Manhattan DA @AlvinBraggNYC is prosecuting a domestic violence victim for murder after campaigning on her innocence.
It's Jose Alba Part 2 without the media frenzy. I was mad about that case. I'm also mad about this one—and you should be, too. My latest🧵 reason.com/2022/09/02/man…
Alvin Bragg specifically ran on dropping the charges against Tracy McCarter, a woman who stabbed her abusive husband after he threatened her life. "I #StandWithTracy," he said. It was "self-defense."
It is difficult to put into words how unprincipled @AlvinBraggNYC has been. He campaigned on "ending mass incarceration."
And now the same prosecutor who publicly called this killing "self-defense" must ensure it is called murder in court. Obscene. reason.com/2022/09/02/man…
Bragg also campaigned on reforming bail. And yet when he won office, he initially tried to prohibit McCarter from leaving NYC to get psychiatric treatment...as a condition of her bail.
This isn't a first: There was Jose Alba. When Bragg dropped those charges, I wrote that not every defendant is lucky to attract such attention from the press.
Well, here we have McCarter, whose misery Bragg used to win office. She deserves your ire too. reason.com/2022/09/02/man…
This is likely about politics. Bragg wants to "end mass incarceration"—for the right people.
He is, after all, a politician. But while McCarter may have been useful on the campaign trail, she is apparently much less so after the fact. /end reason.com/2022/09/02/man…
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Police departments really need to stop making promotional materials out of their cops OD’ing by touching fentanyl, because that’s not scientifically possible.
And media outlets really need to stop recycling those police police press releases, because that’s not journalism.
Last summer I wrote about a San Diego cop who claimed he overdosed by touching fentanyl during a drug bust. "Fentanyl exposure knocks officer off his feet in seconds," was an actual CNN headline.
This isn’t an isolated incident. Here’s a Washington Post story from 2017 that claims an officer in Ohio overdosed from brushing fentanyl off his uniform. It reads like parody. It’s literally not possible. washingtonpost.com/news/morning-m…
I never talk about this. Until I saw 600 experts publicly compare @DrLeanaWen to a supporter of eugenics bc she's come to oppose mandates.
They're doing this in the name of folks like me. I'd like to tell you why they're wrong.
Those 600+ experts want to prohibit Wen from speaking at @PublicHealth's annual meeting. It says a lot about where we're at.
They claim she's "promoted unscientific, unsafe, ableist, fatphobic & unethical practices"...for saying COVID is here to stay. reason.com/2022/08/24/lea…
The head of WHO recently said that Zero COVID is not a viable strategy. This is scientific fact. Yet in this instance it's been deemed so "unscientific" and "unsafe" that it should preclude Wen from speaking in public.
Public health should be about science. Yet it often isn't.
A few months ago, we were told it was virtuous to mock folks who died of COVID, esp if they were vaccine-hesitant.
With Monkeypox, we’re told it’s too far to ask gay men to temporarily desist from promiscuous sex. It says a lot about how we filter everything through identity.
If you spread COVID, you were branded a literal murderer. A moral failure. Why? Because in some sense, even COVID came to be viewed through a lens of privilege.
Those who got it must’ve done something frivolous, as if basic human contact is only needed by a privileged few.
Anyone who met a friend for dinner was a privileged asshole with contempt for the marginalized.
But now a marginalized group is *at the center* of a pandemic. So asking something very basic—to exercise sexual discretion, not abstinence—is unthinkable. It’s so infantilizing.
Manhattan DA Alvin Bragg has dropped the murder charge against Jose Alba. But it never should've been filed.
I wrote about how Bragg's decision to charge Alba—and send him to Rikers—runs contrary to everything he says he stands for. My latest: reason.com/2022/07/19/man…
This is someone who told bodega workers that he was confused by folks "jumping to conclusions" about him prosecuting Alba.
Perhaps it's because you sent a 61-year-old to Rikers, originally sought $500K bond & charged him with murder. It's not a mystery. reason.com/2022/07/19/man…
Put differently, if you run for office pledging to "end mass incarceration" & "reform pretrial detention," and then send an elderly guy to one of the most notorious jails in the U.S. for defending himself, I have a hard time taking you seriously. reason.com/2022/07/19/man…
Lots of problems with this piece, but the biggest is the absurd idea that the 5th Circuit—where Uvalde is located—is eager to award qualified immunity.
The author omits that the Supreme Court recently benchslapped the 5th—twice—for being too *strict.* Let’s look at those cases.
In 2019, the 5th Circuit gave qualified immunity to TX prison guards after they locked him in cells filled with human feces & sewage.
Their reasoning: The *exact amount of time* they locked him in those cells—6 days—had not been outlined in prior caselaw. reason.com/2020/06/25/qua…
The Supreme Court—hardly a left-leaning body right now—called this ruling for what it was: ridiculous, nonsensical, an overly-strict reading of an already-exacting doctrine.
It sounds shocking. But this story is par for the course.
Courts have ruled time and time again that the government is not liable for destroying your property & livelihood if that destruction came as a result of the state using "police powers." OK. reason.com/2022/06/29/thi…