Fiona Apple has a story for you. And it’s incredible. Asked me to share.
She's become an avid, trained Court Watcher. Her observations helped people jailed pretrial file a civil rights lawsuit. Then came the retaliation. Shut off her access to court.
A video story in 8 parts:
“Lets talk about courtrooms!” Fiona Apple’s story begins w/ the Constitutional right to open courts. During COVID, courts closed. Silver lining: Virtual Zoom access for public. Anyone could attend court. Hold actors accountable.
Fiona started Court Watching in PG County, MD.
“Welcome to the fucking word, lady!” Part two of Fiona Apple’s story is a basic, necessary civic’s lesson. On what happens in court after arrest. On bail hearings. On how she sees prosecutors berating people for not having $50.
And on how no one in court really follows the law:
Part three of Fiona Apple’s story: She explains the unique, unconstitutional system in PG County, MD. Where judges illegally abdicate their release decision to *local jailers.* And people Fiona’s there to protect are detained *indefinitely.*
This is the subject of the lawsuit:
This is not hyperbole. But the fourth part of Fiona Apple’s story is one of the clearest, most succinct, & powerful explanations of the impact of pretrial detention. Not just on individuals but on families and communities.
"Every time you touch this system, it sticks to you."
Heres where Fiona Apple’s story gets sinister. Fiona & @CourtWatchPG's observations helped a civil rights lawsuit. Then: “What do you think happened when that lawsuit dropped? They took our fucking Zoom access away."
"It really seems like theyre retaliating against us.” Part 5:
Fiona Apple recounts one of the worst impacts of PG County, MD illegally taking Zoom access away & being unable even to hear what’s happening in court: They can’t give public defenders support identifying ppl in desperate need.
They have no idea who is who. Part six:
Fiona Apple: “I don’t know exactly what to do about all this stuff except to keep court watching & spread information.” Fiona Apple is a true one. Cares so deeply about shedding a light.
"I'm just hoping that the audience that receives this is going to care." Part seven:
Fiona Apple, Court Watcher:"Just think all of those people in there having their lives, family, community upended. A ripple effect. Bc theyre forgotten. W/ no help. Being treated like they're not even human. Please care."
"Thank you for listening. And I hope I made some sense."
Here is more information on the lawsuit Fiona Apple's courtroom observations helped support on behalf of so many people being illegally detained in Prince George's County, MD.
What can you do? First: Sign up to Court Watch! Google Court Watch programs in your area. Ones I know: New Orleans, LA, Baltimore, DC, Chicago, NYC. Some are virtual like Court Watch PG. You can Court Watch from anywhere. More help needed now than ever. courtwatchpg.com
More: Prince George's County, MD & the judges who were sued filed a motion to dismiss. I read through the whole thing. They essentially admit everything. But argue that they should be allowed to continue indefinitely detaining people.
Tomorrow is the hearing. Show up if you can
Fiona Apple has a story for you. And it’s incredible. Asked me to share.
She's become an avid, trained Court Watcher. Her observations helped people jailed pretrial file a civil rights lawsuit. Then came the retaliation. Shut off her access to court.
Her whole video story:
Just to be exceptionally clear here: The *community & court watchers in Prince George's County, MD* asked Fiona to share this story. Fiona is deeply committed to support the local movement. Nothing for them, without them. Nothing about them, without them.
This is incredible. Read this angry, privileged screed from PG County's motion to dismiss the civil rights law suit. Disparaging volunteer Court Watchers. "An army of volunteers, untrained in the law, to watch & make ... impassioned complaints ... w/ little or no legal import."
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
In San Francisco now. Visiting in-laws. Beautiful, calm streets. Coffee, brunch. Normalcy. No difference from the last 20 years I’ve been visiting. Not denying crime exists here like anywhere. Or substance/mental health. But what’s needed: Thoughtful responses. Not war on people. twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
A) Your nearly $1 billion police force *is arresting “dealers.” B)The drug war’s been arresting “dealers” for 50 years. Look where it’s gotten SF. C) Most dealers sell to support their own habit. Suffer from substance issues themselves. D) Arrests, prisons exacerbate. Not solve.
A story about a mother *this week.* forced into a cage in Houston, TX. 8 months pregnant. When her water broke guards discarded her on the street. Thankfully advocates were there to get her help. Gave birth that night. “Pro-life.”
Testimony:
The following is testimony of Krish Gundu (@kinsngops). Head of Texas Jail Project (@TxJailProject). Her team saved this mothers life. Gave this testimony w/ moms permission. She would’ve herself but too traumatized. At a hearing to give *more* money to jails.
Trigger warning:
Good afternoon Commissioners & Judge Hidalgo,
My name is Krish Gundu. I am the co-founder & executive director of Texas Jail Project.
But today I am here to speak as a tax paying citizen of this county and Precinct 4.
Proud to sponsor this critical conversation. Law students see tension between abolition & public defense. "Why should we invest in a career that works within a system we want to dismantle?" Among other reasons: Bc people are jailed right now & need fierce advocates to free them.
"Why should we invest in a career that works within a system we want to dismantle?" Among other reasons: Bc 100,000s of people everyday are targeted & violated by police & need fierce advocates to challenge this state violence in court. Public defenders are first line of defense.
"Why should we invest in a career that works within a system we want to dismantle?" Among other reasons: While fighting for individual justice, defenders witness systemic injustices no one else sees, at volume & scale. To expose & fight outside of court to systemically dismantle.
THREAD: When we talk about crime, we tend only to focus on police *arrest data*. “Felony arrest” sounds scary. But what actually happens to those cases? I crunched some numbers.
*In 2021, 86% of all felony charges in NY were ultimately dismissed.* Read on for why this matters.
For context, as a public defender for close to 10 years, I saw how routinely people I represented arrested on a “felony” were overcharged. Near always: Dismissals, pleas to lesser charges, simple infractions.
But people still felt the pain. Rikers, violence, reputational harm.
While outside of court, I heard constant fearmongering over “felony arrests,” I knew that for the most part, “felonies” weren’t serious offenses. And prosecutors did too.
Police/prosecutors “upcharge” to gain bargaining leverage. Nothing to do w/ “public safety.”
A thing I learned as a public defender: First Amendment protection is at its *pinnacle* when protesting police abuse. While important to be aware of illegal police repercussions for this kind of speech, cursing & insults are strongly protected under the U.S. Constitution.
A thing I learned as a public defender: First Amendment protection is at its *pinnacle* when protesting police abuse. While important to be aware of illegal police repercussions for this kind of speech, cursing & insults are strongly protected under the U.S. Constitution.
A thing I learned as a public defender: First Amendment protection is at its *pinnacle* when protesting police abuse. While important to be aware of illegal police repercussions for this kind of speech, cursing & insults are strongly protected under the U.S. Constitution.