Siddartha Shankar Ray’s speech on Jyoti Basu. Both were close friends. Jyoti Basu was in financial trouble early on. Ray informed this to CM Dr. B. C. Roy, who immediately designated him as LoP so that he could draw LoP’s salary. Current WB CM sends police to LoP’s home !
For the records, I don’t like any of the three. Both Dr. Roy & Jyoti Basu were morally corrupt. On S S Roy, the less said the better, for the uninitiated, read how he persecuted everyone he suspected as Naxal & their families. Video of S S Roy’s speech
Bidhan Chandra Roy backstabbed Subhas Babu, looked the other way when Bengal’s land were given to Bihar and East Pakistan. Jyoti Basu was the member of CPI, which again backstabbed Subhas and sided with the British during Quit India movement.
Only thing that can be said in defense of the current WB CM’s conduct wrt LoP vis a vis Dr Bidhan Roy’s conduct wrt then LoP Jyoti Basu, when Dr Roy showed grace, Jyoti Basu was not a serious challenger. While current LoP has defeated current CM.
Would Dr. Roy be vindictive against a serious challenger. Hard to say because he had no compunction serving in the committee that expelled Subhas Babu from INC & was welcomed by men sent by Birla on his return from that meeting.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Public opinion in Bengal has turned against Begum, at the moment, though I hope the turn is irrevocable. Evidence: Begum’s trusted institutions are retreating: 1) Religious institutions like Ramkrishna Mission 2) Establishment doctors
1) One of Begum’s trusted MLA-doctor described her as Ma Sarada reincarnate. Ramakrishna Mission initially remained silent, but after LoP called for a response as Swami Vivekananda had entrusted them 2 protect Thakur’s legacy, they sternly rebuked the MLA, & indirectly Begum
2) The above was few months back. But day before yesterday SSKM doctors refused to admit Anubrata without examination and after examination 4/7 refused to lie and stated that there was no need to hospitalize him.SSKM would invariably admit Tolamuli corrupt & save them from CBI-ED
Don’t believe Begum had any deal with Modi-Shah 2 get VS 21.2 convincing evidences: 1) she lost her own seat, even more, to her former junior, who even then had the potential 2 become the alternative face 2) Modi virtually became the face of WB BJP, Modi-Shah did daily passengeri
1) As Nandigram campaign progressed, Begum was calling various BJP members so that they sabotage BJP’s campaign in Nandigram, she admitted that the leaked audio of the call to Proloy Pal was genuine.
If there was a deal, she would get Modi-Shah 2 withdraw Suvendu. In fact, have them not field him in the first place & campaign that he ran. Now, that’s a blot she would have to live with for the rest of her life.
To most of the anti Mamata crowd, LS election is less important than VS election because they want the Begum Govt out. LS election is a stepping stone to VS election. If BJP does well in LS in WB it will have a base to launch the final assault on Tolamul.
I can see why this crowd will be fertile ground for the conspiracy theory that Begum has promised hefty LS seats to Modi in exchange of his promise to surrender VS. The anti Mamata crowd doesn’t necessarily trust Modi (mostly they don’t) & they believe WB VS isn’t imp 4 him,
But the theory just isn’t founded in my view. Here is why:
A PIL was filed on huge increase in property of 19 Tolamul leaders & ministers between 2011-2016.HC orders ED enquiry into their wealth. The list includes Firhad, Biman (Speaker), Arup Ray, Moloy Ghatak, Jyotirmoy Mallik, Rajib Banarjee, Sabyasachi, Arjun Singh, Sovan Chatterjee
Others: Bratya Basu, Rejjak Mollah, Iqbal Ahmed, Seuli Saha, Gautam Deb, Swarnakamal Saha, Amit Mitra, Subroto Mukherjee, Sadhan Pande
Strange conspiracy theories floating around even among BJP sympathizers. Modi has struck a deal with Begum by which Begum would surrender a large number of LS seats & Begum would be given VS in return.
I find this absurd. First politicians do not think or work for elections that are not the next one, because democratic politics is never long term and no one can predict politics even 3 months ahead.
2018 December when Congress won 3 states, did anyone think Modi would be back with 300+ seats? But the politics changed radically in the next 3 months because of Pulwama + Balakot. Its ridiculous to think Modi-Begum are discussing 2026 VS now.
Truism: Responsibility of any unacceptable conduct lies primarily with the perpetrator, not the abettor.
So Mamata is responsible 4 the post poll pogrom in WB & Modi for dumping a citizen of the country he is PM of to the wolves. Those blaming others are mere hangers on of power.
So contrary to the IPAC planted individuals with Hindu Bengali persona camouflage, I don’t hold BJP as the primary responsible party for the post poll violence though central BJP abdicated its duty.
Simultaneously, contrary to the positions of BJP’s beneficiaries, neither Zubair, nor liberals, nor Middle East is responsible for betraying the Indian civilization, Modi & RSS is. Its they who fed their ward to wolves.