The Cultural Tutor Profile picture
Nov 13, 2022 25 tweets 10 min read Read on X
How old do you think this building is?

Well, it's not as old as you might guess: it was built in 1967.

Here's its story (and why architectural style is always a choice...) Image
It's the great Cloth Hall of Ypres, a town in Belgium, built between 1933 and 1967.

But that doesn't tell the full story, of course. It's actually a stone-for-stone reconstruction of the original Cloth Hall, completed in 1304. Image
The name "cloth hall" comes from the fact that it was simultaneously a warehouse and marketplace for the Flemish cloth industry.

This vast and splendid hall is testament to the wealth of that age, and one of the great achievements of civic Gothic architecture. Image
It was almost totally destroyed during the First World War and left in ruins for a dozen years; then it was decided to rebuild the hall exactly as it had been.

The project started in 1933 and finished in 1967. The hall now hosts a museum and is a UNESCO World Heritage Site. Image
But the Cloth Hall of Ypres is not unusual: there are countless buildings across the world which are reconstructions of an older original.

Like the Alcázar of Toledo, a 16th century fortress destroyed in the Spanish Civil War and rebuilt in the 1950s: ImageImage
Or the innumerable churches and religious buildings across the USSR demolished by the authorities, only to be rebuilt after the fall of the Soviet Union.

Most notably the Cathedral of Christ the Saviour in Moscow, demolished in 1931 and rebuilt in the 1990s. ImageImage
Or St. Michael's Golden-Domed Monastery (left) in Kyiv, Ukraine, which was demolished in the 1930s and also rebuilt during the 1990s.

Though not all were rebuilt: Alexander Nevsky Cathedral (right) in Baku, Azerbaijan, destroyed in the 1930s, has never been rebuilt. ImageImage
Sometimes old buildings were knocked down for the sake of efficiency and later considered as bureaucratic errors.

Such as the 16th century Yongdingmen (Gate of Perpetual Peace) in Beijing, which was destroyed to make room for a road in the 1950s, only to be rebuilt in 2005: ImageImage
Natural disasters or structural problems are also common causes of unintentional demolition.

The part-Medieval, part-Renaissance St Mark's Campanile in Venice collapsed in 1902 when undergoing restoration work.

By 1912 it had been fully rebuilt, almost exactly as it once stood: ImageImage
Or it was simply time itself that led to ruin, as with Trakai Island Castle in Lithuania, first built by Vytautas the Great in the 15th century.

It was rebuilt in interrupted stages throughout the 20th century, finally finished in the 1960s, and now a major tourist attraction. Image
And war, of course, is guilty of much demolition.

There are too many cases to even scratch the surface, but one example is post-WWII Germany, whose cities had been gutted - Dresden more than most.

The Frauenkirche was utterly destroyed in 1945; 60 years later it stood again. Image
There's a difference between *reconstruction* and *restoration*.

All these are examples of reconstruction, where a totally or mostly ruined building is returned to its original appearance, whereas restoration is more like repair.
And there's another side to reconstruction.

Rather than rebuilding immediately (or as soon as circumstances permit) sometimes a structure is rebuilt after centuries...

Such as Shakespeare's Globe in Britain (1997) or Babylon in Iraq (1978). ImageImage
This latter category is more experimental, but the former - of rebuilding recently destroyed structures exactly as they were - is a hot topic.

While the general public almost always approve of such reconstruction, architectural theorists and urban planners are less convinced...
Some are tempted to say that the Cloth Hall, the Frauenkirche, the Alcazar of Toledo and all the rest aren't real buildings, that they're inauthentic copies, merely sentimental.

But what makes a building "real" if not that it simply exists?
Usually propelling this argument is change. Because destruction - intentional or not - is a chance to build something new.

See, most buildings destroyed in WWII weren't reconstructed. Architects and governments had a unique opportunity to - literally - build a new world. Image
But change is not inherently bad. Many forget that cities like Paris were totally overhauled in the 19th century. Its Medieval streets were demolished and replaced with brand new boulevards and houses by Haussmann.

What is old was also once new; styles should and must evolve. Image
See, the deeper point is that people can attach importance to specific buildings or styles.

And what's sentimental about making buildings whose architecture people genuinely like?

It's not always traditional either. Serbia's Avala Tower was destroyed in 1999 and remade in 2010: Image
While Frankfurt's old town was, like so many, destroyed in WWII.

It was initially rebuilt in a modernist fashion, but after lengthy public campaigns it was rebuilt again between 2012 and 2018 according to its prewar appearance.

The people of the city preferred it that way. ImageImage
While the 16th century House of the Blackheads in Riga, also destroyed in WWII, was rebuilt in the 90s partially thanks to public donations: people symbolically paid for a brick to be laid, thus playing a direct role in its reconstruction.

The building was important to them. ImageImage
Perhaps the most interesting thing about these reconstructions is that they were even possible.

Much modern architecture is wonderful - but, as with any style, much of it isn't. Nonetheless, we get the impression that other, older styles just aren't feasible any more.
And yet both of these were built in the 1960s.

One is the Warsaw Old Town, reconstructed after being destroyed in WWII. The other is postwar tower blocks in London.

It's not about which is better - just what is possible. ImageImage
So a better way to view these reconstructions isn't as sentimental or as mere imitations, but as any other 20th century building - just one that happened to be designed differently.

A meaningful choice, as every building is.

(Buda Castle, Hungary) ImageImage
Ultimately, the decision to reconstruct all these buildings tells us something fundamental about architecture.

That buildings often surpass their function entirely and start to *mean* something to the people who live in or around them, regardless of what they are for.
The old towns of Frankfurt and Warsaw, the House of the Blackheads in Riga, St. Mark's Campanile in Venice, the churches and civic buildings of Dresden...

These were symbols for the people of those cities; a part of their identity.

Such is the power of architecture.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with The Cultural Tutor

The Cultural Tutor Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @culturaltutor

Mar 31
The Eiffel Tower was completed 136 years ago today.

It's now a global symbol of France and over 7 million tourists visit it every year.

But people hated the Eiffel Tower at first — they called it humiliating, modern, and "too American"... Image
The Eiffel Tower was started in 1887 and finished two years later, on 31 March 1889.

This was an unprecedented structure and a challenge to engineering unlike anything attempted before.

Upon completion it was 300 metres tall and immediately became the world's tallest building. Image
No structure in history had ever been more than 200 metres tall, let alone 300, and the Eiffel Tower's record wasn't overtaken until the Chrysler Building was finished in 1930.

It still dominates the skyline of Paris nearly a century and a half later. Image
Read 25 tweets
Mar 12
These buildings, from around the world, look like they're either ancient or medieval.

But they were all built in the last few decades... Image
The Ranganathaswamy Temple in Tiruchirappalli, India, has a history going back centuries.

But its tallest gopuram (a form of monumental gateway tower) was only completed in 1987.

You can see the older part at the bottom; its base is several hundred years old. Image
Warsaw, the capital of Poland, was devastated during WWII — and its Old Town was almost completely destroyed.

But, over the course of three decades, it was scrupulously rebuilt, even becoming a UNESCO World Heritage Site in 1980. Image
Read 24 tweets
Mar 9
571 years ago today Amerigo Vespucci was born.

He's the guy the Americas are named after.

But it was basically an accident — and he didn't even know about it... Image
As with the other continents, it isn't completely clear how the Americas got their name.

But the most widely accepted theory is that America was named after the Italian explorer Amerigo Vespucci, who travelled there twice in the late 1490s and early 1500s. Image
This Amerigo Vespucci was born on 9th March 1454 in Florence, northern Italy, the home of the Renaissance.

He knew members of the famous de' Medici Family, and through them ended up working in Seville, southern Spain, where he may have worked with Christopher Columbus. Image
Read 20 tweets
Mar 5
The Brutalist is about an architect who studied at the Bauhaus.

Its protagonist is fictional, but the Bauhaus was real.

What was it? The most influential design school in history.

So, from fonts to furniture, this is how Bauhaus created the aesthetic of the modern world... Image
During the 19th century architecture, art, and design were all about the past.

This was the age of Revivalism — everything was built or designed in historical styles.

And it was also a maximalist age: decoration, detail, colour, and ornamentation were in fashion. Image
The first rebellion against Revivalism was Art Nouveau — literally "New Art" in French.

It emerged in Belgium in the 1890s and soon took over the world.

This was a new style not chained to the past, a luxurious aesthetic defined by flowing lines and natural forms. Image
Read 25 tweets
Feb 26
Mont-Saint-Michel in France is one of the most famous places in the world.

You've seen thousands of photos of it... but what is Mont-Saint-Michel? Who built it? And when?

This is a brief history of the world's strangest village... Image
First — where is it?

Mont-Saint-Michel (which is the name of the island, the village, and the abbey) is a tidal island off the coast of Normandy, in northern France.

"Tidal" means that it is surrounded by sea or by land depending on the tides. Image
Legend says that during the 8th century a bishop called Autbert of Avranches had a dream in which the Archangel Saint Michael told him to build a shrine on the island.

The Archangel Michael, who defeated Satan in battle, was a popular saint at the time. Image
Read 25 tweets
Feb 19
This unusual house in Turin was built 123 years ago.

It's the perfect example of a kind of architecture unique to Italy, known as the "Liberty Style".

How to make ordinary buildings more interesting? The Liberty Style has an answer... Image
During the 1890s there was an artistic and architectural revolution in Europe: Art Nouveau.

It means "New Art" in French, and that's exactly what it was — a whole new approach to design, whether of buildings, furniture, clothes, sculpture, or crockery. Image
There were many genres of Art Nouveau, but what they had in common was a commitment to traditional craftsmanship, the embrace of new materials like iron, and a turn toward flowing designs inspired by nature.

Like the Hôtel Tassel in Brussels, designed by Victor Horta, from 1893: Image
Read 24 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(