Anatoly Karlin 🧬⏩ Profile picture
Dec 11, 2022 6 tweets 2 min read Read on X
#decolonization

Chechen separatist leader Dudayev had powerful ideas on Chechnya's (current budget 80-85% dependent on transfers, like Dagestan and Ingushetia) economic prospects after independence. (h/t @shanggyangg). ImageImage
"All the oil hasn't been prospected; even Kuwait doesn't hold a candle to us there. They have no water or forests. We will sell spring water and drink camel milk. Arabia has many camels, we can acclimatize them to Chechnya."

PS. Many Eastern Euro states have statues to this guy.
"Chechen intellectuals will be trained all over the world and will steadily displace the Jews. Jews are a capable nation, but Chechens will dominate through courage. We will become the main intellectual force in the world."

Powerful.
40/100k Chechens in the USSR in 1973 were scientists, relative to 3,200/100k Jews. unz.com/akarlin/soviet…
Irony is in a hypothetical future Russia with no more "Great Power" pretensions, losing DICh (Dagestan/Ingushetia/Chechnya) will actually be a good thing: Savings for the budget, annulment of deleterious overflow effects on institutions, ethnic Russian share of RF goes up a bit.
But it will be bad for DICh themselves. They're much less socially developed even relative to Georgia, Armenia, etc., don't have Azeris' oil, but currently have higher living standards than all of them due to transfers & full access to Russian labor markets.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Anatoly Karlin 🧬⏩

Anatoly Karlin 🧬⏩ Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @powerfultakes

Mar 16
🇷🇺 Russia Elections 2024 Thread

I'll be posting live coverage of interesting developments in the Russian elections here.

(Within a specific definition of "interesting", obviously said term doesn't apply to its outcome).
Result from exit poll at Russian Embassy in Prague (via Max Kats):
* Davankov - 66.5%
* Putin - 4.1%
* Spoiled ballot: 24.8%

Obviously, Prague is not representative of Russia; extremely so. And obviously you'd need to be "bold" to say you voted for Putin in a country where public support for Z is literally criminal. Still, safe to say pocket liberal candidate Davankov sweeps the board in most of the West.

This would be a change from previous elections, in which Putin/United Russia polled competitively against the "liberal" placeholder in 2012, 2016, 2018, etc, winning in most places outside the Anglosphere.
*
*

Russian Embassies abroad tallied the vote fairly in past elections. I wonder whether this will still be true this time round in light of the stupendous tilt against Putin that has unsurprisingly developed after the war. The differentials - 10% (?) for Putin in Western Europe and the US, 80% in Russia - would come off as a bit weird.akarlin.com/prokhorov-pres…
akarlin.com/russian-global…Image
Opinion Polls: A List

Compendium here:

VCIOM:

Putin consistently at 75%, Davankov up to 6%
State owned pollster

FOM:
Putin 80.8%, Kharitonov 5.7%, Slutsky 5.6%, Davankov 4.6% / turnout 69.8%
(This looks remarkably like kremlins' optimal result. Also unlike its standard polls has no demographic breakdowns).
State owned pollster

Levada: Curiously did not actually do a poll on Presidential elections - only on party popularity.
Private pollsters and "foreign agent"

Russian Field: Neither did they! Again, only question on parties.
Private pollster

(This is curious and notable because Levada & Russian Field are the two liberal-leaning opinion pollsters).

ExtremeScan:
New polling outfit, seems very oppositionist.
Putin 63% (down from 69% in Jan, with a notable 5% pt decline right after Navalny's death), Davonkov 4%

IRPZ
Obscure pollster cited by Boris Nadezhdin; of those decided:
Putin 73.1%, Davankov 11.9%, Kharitonov 6.8%, Slutsky 4.2%, spoiled 4.0% / 20% remain undecided

CIPKR
Putin 78-80%, Davankov 5-6%, Kharitonov 6-8%, Slutsky 5-6%, spoil ballot: 1-2%
Never heard of themen.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024_Russ…
wciom.ru/ratings/vybory…
wciom.ru/analytical-rev…
fom.ru/Politika/14991
levada.ru/2024/02/29/rej…
russianfield.com/10days
extremescan.eu/ru
t.me/BorisNadezhdin…
cipkr.ru/2024/03/11/vyb…Image
Image
Read 18 tweets
Feb 17
This is one of the best maps for groking why colonialism could work c.1900 and one of the reasons it became unsustainable later on, and why why Europe's prominence in particular declined relative to both the US & the Rest. Image
France/Britain & US have ~equal population to Latam and Africa, respectively.

Why Turks once viewed Greeks as a real threat, difference when ratio is 1:1.7 vs. 1:6. akarlin.com/turkey-populat…
Conversely, imagine populations of Europeans had they kept their "weight" constant relative to Third World, proxied by say India: 200-300M Germans, Italians, French, English each.

Germany + France > USA. About as many ethnic Russians as Americans. Ofc impact on influence.
Read 6 tweets
Feb 16
NAVALNY DEATH

Initial thoughts:

(1) Almost certainly ordered or okayed by Putin. In retrospect, the theory that Navalny's disappearance in December was a trial balloon to gauge the public reaction - found to be encouragingly lackluster - to harsher measures has been vindicated.Meme h/t @devarbol
(2) The usual amusing preoccupation with symbolic dates, exactly one month before the Presidential elections (to which Navalny represented ~zero threat).
(3) But more amusing still is that Putin did it while poor @TuckerCarlson is performing cartwheels trying to humanize Russia for the American rightoid audience.

Just a never-ending series of humiliations for him - but what's the actual point?!
Read 8 tweets
Jan 14
XI POPULARITY

New study suggests that Xi's approval rating might be inflated by ~25% percentage points.

When asked directly: 95%. (In line with many other surveys showing 90%+).

cambridge.org/core/journals/…Image
But when tested as part of a list experiment, it plummets to 70%! Image
In list surveys there's a control and a treatment group which get a set of non-sensitive questions, but the control group also gets one "controversial" item. The respondents then say how many of the questions they agree with without actually ever answering the controversial one.
Read 7 tweets
Dec 5, 2023
PISA 2022

Results released.

Table of the results summary including the changes (sharply negative in most of the high IQ world) from 2018.oecd.org/pisa/

Image
Link to the report (which I haven't yet looked at it in any detail): oecd-ilibrary.org/docserver/53f2…
Some immediate observations in no particular order:

(1) Notable sharp fall in performance (esp. Math) relative to 2022 (average -2 IQ points in IQ equivalent across the OECD relative to PISA 2018), I assume this is mostly a COVID/lockdowns effect.

(2) Finland is no longer remarkable within Europe.

(3) Türkiye is now above Greece.

(4) Mongolia participated first time, is close to Kazakhstan (Kazakh figures these days would overwhelmingly reflect locals because % Europeans is small and in unremitting decline). Would be much bigger gap with East Asia than the 5 IQ point gap estimated by Lynn.

(5) As in previous surveys, Montenegrins do worse than Serbs. This correlates with personal observations there this year, they did appear to be "slower" than the other Balkan peoples and Turks to me. Side note but it is nice when personal observations coincide with data.

(6) Uzbekistan is very low and around Indonesia/Morocco/Jordan level, nothing surprising there. I was in Morocco this year and TBF while Arab IQ is usually nothing to write home about I was very impressed with their language skills, many of them were genuinely fluent in multiple European languages as well as Arab and Berber. Though I do realize that this is a common situation at crossroads type territories, and picking up some conversational Spanish/English/German to make tourism $$$ isn't super reflective of raw cognitive ability.

(7) Cambodia LOL.

(8) Ukraine performance as expected.

(9) Russian participation in PISA is yet another casualty of the Ukraine War.
Read 4 tweets
Nov 19, 2023
Let's be clear: Le funny memes aside, Milei is a fascist and populist who opposes abortion rights (including for rape) and sex education in schools, promotes COVID conspiracies & anti-vaxxerism, and wants to dismantle Argentine public science institutions. english.elpais.com/international/…

Image
Far Right populism has been in retreat in the advanced Western countries after peaking in the 2010s. But the debased memes it created will continue to afflict the poorer and intellectually marginal areas of the world, with their weaker memetic nervous systems, for years to come.
Early 21C American r*ghtoids are much like mid-19C European socialists.

Created funny temporary "drama" in their centers of origin, have lost their luster.

Will bring vastly greater harm to the immunologically much weaker Third World where they're taken "seriously."
Read 11 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(