Yes, under Utah's new "sensitive materials" law, librarians are being pressured to ban books that include any of a wide range of sexual content, if -- and, this is key -- if the district determines a book has "no serious value for minors."
Here's the list of 44 being banned in Washington County. Many are widely recognized, popular, award-winning literary works. They're being determined to have "no serious value for minors" to appease the vocal activists who want books w/ sex of any kind banned.
To be clear: they're saying The Bluest Eye, The Handmaid's Tale, Forever, Push, Lookin for Alaska -- 44 books -- have absolutely no literary or artistic value for anyone under 18. They're applying a law that aims to bar "indecent or pornographic material" from schools.
Here's the law. Under ordinary circumstances, books in libraries, used on AP exams, major award-winners and nominees, would be seen to have "serious value."
But the law, and the political climate in UT, is leading districts to alter that for books w/ sex that anyone objects to.
Washington County follows Alpine district, which banned 22 books under the same law last month. Other districts are also receiving challenges and being pressured to make similar determinations. kuer.org/education/2022…
UT is just one state in what is quickly becoming a national effort to equate any kind of sex in books as "porn", to suppress their availability to young people. Some want to stretch the definition to apply to any and all LGBTQ books, especially. This is censorship. #FreeTheBooks
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Banned book of the day is "And Tango Makes Three" by Justin Richardson and Peter Parnell.
With its true story of 2 male penguins raising a baby, it's been targeted for years. But we @PENamerica are seeing an uptick in efforts to ban it across FL... #FreeTheBooks
In Lake County. the district banned the book specifically b/c of the "Don't Say Gay" law. Note: the law bans "classroom instruction" on gender and sexuality, not library books. No matter. 🤷♂️ h/t @FLFreedomRead
In Escambia, FL, Tango was one of 100+ books challenged by a teacher, which resulted in it going on backroom shelves for a time and requiring a parental permission slip. The objection? "LGBTQ agenda using penguins", and some key excerpts:
🐧🏳️🌈🐧 pnj.com/story/news/loc…
Well, it happened. Someone banned a Berenstain Bears book...
It's just 1 of a whopping 176 titles that were ordered out of classrooms in a Florida district. The books were part of a large collection to add diverse & inclusive literature to classrooms. They were ordered off shelves in January for extra "review"...
The list is a breathtaking array of books celebrating the diversity of human identities, cultures, traditions -- books historically not available in schools. The collection was banned wholesale in a multi-racial district! Books by 100+ authors incl @Lupita_Nyongo@LindaSuePark
In Escambia, Florida, someone is trying to ban this children's book about Wilma Rudolph, the African-American sprinter who set world records in running and won gold medals at the 1960 Olympics.
What's so "controversial" about it?...
The teacher who filed the complaint-- which led to the book being restricted to back rooms and requiring specific parental permission for a student to even see it -- zeroed in on these 2 pages as allegedly breaking new Florida education laws, incl the Stop WOKE act.
The book is no longer restricted, but still "under review."
This is an encapsulation of the kinds of stories, histories being targeted for banning all over... In fact, someone tried to ban the same book in Prosper ISD, Texas earlier this year 👇👇👇
Book banning is not just people showing up to school boards anymore. 🧵
In numerous states, new fronts are emerging-- state laws instilling fear in schools, or proposals to wholly defund public libraries.
E.g. New law in UT, HB 374, leading to bans 👇 ksl.com/article/505196…
Similar story in MO, with SB 775, that we @PENamerica called attention to last week. Fear of reprisal--and criminal punishment--led to an astonishing array of book bans. We found at least 300 or so, but that's a minimum count. pen.org/spiegelman-atw…
In TN, a state-appointed commission is setting new guidelines for books in schools. The body will soon be able to issue book bans; as any decision on the suitability of any single book in any single school will apply state-wide. So much for local control? tennessean.com/story/news/pol…
In the race for most draconian school district, Keller ISD in TX is leading. They vote tomorrow on a policy that would ban books with "gender fluidity". This is the district that prev. banned The Bible, graphic adap. of Diary of Anne Frank, among others... dallasnews.com/opinion/commen…
The policy would ban books w/ "discussion or depiction" of gender fluidity or which "espouses the view that gender is merely a social construct" from ALL schools. Would surely be interpreted widely against LGBTQ. They want to close minds to the real world.
A school board immediately revokes access to a long list of books in response to a thinly-supported objection, usually from 1 person.
Board members don't:
❎ read the books
❎ follow policies
❎ say how long these removals will last
It's called book banning.
📚📚📚🧵
Boards say all the time books are just 'under review'. That's what a board member said last week in Beaufort, SC, where they've recently removed access to 99 books based on a single complaint.
In Duval in FL, board says 176 books are just "under review"... since January. There was no official challenge. District ordered the books removed from classrooms. The books are about non-white and LGBTQ+ identities. Teachers and students can't use them. bookriot.com/duval-county-p…