Whistleblowing Allegation: Corruption of Green Party Internal Democracy
I have today called for urgent, independent investigation into facts surrounding subversion of will of conference in taking of controversial motion on #DQSH last weekend #GPC22 👇 electshahrar.co.uk/corruption-of-…
As an ordinary member, I write to blow the whistle on evidence of serious wrongdoing in the Green Party of England and Wales and I believe it to be both in the interest of the Party and the wider public interest to do so.
Late motion "Solidarity with DQSH" taken without due authority of conference. There are multiple grounds to believe that this part of a determined effort by some to pass the motion “at all costs”, the chief obstacle to doing so being to make sure that plenary time made for it.
The purpose of this whistleblowing complaint is primarily to ascertain the truth and to safeguard our reputation. It cannot be assessed ahead of establishing the full facts what further reputational damage could be caused to the Party.
There is reputational damage caused by prioritising and seeking to pass a controversial motion on DQSH ahead of what others might consider to be the core business of the party on energy, environment and human rights.
There is also reputational damage caused by appearance of cover-up or collusion in what appears to be a serious breach of trust of members in the conduct of conference; the supreme decision-making body of our Party.
If there has been misconduct or manipulation of party process this goes to heart of our very ability to function as a democratic political party. Only by tackling this head-on that we can restore our credibility, & ultimately our reputation, to claim to be party unlike any other.
In absence of full, independent investigation I believe this motion must be recalled. Other motions were deprived of the time, or opportunity for advancement, that this motion on DQSH was wrongly given, which represents a totally unprecedented breach of trust of our governance.
It is certainly unprecedented in the twenty years I have been active as a member of this esteemed party of ours.
It is with a heavy heart that I must submit this Whistleblowing allegation.
Shooting messenger: It's laughably desperate to claim "sour grapes" on part of those who voted against solidarity DQSH. A revelation came about day after conference that a proposer of late motion on energy that should have been taken next, if it all, had not withdrawn his motion!
That revelation flatly contradicted assertion of a co-chair on Saturday, who just happened also to be lead proposer of DQSH.
First time in 40 conferences I've participated in that such a prioritisation failure has happened.
Imperative we have urgent, independent investigation.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Short thread 🧵on #Mermaids, Aimee Challenor & Green Party. In 2016, Challenor, then prominent in our party, organised an open letter to attack Daily Mail for running a story questioning role of Mermaids in a dispute between parents on social transitioning of their child.
Here's story from Oct 2016: Parents in bitter battle over their child's gender: Father brands controversial transgender charity as ‘meddlers’ in yet ANOTHER case of a mother dressing her son, five, as a girl dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3…
👉 Mother believes boy, five, should wear girl's uniform to school
👉 She was backed on issue by Mermaids who leant on school
👉 Father says his son has simply been confused by his mother dressing him
👉 five-year-old has been dressed as a girl since he was two by mother
Remember grotesque contravention of @bindelj basic freedom of speech by @MyNottingham in June?
"Violence against women and girls:
Nottingham council apologises to Julie Bindel for unlawfully cancelling talk"
Big respect Julie for this win! 💪🏽♀️👏🏽👏⚖️❤️👇🏼 theguardian.com/society/2022/o…
👉 A city council has apologised to veteran feminist and lesbian activist Julie Bindel after cancelling a talk because of “the speaker’s views on transgender rights”.
👉 She ended up speaking in the library car park and at the time said she would be suing the council.
👉 In a statement at the time, it said: “Nottingham is an inclusive city and as a council we support our LGBT community and have committed to supporting trans rights as human rights through Stonewall.”
Green Party has just passed Late motion Solidarity with Drag Queen Story Time/Hour. Couple of excerpts below - from synopsis & one of action points. #DQSH#GPC22
Just to note a few points from debate. I spoke against motion on following grounds
👉 procedurally had not benefitted from full amendments & scrutiny process
👉 motion full of straw men, chiefly conflating far-right critics with others with justifiable concerns
👉 wider context being missed, one in which lifelong feminists such as @bindelj having to take council to court for debarring her from speaking on women's rights in library space. Why weren't we putting motions about this too?
Leaders Q&A have just been asked by member whether they will "unequivocally condemn gender critical belief as transphobic". #gpc22
Adrian's response *by far* most nuanced, opens by saying disnclined to speak in "slogans & soundbites" whilst agreeing with leaders on panel & this wasn't a criticism of them (v diplomatic). Then moves on to reference @thecassreview & to take account of evidence & safeguarding.
Hats off 👏🏼👏🏽 @AdrianRamsay for speaking with nuance & compassion on this topic, whilst recognising needs of interests of all to be respected. Massive breakthrough here on our leadership team for a co-leader to have courage to say this in incredibly hostile environment in party.
Challenging GPEW Deputy Leader Election 2022: Institutionalised Smear Campaigns, Rule Breaches & Hostile Environment 4 Gender Critical ♀️
Unfortunately I feel I must speak out against the legitimacy of the Deputy Leader contest. Part thread. Link to full 👉electshahrar.co.uk/challenge-to-d…
I have raised my concerns with ERO and was told that results would not be announced today (7 Sept 2022) & this would give him extra time to consider my representations & consult with other officials.
I have challenged the result on a number of grounds, including material breaches of rules by candidate who was announced today as winner, Zack Polanski. Best laid plans on announcing a result should not take priority over integrity of our internal democracy.
When asked at deputy leader hustings tonight to name a union figure who inspired me, I chose Emmeline Pankhurst.
I said any of us who truly believed in workers rights to collective action should have been horrified at scenes of intimidation against women at Manchester statue.
I'd expect Greens in public position to call out such behaviour not remain quiet.
If you think party failing to speak truth & justice on women's rights you can elect a deputy to redress that lack - in keeping with our deep green values for freedom of protest & equality for all.
In 1903 Pankhurst founded the Women's Social and Political Union (WSPU), an all-women suffrage advocacy organisation dedicated to