Phil Cunningham Profile picture
Nov 30 19 tweets 11 min read
CCTV FOLLIES 11.30 Another slow news day

Dark attire is first indication that something happened.
It did.
Jiang Zemin is dead.
CCTV can make the protests go away with a magic wand, they can make Jiang's successor and Xi's predecessor disappear from the stage in real time, Image
but how long can they deny this story? Perhaps a short delay in the announcement of Jiang's passing to conjure up a narrative favorable to Xi, but they can't hide it for long. Image
Here he is. A man who helped Xi in his unexpected rise but got no gratitude. Banished like a Buddha on a shelf. Image
The leading organs of the Chinese Communist Party join in making this notice. This goes on for ten unblinking minutes.
What a difference a day makes!
Xi Jinping's image appeared 13 times in the first ten minutes of yesterday's news. It was all about him, and still is, in a way... Image
Next, some (grainy) images of Jiang Zemin during his heyday. This section is laudatory but accounts for only 3 minutes of this special edition of Xinwen Lianbo that runs way over time to 70 minutes.

(otherwise there would hardly be room to show Xi in action and cheer Russia.) ImageImage
The images will evoke nostalgia in many, if only because China is a much more cold, closed and clammy place now.

Scenes of Jiang mixing with the masses, inspecting crop yields and showing solicitude to farmers, while not so different from today's photo ops, show a human touch. ImageImageImageImage
And then there's the industrial sector to play act for.
Helmets on! ImageImageImageImage
And science and other things.

There's lots of posing involved, but Jiang, in contrast to his current successor, was well-educated, urbane, a man of science and spoke several languages fluently.

He could recite the Gettysburg address in English. ImageImageImageImage
He also show a sense of humor, albeit it somewhat corny, and a range of human emotions not obvious in the current paramount leader. ImageImageImageImage
Jiang could be charming, even sweet, at times. Image
And he paid his dues, playing to the camera, inspecting flood zones and the like. ImageImage
He presided over the return of Hong Kong in 1997.
That's Li Peng on his right. ImageImageImage
And he could really ham it up. I saw him speak at Harvard and he was good with the crowd. I shouted out a question about human rights (only to be denied floor by host Ezra Vogel) by Jiang said he had good hearing and tried to respond anyway. Image
He studied electrical engineering in the Soviet Union and presided over opening the controversial Three Gorges Dam, a scheme first dreamed up by Mao and long a pet CCP project. ImageImageImage
He was open to "foreign influences" and pushed hard for modernization, even if it meant diluting the what Xi Jinping calls "the original mission" of the party. ImageImageImageImage
Diplomats found him funny, even "fuzzy." He played the Titanic theme song for a group of American visitors in his home in Zhongnanhai.
Can't picture Xi doing that (though Xi reported likes at least one Hollywood movie--"The Godfather") ImageImageImage
Jiang was the first Chinese leader to readily participate in international summitry. Image
So now, the party under Xi Jinping, perhaps sensing that some people may miss those less stringent days, heaps rote praise upon the deceased former leader in a way that gives Xi the last word. Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Phil Cunningham

Phil Cunningham Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @jinpeili

Dec 2
CCTV FOLLIES 12.02 Jiang Zemin: burying with praise

The first minute of Xinwen Lianbo is promising as it's got some facts about Jiang's childhood and pretty stock pictures. As he gets older, the narration gets more turgid and laden with his increasingly lengthy titles. ImageImageImageImage
He went to high school in Yangzhou and studied at Jiaotong University in Shanghai. He opposed the Japanese invasion and welcomed the CCP liberation of Shanghai. In the 1980's he promoted science and traveled. ImageImageImageImage
The enunciation of slogans soon replaces any meaningful comment about the man's life
The whole "great glorious tribute" seems a power play to bury his memory.
Rote words replace story and it goes on and on

One gets the sinking feeling it will last exactly one hour, and it does Image
Read 12 tweets
Dec 1
CCTV FOLLIES 12.01 Mourning and museums

Gloomy mourning rites for Jiang Zemin (10 minutes)
-Things brighten up at a CCP museum exhibit personally inspired by Xi Jinping
(It's like the Wizard of Oz going from B&W to color.)

-Russian update on Ukraine
-US stealing oil ImageImageImageImage
The camera starts with Xi and his wife and then turns its hierarchy-sensitive gaze to the rest of the masked politburo. What? Xi wearing a mask? Outside in the fresh air?
Symbolism.
He's at one with the mourning elite today. ImageImageImageImage
The Nightly News recounts the drama of Jiang Zemin's body being flown into Beijing. ImageImageImageImage
Read 21 tweets
Nov 30
CCTV FOLLIES 11.30 Xinwen Lianbo, part two

"Jiang was a great Marxist...an outstanding leader of our great cause...an incalculable loss"

"In accordance with China's practice, foreign governments, political parties and friendly personages will not be invited." Image
Xi Jinping (top of the list, large print) heads the honorary funeral committee. This section includes hundreds of names and goes on for a mind-numbing five minutes.

Fun fact: Hu Jintao ranks 36th in the titular hierarchy. ImageImageImageImage
Sometimes CCTV wows its viewers with spectacular images.

Sometimes it bores people out of their minds. ImageImageImageImage
Read 19 tweets
Nov 29
CCTV FOLLIES 11.29 Xi on the top of the world

-Ten year's of success under Xi
-No corner of China untouched by the Xi "touch"
-Covid prevention now even more correct than before
-Xi congratulates Russia-China on energy ties
-Putin does too
-Russia bombs Ukrainian tanks
Another big news day at CCTV, which starts out with an 8-minute segment of scenic canned footage. Some of the footage is stunning, but it's all in service to the party line.
CCTV takes us to a far-away, but not forgotten corner of China where the roads are narrow and winding.
Read 48 tweets
Nov 28
CCTV FOLLIES 11.28 China's clarion call to the world

News opens at Tiananmen. It features scenes of mass gatherings, enthusiastic youth and heroic accomplishments. It will tell a fairy tale about a nation that has rejuvenated itself under the firm guidance of a very wise man.
Today, the big news:
-Xi welcomes the Mongolian president
-Xi has a meeting with the Mongolian president
-The legendary story of how China rejuvenated under Xi
-Russia strikes military targets in Kherson
The audience is about to begin. Mongolia's president is taken to Tiananmen Square. He treads the VIP red carpet to mount the steps into the Great Hall of the People.
Read 56 tweets
Nov 27
CCTV FOLLIES 11/27 What protests?

When the going gets hot, CCTV plays it cool.
As protests proliferate in China's cities, CCTV talks about the weather. Let it snow!
-China economy good
-Snow in north China
-Fewer fairy lights on high streets of England this year. Image
From Shanghai to Beijing, new businesses are doing well ImageImage
Foreign Minister Wang Yi warmly welcomes the new Russian ambassador to Beijing. ImageImageImageImage
Read 18 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(