1/ This morning,Tuesday, Sept 13, ’22, on Morning Joe. I heard several thoughtful folks having a political discussion. Often, as someone spoke about what they understood, others would listen and ask for the person to say more.
2/ Also, there was an assumption that everyone was attempting to speak accurately. I learned a bunch of new things about recent events. I changed my mind about some things. My blood pressure didn’t spike.
3/ The participants included Joe Scarborough, David Corn, Eugene Robinson, Adam Kinzinger, and Katy Kay. Black, White, Male, Female, Republican, Democrat, Congressman, reporters, news anchors. Each was intelligent, curious, courteous and committed to learning from one another.
4/ And you know what? It was really enjoyable. It’s fun to listen to intelligent conversation. At first I wondered if the conversation was working so well because they’re all moderates. But that wasn’t it.
5/The goal was not to be in the center of a continuum from left to right. That goal produces boring pablum. The goal was for each person to learn from and to teach one another. And us.
6/There was an absence of something, an absence that allowed the conversation to flow and to produce insight. What was absent was self-righteousness. No one was being the jerk who expects everyone to accede to the truth he or she was announcing.
7/ Self-righteousness throttles community, ends conversations, and imprisons us in loneliness.
8/ Self-righteousness is a major enemy of democracy. If I think that what I believe is right because I, the great and all-knowing self, believe it, then I will try to bend others to my will. Self-righteousness is the engine that drives autocracy.
9/ Here is one of my favorite texts: “Jesus told this parable to those who trusted in themselves, that they were righteous,’Two men went to the temple to pray. The first, a Pharisee, prayed, ‘Lord, I think thee that I am not as other men are - extortioners, unjust, adulterers,..
.10/... or even as this publican. I fast twice in the week, I give tithes of all that I possess.’ And the publican, standing afar off, would not lift up so much as his eyes unto heaven, but smote upon his breast, saying, ‘God, be merciful to me, a sinner.’...
11/... I tell you, [said Jesus] this man went down to his house justified, rather than the other: for everyone that exalts himself will be abased, and he that humbles himself will be exalted.’” (Luke, Chapter 9:10-14)
12/ Since at least 2015, over half of America has been enduring the interminable, exhausting self-exaltation of the Trump-eter-in-Chief, who has transfixed the media and brought into our homes the noxious noise of the orange lout from morning till night.
13/ He who has exalted himself is finally, at long, long last, being brought low. And he who is a common man, whose speech is sometimes halting, but whose gait is still determined, is presiding over our government and working to bring about a more just society.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1/ To all my sisters who awoke this morning, feeling betrayed and insulted -- I stand with you. The court is wrong. The decision expresses a sweeping, reckless misogyny.
2/ The decision is unjust. Should it stand as Alito wrote it, it will rival Dred Scott in its infamy. Indeed it outdoes Dred Scott, for this ruling takes freedom away from the majority of the citizens of the country.
3/ Freedom means, most basically, that I make decisions about what goes on inside my skin. I am not in charge of what goes on inside your skin.
1/Most of us have been watching Vlad the Terrible murder the brave and innocent ordinary people of Ukraine. We are watching an evil man do genocide.
2/Last night we watched as Russia fired on a major nuclear power plant. The danger was the release of nuclear fallout -- ten times greater than the disaster at Chernobyl. Putin is an utter monster, ghoulishly spreading death.
3/We are seeing evil on an epic scale. He is at enmity with God, with the Earth, and with humanity.
1/ Trump in the West, Putin in the East. This is the age of Transactional Man. Our heroes compulsively deal. The more amoral the deal maker, the stronger they appear. They advertise themselves as “strong men.”
2/ The Russian tanks entering Ukraine are an object lesson in toxic masculinity. Freud would have some choice words about those cannons. Some combination of greed and unregistered self-loathing has pushed Putin to Hitlerian depths.
3/ Putin's analysis of his situation is apparently that Russia can’t be secure because it just doesn’t yet have enough land. So now millions of people will lose their freedom and hundreds of thousands may well get killed. Then Vlad will get his mojo back for a little while.
I listened briefly this morning to a tape of Trump in Texas Saturday night. Evil is rising. It’s contagious.
2/ As fascism spreads, evil enfolds first the surly outsiders who become the future tyrant’s goon squads, then the ignorant, then the envious, then the ordinary. It takes years. It suffers defeats and then regroups.
3/This was the pattern for Italy, Germany, Russia, Yugoslavia, China, Romania . . . What begins as folly ends in oceanic suffering. Already the GOP has become morally bankrupt, as its once-honorable membership accedes to Trump’s lies and threats.
1/ “So authentic! So sincere! He’s not a politician! He’s for real!” That’s what 30-40% of the country has been saying about Donald John Trump for the past 6+ years.
2/ I grant that Trump does have a great destructive power. He has single-handedly detonated the moral implosion of the GOP & threatens to end our Democracy. But he is not sincere. He is, as we all can see, a compulsive liar. How then does he carry off the appearance of sincerity?
3/ As usual, the answer lies within the word itself.
1/There’s a marvelous scene in Eric Larson’s "The Splendid and the Vile" when the great Harry Hopkins is preparing to leave England after his prolonged visit with Winston Churchill.
2/The moment was fraught. Hitler was preparing his invasion of Russia, and wanted to finish off England with even more saturation bombing. Roosevelt had promised during his third campaign not to join in the war (Japan had not yet bombed Pearl Harbor).
3/...The rest of Europe was tottering. England stood alone.