection" by Paul Wolff Mitchell does a powerful job of explaining this severe fuckery.
I guarantee this article will answer a lot of questions, & leave you with a new level of...shudder. drive.google.com/file/d/14udZd7…
15) Most important thread on this, by Advisory Committee member @MxAbdulAliy, speaking to role (and lack thereof) of community in the burial plan Penn posted "notice" of:
To clarify:
This *is* the same museum that stole remains of Katricia & Delisha, children murdered in 1985 MOVE bombing.
Before we knew that curator Janet Monge had their bones in her lab, she already faced criticism for use of Morton Collection--which they're now trying to bury:
A couple quick resources before I gotta hop off and finish final edits on my article (about both Morton collection and MOVE remains at the Penn Museum, as it happens):
What's proposed in the Notice is based on a completely gross misreading of this article: prss.sas.upenn.edu/penn-medicines…
This page has the Penn Museum's "apology" for holding unethically collected Morton Crania--issued the week before news broke re: MOVE remains.
It's their attempt to appear to be responsive to community...--issued the week before news broke re: MOVE remains penn.museum/sites/morton/
THREAD:
Breaking twitter silence now the City of Philadelphia's has released their investigagtion into the MOVE bombing remains.
Sending love to everyone whose lives this touches, especially those whose murdered loved ones' bodies are yet again subject to public interrogation.
The report covers the remains found at the Medical Examiner's Office in May 2021; & as well as the other remains held by Alan Mann and Janet Monge at the Penn Museum, made public in April 2021. phila.gov/documents/inde…
I'm still working through the report myself, but if folks have questions I will do my best to share based on what I know from my own research.
I plan to use this thread to share some key coverage and responses to this report.
1: There this a thing that happens where they drown the truth in details.
And that's what they did here: the highly paid partners at a fancy law firm, @llc_tucker, wrote a total POS 217 pg "independent legal report" for @Penn, claiming the Penn Museum never had Delisha's bones.
2: This claim was in response to two things:
1. The original reporting last April said @pennmuseum had the remains of 2 children murdered in the 1985 MOVE bombing.
2. Only one child's remains, Katricia/Tree's, were retrieved from the home a former curator & returned her family.
3: In their attempt to explain the discrepancy, incl eyewitness accounts & actual x-rays taken @CAAMatPenn of Delisha's remains, @Penn's report scapegoated a single graduate student, claiming he planted evidence...on a day when he was literally out of the country.
(Impressive!)