BREAKING: The report into poor maternity care at #EastKent has been published and says it found a clear pattern of poor care leading to 45 baby deaths. Better care could have made a difference in 97 cases examined.
"We have found that the Trust wrongly took comfort from the fact that the great majority of
births in East Kent ended with no damage to either mother or baby"
How often is that the stock phrase by NHS trusts in response to concerns? #EastKent
"The origins of the harm we have identified...lie in failures of teamworking, professionalism, compassion and listening" #EastKent
"We found gross failures of teamworking...a series of problems between the midwives, obstetricians, paediatricians and other professionals...Some staff have acted as if they were responsible for separate fiefdoms, cultivating a culture of tribalism" #EastKent
"We have found divisions among the midwives which at times included bullying to such an extent that the maternity services were not safe" #EastKent
"God only takes the babies that he wants to take"
There can be no place in the NHS for comments like this to a mother whose baby has just died. #EastKent
Diabetes? Meh not an issue for these midwives #eastkent
Safety investigations were often conducted narrowly and defensively...a junior obstetrician or midwife was often found who could be blamed #eastkent
#EastKemt "demonstrates the problems that occur when some consultants stubbornly refuse to change unacceptable behaviour"
No shortage of regulators at #EastKent but "the system as a whole failed to identify the shortcomings early enough and clearly enough to ensure real improvement followed."
.@NHSEngland was warned about poor maternity care at #EastKent as early as spring 2013 - these warnings got no traction.
This was a time when NHSE was not interested in safety. Simon Stevens hived it off to a separate body, despite the responsibilities being in legislation.
How maternity scandals are made. Tough questions for the @MidwivesRCM here. Is it a union or a professional body? Are midwives above patient safety?
#EastKent report says individual clinicians are not to blame: "We have concluded that accountability
lies with the successive trust boards & CEOs/Chairs. They had the info that there were serious failings, and they were in a position to act; but they ignored the warning signs"
The @gmcuk was unable to tackle poor consultant behaviour at #EastKent
"We have found, however, that the way in which “normal birth” was spoken about and set out in material for mothers created an expectation that it was an ideal that staff and women should strive to achieve." #Eastkent#normalbirth#maternitysafety
Here are the main 4 recommendations made by the #EastKent inquiry to try and prevent similar failures happening again. I am afraid some of these leave me distinctly unimpressed. But Rec 1 and 4 seem best? What do you think twitter?
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
🚨 This weekend The Sunday Times paywall is down, meaning my and my colleagues back catalogue of incredible investigations and stories are FREE to read.
I thought I'd give you 5 stories I think deserve your time: 1/6
You hear a lot about bullying and racism within the NHS - rarely have I come across such a bad case as this at Barts that we published recently...
The Sunday Times is campaigning for victims of the sodium valproate drug disaster to get compensation. Why? Because the children and families are suffering like this: 🔓 3/6 thetimes.com/uk/healthcare/…
💔 Ryan and Emmie should have been watching baby Quinn grow up for the past 3 years. Instead, they've had to battle the NHS and its regulator to get the truth for Quinn who died at Nottingham Hospitals from care so bad it has been judged criminal: thetimes.com/uk/healthcare/…
Nottingham University Hospitals Trust was fined £1.67 million in a rare criminal prosecution by the CQC last week over Quinn's death and 2 other babies. But its first response to the couple's detailed 10-page dossier of evidence was a brutal 2 sentence email:
Quinn died after being starved of oxygen because his mother had a placental abruption - staff didn't give them safety advice, call logs went missing and medical records were incorrect. The trust was described as obstructive by the coroner. It admitted liability only last year.
🚨 INVESTIGATION: 1,540 children across England have been misdiagnosed by NHS hearing tests. Leaked @NHSEngland documents reveal concerns at 90 units. Insiders say NHSE hasn't acted despite evidence of the scale of harm 🧵1/8 thetimes.com/article/e23d4f…
Papers marked 'official sensitive, restricted and confidential' (🤣) detail widespread systemic failings in paediatric audiology testing. 480 children have been moderately or severely harmed, in other words left without hearing aids and at risk of permanent development delays 2/8
Health secretary @wesstreeting was only briefed about the crisis on Friday last week...he told me: "This is an appalling state of affairs...it is outrageous that these failings will have potentially serious developmental consequences for children." 3/8 thetimes.com/article/e23d4f…
🚨 ICYMI in yesterday's print Sunday Times - One of England's largest and high profile NHS trusts @GSTTnhs may need a bail out from @DHSCgovuk to cover day to day spending. It is part of a wider £4.5bn spending crisis sweeping the NHS 🧵 1/7
Hospitals across England have been told to cut costs and consider closing some services. At @GSTTnhs staffing costs needed to be cut by a third in the year ahead, equivalent to £55 million with another £39 million in savings needed from other areas 2/7
If @GSTTnhs can't get control of an underlying £84m deficit it may need a loan from the NHS to cover costs. Info sent to staff below: 3/7
🚨 How did Salford Royal Hospital - dubbed the safest in England - fail to investigate the death of a teenager and allow a dangerous surgeon to continue operating for 7 years, harming dozens of patients?
I've been asking questions for 8 yrs. Let me tell you about it...🧵1/9
In 2007, Catherine O'Connor died after losing 14 litres of blood. An expert review in 2022 said spinal surgeon John Bradley Williamson's “unacceptable and unjustifiable” actions “directly contributed” to her death. Read more here: 2/9 thetimes.co.uk/article/surgeo…
A major report by a barrister brought in to examine Salford Royal's handling of concerns about Williamson was published this week. It details significant governance failures by Salford Royal when Sir David Dalton was CEO 3/9
🚨 INVESTIGATION: Top NHS boss Sir David Dalton was warned about a 'butcher' surgeon in 2014 harming patients. Now his victims want a full recall of patients, backed by a whistleblower doctor who says he knows more have been harmed 🧵1/7 thetimes.co.uk/article/cd69ae…
Spinal surgeon John Bradley Williamson harmed dozens of patients in botched surgery at Salford Royal, Spire Manchester and Manchester Children's Hospital. Injuries includes misplaced spinal screws, catastrophic bleeding, paralysis and disability 2/7
A review of patients over a 5 year period found multiple cases of harm. Now victims say all his patients should be reviewed.
Michelle Nolan takes morphine daily for pain and has been told by Spire her care was sub-standard "People deserve the truth, lives have been ruined" 3/7