Catching up on the latest #MysteryBroker dispatch, in which he details several elements of he bull case for stocks from here, while saying that it is not yet his "base case..."
The #MysteryBroker notes the 19% S&P 500 rally (intraday low to high) had some of the elements “necessary for a new bull market to take hold.” Breadth of the rally, leadership by high-beta stocks, credit spreads narrowing. He also likes the continued investor skepticism...
The #MysteryBroker says outperformance by financial stocks in the rebound wasn't present - a missing element of the new-bull-market case. In any case, he says the S&P 500 needs to reach 4545 (a 25% gain) by Sept. 16, or at the outside by Oct. 2, to prove it’s a bull market.
For what it's worth, he doesn't lean much on the point that no bear-market rally has ever gained 50%+ of total losses (since 1950 on a closing basis) and then go make a new low. Says there have been too many failed rallies very close to that magnitude for comfort.
#MysteryBroker continues to say inflation's on a sustained downswing, “by all measures supply chain issues are improving,” productivity bottoming. Wild card: He sees a coup/assassination of Putin a “much higher possibility than investors have handicapped,” would drop oil prices.
The #MysteryBroker sees one shorter-term bullish scenario that would be a huge head fake, essentially the “deferred-recession” possibility...
The #MysteryBroker notes the shortest time historically from inversion of the 3-month/10-year Treasury curve has been eight months. If it inverts next month as seems likely, the front edge of the recession onset window is May 2023...
Because stocks have tended to peak an average six months before recession, #MysteryBroker says it would mean the S&P rallies to a new high by mid-2023 before starting to discount a late-2023 recession.
The #MysteryBroker notes this would rebuild investor complacency, with the Fed likely stopping rate hikes in coming months, and would also fit with the very strong historical strength in stocks from a mid-term election into June the following year.
In the here and now, bottom line, #MysteryBroker is alert to the bullish potential, and believes the next 30 days will be the tell, but remains concerned the Fed will “ignore the upcoming favorable inflation data” and over-tighten into recession.
That's it for now. Please pay attention to the fine print here...

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Michael Santoli

Michael Santoli Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @michaelsantoli

Aug 8
Having most recently argued weeks ago that Street sentiment was way too negative on recession odds, corporate earnings and stock prices, the #MysteryBroker weighs in on the current key market juncture, lays out a few likely scenarios rather than a single high-conviction view...
Before detailing the scenarios, #MysteryBroker sees the ultimate path from here almost wholly dependent on whether the Fed responds to forward-looking inflation indicators that suggest to him inflation is already headed down decisively by moderating its tightening plans - or not.
First scenario, #MysteryBroker says is a pure bear-market rally, S&P peaks no higher than 4200, drops to an ultimate bottom between 3150 and 3400. This would require a recession start by early next year "at the latest..."
Read 8 tweets
Aug 7
Stocks have regained almost half of their total decline, but not quite. Several signals of a good bottom and new uptrend triggered, but it’s a close call. The “recession is here” case isn’t disproved, but recent data counter it.

Weekend @CNBCPro column.

cnb.cx/3JyEZb0
Debate can seem binary - between “It’s a doomed bear-market rally, new lows ahead” and “Bear over, up and away.”

Nuance is better: “This rally might not have the horses to break decisively higher right away, but it’d likely take a lot of fresh macro erosion to break June lows.”
Bears anchoring to the 2000-02 phase (shallow recession but nasty reckoning for Corporate America and top-heavy, frothy market). Also, the kind of washout conditions/broad bounce we just saw in June usually lead to a good low but didn’t prove to be decisive in ‘00-‘02 or ‘07-‘09.
Read 4 tweets
Jul 14
The #MysteryBroker checks in to rail incredulously at the Fed's apparent intent to push ahead with more and bigger rate hikes based on "lagging" CPI numbers in the face of clear market and data indicators "signaling a significant decline in inflation over the next year."
The #MysteryBroker says if the Fed hikes 75-100bp in July and another 50-75bp in September, "a recession is very likely to begin by early next year. The stock market would decline 30 to 35% from the all time high in that scenario." Implies an S&P 500 3100-3300 in this bear case.
Still, #MysteryBroker adds that his "base case is that the Fed only raises 75 basis points in July and then either pauses or raises 25 basis points in September as the data clearly reveals lower future inflation rates." Would mean more limited downside risk to equities.
Read 4 tweets
Jul 6
In overnight update, #MysteryBroker criticizes the Fed for trapping itself by focusing on gas prices and UMich inflation expectations just as core inflation is rolling over, but still sees risks to earnings and the economy being generally overstated by observers and the markets.
The #MysteryBroker believes earnings should be more resilient than feared given high nominal GDP growth and disappointments are more about underappreciated impact of China lockdowns and pivot away from home/goods spending than true consumer/business stress.
Current #MysteryBroker take: "The stock market is already discounting a mild recession. Don’t believe we will have anything worse than a moderate recession ahead and there are many good values...The Fed tightening cycle will be much shorter than consensus expects."
Read 5 tweets
May 16
The #MysteryBroker weighs in after Friday's bounce to say it "likely" marked the low for the current phase of the downturn, sees 4-6-week rally totaling 8-15% in S&P 500 based on some rare oversold indicators and persistent bearish sentiment.
The #MysteryBroker notes the extensive history of S&P 500 declines that ended just short of 20% (as I detailed last week - '90, '98, '11, '18), saying the crucial variable that determines if such a drop goes much further is whether a recession hits within months. He thinks not.
The #MysteryBroker says his base case for 2022 has been a low in October (fitting the mid-term election year pattern,) but a chance last week was the low in part because so few believe it and the key bearish factors (rate-hike expectations and inflation) might well have peaked.
Read 6 tweets
Apr 25
The #MysteryBroker checks in: Pessimism has reached extremes (historic lows in AAII survey bulls, equity fund outflows, his proprietary sentiment gauge), limits immediate downside and improves multi-month risk/reward for stocks given imminent-recession fears he sees as overdone.
The #MysteryBroker thinks the market has probably overshot likely Fed rate-hike path, Treasury yields set to peak within two weeks and ease lower for a couple months. He’s among those who think we’re tracking the 1994 bond-crash/Fed-hiking/volatile-stocks scenario.
The #MysteryBroker sees commodity, used-car inflation ebbing, views oil/food inflation as largely neutral for the economy in aggregate. Travel, auto demand strong. Earnings look OK, S&P 500 P/E 18.6x but a more reasonable 16x ex the largest 5 stocks.
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(