Had another chat with Faina Savenkova yesterday. She’s a 14 year old girl living in Donbass who’s on the Ukrainian “hit list” Myrotvorets. She’s not famous, like Greta Thunberg. But she should be. She’s an incredible young woman
If you’re not familiar with Myrotvorets it is an online database of “enemies of Ukraine.” It has links with the gov. It publishes the names and addresses of hundreds of children. And marks journalists as liquidated when they are killed.
Faina is the only child on the list who is outspoken. The rest and their families, understandably don’t speak out due to fear of reprisals. Faina is a courageous young woman. She was put on the list because she campaigned for justice in Donbass. She was 12 at the time!
She recently wrote to @amnesty and the @UN. I have a lot of respect for both. But am disappointed they haven’t replied to her. AI recently criticised Ukraine and got hammered for it. Have they now been intimidated to not call out Ukrainian human rights abuses?
I could make a solid argument that a list, publishing the home addresses of children and promoting violence toward them, is the most serious human rights violation in Europe right now… is there much more extreme? and yet people are silent…
One of the reasons for silence, is that anyone who criticises Myrotvorets, in some kind of Kafkeresque nightmare, is themselves put on the list. Like myself and recently Canadian journalist Guy Boulliane.
The list exists to shut down any criticism of the Ukrainian government and extremist elements in the country. Numerous ‘Ukrainians’ have refused video interviews with me because they are on the list and they fear reprisals.
NATO and Ukraine have the power to shut the list down. But they don’t. Why? Because the extremist element in Ukraine is integral to their war against Russia. When a society says it’s ok to promote violence toward children… it opens a dark door that can be difficult to shut.
If this war is about European values, the list must be shut down. Extremism by its very character must be fought and not acquiesced. When a 14 year old girl, whose home address is published by extremists, speaks. And nothing is being done about. We need to listen.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Met up with my translator, Anna, this morning. “How are you?” I asked.
“Oh,” she sighed. “My local school got bombed last night. About 11 o’clock. Pictures fell off my wall it was so close.”
“Is your daughter ok?” Her two year old was sleeping beside her…
“Her body shrieked (convulsed) every time, with the whistles and explosions but she didn’t wake up.”
5 missiles hit the area. There are no military targets nearby.
I can’t get over how f**cking normal conversations like this are in Donestk.
Sorry to be glib, but can NATO please order their ally Ukraine to stop trying to kill Anna and her daughter. She’s a really nice person and is no threat to NATO! I’m sorry but this really pisses me off!
She has a two year old child! And there’s no military purpose
Had a fascinating interview with Marianna Vyshemirsky today in Donbass. She was made famous by the pic of her, pregnant in a Mariupol hospital during Russia’s assault on the city. Her story has been kicked around like a propaganda football ever since. It’s a fascinating story…
After the photo went ‘viral,’ she told western reporters that she didn’t want to do interviews, especially as she had just given birth but they said she needed to comment. She said they left out parts of what she said and misrepresented her.
The Russians then accused her of being a staged actor. She wasn’t. The photos were genuine. The Russians certainly got that wrong! But she criticised the western reporters for not writing what she said, specifically that it wasn’t a Russian airstrike.
Spoke to a pro ukr friend in Kyiv recently on the phone. “Tell me,” he said, “isn’t Donetsk such a poor and ugly place?” Ukrainian propaganda dictates that “separatist” areas are squalid places inhabited by moronic hillbilly types. The truth is rather different… 🧵
Even on Wikipedia there is a list of Ukrainian cities… they all have beautiful pictures…. Except Donetsk. It’s actually funny the length propagandists will go to…
In Kyiv, before the war, people would laugh when they saw a Donbass number plate. Most countries have that region where those “stupid people” with those “funny accents” live. That was Donbass.
Just got back to Donetsk. Had to leave for a few weeks as it’s damn hard working as a journalist here. Looked in the mirror one day and appeared ten years older. Here’s a thread on what’s it’s like working in this beautiful city in wartime…
Every time you step out your apartment you’re worry about getting blown up by Ukrainian shelling. Your heart beat and pace quicken when you pass street corners that were recently hit, with bodies lying on the pavement and shrapnel marks scattering the walls…
Some buildings and streets you circumnavigate because you think they are most likely to be hit next… you never see children in the centre… they’ve all been sent away.
This is Natasha, chief volunteer at the Crimean border. She tells me many of the refugees she’s helped over 8 months, are Ukrainians fleeing mobilisation. They can’t get out through Ukraine, so they come through Crimea. They tell her…
“I don’t want to go to war, as I don’t want to kill my brothers. Yes, this is my land, but I do not undersand what we are fight for.” They say they have families in Russia. And don’t understand why they should go to war when they are all Slavs, if it can be solved peacefully.
She also tells me the stories refugees tell her (of which I have heard many myself) of Ukrainian soldiers killing civilians suspected of being pro Russian. I fear the scale of which could be far worse than we realise.
It’s always difficult to gauge pro rus/pro ukr support in cities in the south and East. Crimea and east donbass are overwhelmingly Russian. Mariupol? Since pro ukrs have fled, it is now overwhelmingly Russian.
Pre invasion? It was very mixed. Both sides would claim a majority. My feelings are that it was a Russian majority. Berdyansk, which is west along the coast, outside donbass may have been ukr majority pre war. These pre war percentages are difficult.