If the red wave is more of a splash, the silver lining is that a wave would likely just enable the GOP’s worst tendencies and put it on auto-pilot, guaranteeing ineffective leadership (McCarthy) remains safe 1/
There are reasons to celebrate, like Florida, Ohio, etc. However, the GOP didn’t have a national governing agenda. McCarthy’s big sell was tinkering with social security and other programs. GOP leadership was talking to Democrats about getting more money for Ukraine in Jan. 2/
People like Vance won because they were good candidates with good messaging who also didn’t back off on hard issues 3/
I am not an accelerationist by any stretch of the imagination
But if the GOP underperforms nationally when it should have a slam dunk across the board, that calls into question incumbent leadership -- and that is a very good thing in the long run 4/
Who actually thinks the GOP earned a red wave? What was the GOP's national message? What was its vision? Again, McCarthy and McConnell just promised more of the same while highlighting Biden's failures. But that is a *negative* agenda, not a path forward 5/
Imagine all this, and making your platform slashing Medicare
Ultimately I am not dooming on whatever happens. Dooming is lame. If the GOP gets its teeth kicked in during what should be an easy sweep, then that is what needed to happen for something to change 7/
The most self-destructive thing that could happen on the right now would be for the Trump camp and DeSantis camp to fight. There are good people who agree on much in both. The only ones who would benefit from it would be libs and the establishment.
Comes the response: DeSantis is the establishment!
Trump world is filled with Bush people, Evan McMullin stand, and neocons wearing MAGA hats. Every claim you can make against DeSantis in this regard can be made against Trump, which is why it’s moot and pyrrhic.
But Trump started it!
True. But what do you expect? He’s ego-driven. The thing is to not encourage it.
Doom and gloom is understandable and serves a venting purpose but it ultimately needs to end. Republicans bumbled into midterms without a vision and spent millions of dollars undermining decent candidates to protect establishment fiefs.
If you actually think the tide is irreversible and It's So Over and yet continue to participate in the discourse, you're just indulging in a pity party for yourself. You're masturbating to sad music. Stop it.
GOP leadership did a terrible job. They chose to lose. Trump absolutely picked some duds. Neither Trump nor the GOP could come up with a coherent argument except for "Biden bad." Basically the right hardly put up a fight and people are saying it's over. That is absurd.
Remember Jason Steorts, National Review's managing editor, wrote that, on the one hand, he's never been convinced legislation like the Parental Rights in Education law "are not blunt instruments that will bring about harmful unintended consequences." And on the other hand . . .
. . . according to Steorts, their "promotion has sometimes tended toward bigotry, paradigmatically represented in certain remarks by Governor DeSantis's spokeswoman," at the time Christina Pushaw. nationalreview.com/corner/fight-c…
Some people wanted to pretend culture war issues like transgenderism are dead in the water because they are somehow too far away from the lives of the average person.
That has proven totally false, and @approject and @Schilling1776 have done incredible work on this front.
Wrote this in response to conservatives, mostly at National Review, who clutched their pearls at DeSantis taking on the gr♾️mers—but it applies more broadly. People want culture warriors. Whether that’s Trump or DeSantis or MTG or Kari Lake. chroniclesmagazine.org/columns/theory…
You heard this in 2020, when Karl Rove and co. tried to explain why some Hispanics were shifting right. They said it was because the GOP took a softer tone on immigration, which was false.
Watch the video of the Tejano with a chainsaw ranting about BLM to really understand why.
The abuses of the establishment against Americans have all but guaranteed the rise of a force that will be as bad or worse than what they pretended the first iteration of Trumpism was. It'll be good and necessary when it comes. chroniclesmagazine.org/columns/a-cons…
It's hard to explain what a disaster this is for the establishment. Getting to this point wasn't easy. They had to radicalize the people who are most patriotic about this country and most reverent of its myths, symbols, and founding documents: Middle Americans.
The Trump moment was a repudiation of the status quo through a legitimate democratic process.
By subsequently denying that option to people through force and fraud, the establishment effectively removed a pressure relief valve.
Jack thinks he’s got smart things to say about what counts as “accurate” information.
Jack also suppressed one of the biggest political corruption stories of our time ahead of a presidential election and locked the New York Post out of its account for more than two weeks.
Flashback to March 25, 2021: "At a congressional hearing on misinformation and social media, Dorsey said Twitter made a 'total mistake' by barring users from sharing The Post's bombshell October report about Hunter Biden’s emails."
But in an absolute joke of a decision, the FEC ruled Twitter under Dorsey did not violate federal elections law by suppressing the Hunter Biden story. I guess that's why he feels bold enough to open his mouth now. Maybe we should revisit this at some point.cnbc.com/2021/09/15/twi…