So to give you a sense of how full of shit the Russians are, the top left image on the first slide is from a Syrian film production of a movie about the White Helmets faking chemical attacks, stills from which Russia previously used in their propaganda. bellingcat.com/news/mena/2018…
Back in 2018 Russia 1 used production stills from the movie as evidence of the White Helmets faking attacks on civilians. You can find the production stills on the film's own Facebook page facebook.com/99314651083244…
That's 2022 Russian propaganda using stills from a 2018 Syrian anti-White Helmets propaganda film, which Russian media in 2018 used as direct evidence of the White Helmets creating propaganda.
When I said Russia was just rebadging old propaganda from Syria to use in Ukraine I didn't realise they were going to be this on the nose.
This image titled "Creation of Dirty Bomb" with the text "Used materials: uranium 235, plutonium 239" is first appears in a 2014 report on a training exercise and is unrelated to the text on the picture eng.ceti.me/?p=95
If you state you believe Russia's claims you're either an idiot, liar, or both.
The left image in this pair of images from the Russian Ukrainian dirty bomb presentation captioned “Panic amongst citizens and increase in the flow of refugees” is from 9/11. I'm not joking.
I'm glad people are starting to realise that Russia isn't actually good at propaganda, it's just we've just been really dumb in the past, so they've looked smart in comparison.
More lazy propaganda from the Russian presentation:
Russian propagandists can't even be bothered to put any effort into their propaganda anymore, they're just phoning it in. Where's the artistry, the joie de vivre?
But even with this complete lack of effort, their propaganda still gets headlines like this from wire services, and they know it will, because it always works.
At this point, despite making a lot of noise, Russia has presented zero actual evidence to support its claims that Ukraine is making a dirty bomb, just a lazy Powerpoint presentation and Shoigu making some phone calls in a desperate attempt to stay relevant.
Hopefully the only reaction at the UN to their presentation will be everyone walking out before it starts.
More examples of Russia's trash propaganda from this presentation
Ever wonder how Russian cruise missiles find their way into Ukrainian playgrounds, power stations, and apartment buildings? Well thanks to @bellingcat’s @christogrozev wonder no more. It’s time to meet the team behind the targeting of Russian missiles on civilian infrastructure.
Scourge of the Russian intelligence services, Christo Grozev, has spent the last several months piecing together the team responsible for programming Russian cruise missiles launched at targets in Ukraine, frequently hitting civilian infrastructure.
The missile programmers are part of the Russian Armed Forces’ vast Main Computation Centre of the General Staff (GVC), and working with @the_ins_ru and @derspiegel we’ve identified the 33 military engineers involved with cruise missile attacks in Ukraine. bellingcat.com/news/uk-and-eu…
To build on this, my personal belief is most counter-disinformation work fails to address the fundamental issues that lead to the creation of disinformation, and generally misunderstands the source of disinformation in the first place.
The focus is often on outside actors (ie Russia) influencing communities through disinformation, when the reality is its more often communities themselves who create disinformation through their own efforts to counter what they see as disinformation.
That's then amplified by state actors when it suits their needs, so to truly address disinformation we need to understand why those communities create disinformation, and look at how to address that.
The latest reporting from @bellingcat and @LHreports's QAnon analysis platform examines the spread of conspiracy theories among Dutch farmers that fuelled protests that made its way all to Tucker Carlson's show. trouw.nl/verdieping/hoe…
These ideas reached a broad US audience when Tucker Carlson aired them back in July, with Eva Vlaardingerbroek providing the details of the theory to his audience:
As day follows night, Donald Trump even began to mention Dutch farmers following Tucker Carlson's coverage of the events and the theories fuelling them.
His comments about the US reveal his totally reductive world view, the US is the greatest evil in the world therefore anyone he thinks is in opposition to the US must be on the right side. It's incredibly stupid, but not untypical among a certain type of person.
My belief is the root of this is what I like to call "traumatic moral injury", where an individual suffers such a severe moral injury from an event or series of events (often legitimately) they start seeing the entire world through the lens of that injury.
The new United Nations Human Rights report on the situation in Ukraine from Feb 1st to July 31st 2022 is now out ohchr.org/sites/default/…
The report opens with the numbers of deaths and attacks on civilian infrastructure confirmed by the UN investigators, with at least 5,385 persons killed and 7,264 persons injured, and 252 medical facilities, 384 educational facilities and 90 places of worship damaged or destroyed
33 out of 38 civilians released from Russian captivity reported torture and ill-treatment while in detention in interviews with the OHCHR, and 34 additional complaints of torture and ill-treatment were reported to the OHCHR.
Just a bit of clarity on some of the reporting about Prigozhin and him suing people over claiming he's involved with Wagner, which he's now admitted is actually true. First of all, he didn't sue Bellingcat, he sued me personally, and not even for something I had said.
He sued me for the contents of articles linked in tweets I published, including two Bellingcat articles and articles from CNN and Spiegel. He didn't sue Bellingcat, CNN, or Spiegel for what was in the articles, just me for linking to them.
Here's the tweets in question, and thanks to the UK's terrible libel laws it cost tens of thousands of pounds to respond to his case, and that was just from the initial stages. It's only thanks to his lawyers pulling out of the case it didn't cost hundreds of thousands.