1/To find out what's important in aerospace gas turbine design it's best to see what the pros are working on. This is a thread on the Rolls-Royce Ultrafan development engine, and the features that make it special.
Basically, a window into the industry's future.
2/So you know what's coming, we're going to visit the following, from front to back:
1)Gas turbine basics.
2)Composite fan blades & casing.
3)Bypass ratio.
4)Compressors.
5)Lean burn combustion.
6)The power gearbox (a big deal!)
3/Firstly a basic primer.
Turbojets are a Brayton Cycle engine with turbines, hence the 'turbo'. Air is pulled through a compressor, then enters the combustor. A kerosene fuel/ air mix ignites, expands and pushes through the turbine stage, which powers the compressors. A cycle
4/Transmission.
The turbine is typically two stage, and powers two compressor stages. The high pressure turbine powers the high pressure compressor, and the low/ intermediate pressure turbines likewise, through two shafts, one inside the other.
5/Turbofan.
The turbofan adds something new: A bypass stage. A ducted fan, powered by the low pressure turbine, accelerates air around the core but not through it: It's more efficient to push a large volume gently than a small volume roughly. This is almost always useful.
6/3rd shaft.
Uniquely, Rolls-Royce widebody engines employ a 3 shaft configuration, with a 3rd low pressure turbine powering the fan. This is more mechanically complex, and almost bankrupted the company two decades ago, but allows efficient energy management & a modular design
7/The fan: Materials.
RR is late to the game here: GE beat them by a decade to carbon composite fan blades. Not only do they save weight, but they reduce the need for bulky kevlar armour in case of a blade separation (See pic), allowing a composite fan case: Added lightness!
8/The fan: Legacy titanium.
A shoutout, nonetheless, to the hollow diffusion bonded/ superplastic formed titanium fan blades they replace: High pressure nitrogen blown hollow sparred blades. Inflated like a big titanium balloon. Delightful!
9/The fan: Size.
The Ultrafan is aptly named: With a 140" diameter, the fan system is the world's largest. The bypass ratio, or volume of air through the bypass vs the core, is a massive 14:1
For reference, legacy engines have a BPR of 5:1-7:1 and the latest manage 10:1
10/BPR
High BPR means the efficient fan does more of the work, and requires a lower fan pressure ratio to fly the plane, which makes it more efficient still. This is enhanced further when the engine operating pressure ratio, set by the compressor, is very high. Bringing us to..
11/Compression ratio.
For turbomachinery to work at all, the air must be compressed before the combustor.
Because hot air wastes energy, max thermal efficiency demands that after the combustor we expand as much as possible in the turbine, doing useful work.
12/Air hates being compressed. Many stator & rotating stages are needed, because excessive adverse pressure gradients will lead to boundary layer separation, a rotating stall and, potentially, engine surge.
Annoyingly, air also heats as it is compressed, impacting efficiency.
13/But if you can do it with a minimum of losses, your engine benefits.
The direction of progress:
The old workhorse, the Trent 700, had a 38:1 compressor pressure ratio.
The latest T1000, TXWB & T7000 hit 50:1.
The Ultrafan manages an unearthly 70:1! This then enables...
14/Lean combustion.
This is a big compromise. Lean burning (a higher than necessary air:Fuel ratio) encourages cleaner burning, however it also lowers average combustion chamber temperature. Gas turbines get more efficient, not less, with increasing turbine inlet temperature.
15/Lean combustion
However, the adiabatic flame temp of kerosene is 2093C, which is *about* 300-400C higher than the cooled max operating of turbine entry vanes, so there is a narrow band in which lean premixing can help. This band narrows with improved vane cooling & metallurgy
16/Lean premixing.
In the conventional approach, the fuel is injected directly into the combustion chamber along with about 30% of the incoming air. In lean burn, the premixing occurs with the majority of the air volume before entering the combustor and igniting.
17/Lean premixing.
Lean fuel/ air premixing is an exacting science which I cannot do justice. It brings risks of vibration, noise, flameouts... Lean premixing is *hard*, but RR demonstrated it in 2018. More complete combustion, reduced CO2 and reduced NOx is the result.
17/Lean premixing.
Lean fuel/ air premixing is an exacting science which I cannot do justice. It brings risks of vibration, noise, flameouts... Lean premixing is *hard*, but RR demonstrated it in 2018. More complete combustion, reduced CO2 and reduced NOx is the result.
18/The Power Gearbox.
Finally, the Big Dog. Remember the low pressure turbine stage that drives the fan? Well traditionally that is direct-drive, which presents a problem: The ideal rotation speed of a low pressure turbine stage is nowhere close to that of a large fan stage.
19/The ultimate fix: Pratt & Whitney pioneered the geared turbofan in 2008 with the PW1000G, a later variant of which eventually saw service on the A320neo in 2016. Since then the race was on to supersize the technology for the widebody market.
20/The result, the Ultrafan Power Gearbox, is a beast: A planetary gearbox designed to operate at 50MW (or 500 family cars), it's clocked 64MW (87,000 horsepower) in testing. That is legitimately enough to light up a small city.
And it's just for that monster fan stage.
21/And that's an incomplete list of gas turbine focal points.
Not mentioned so far: Metallurgical improvements to blades & casings, turbine & compressor bladed discs, electrification vs direct drive, hybrid electrics and hydrogen burning. All of these & more in due course.
It's the greatest story never told: It's the story of how a frugal county in the North of England invented the modern world.
Put on a flat cap and call up the whippet, because this is a thread about my home county, and the inventions that came out of Yorkshire!
Steel!
Benjamin Huntsman invented high homogeneity crucible steel in Sheffield in the 1740s, firing with coke to fully melt the steel and homogenise the carbon content.
This became used… everywhere, and supercharged the ongoing industrial revolution.
Steam trains.
Steam locomotion had been in development for some decades by 1812, but arguably the world's first commercially successful steam locomotive was Matthew Murray's Salamanca. To him, we owe speed.
A liquid rocket boost stage needs to pump fuel and cryogenic oxidiser to the combustion chamber at a rate that beggars belief: The 33 engines on the boost stage of SpaceX's monstrous ‘Superheavy’ booster each chew through about 700 kg of propellant every second. Put all those engines together and the flow rate of liquid fuel & oxygen would be sufficient to empty an Olympic swimming pool in under 2 minutes, if you could find an Olympic swimming pool for cryogenic propellant.
Can you think of any conventional lightweight pump that can do this? Me neither. You need something special…
The turbopump comprises a typically-axial turbine powered by hot, pressurised gas flow that powers centrifugal compressor pumps that pump the colossal quantities of propellant required and pressurize it to, potentially, hundreds of standard atmospheres.
It's a handy, lightweight way to provide pumping power, but it does require that you have a source of hot, high-pressure gas to work with.
Now, where would you find that in a rocket engine?
Indeed. In order to burn fuel, we must pump it. In order to pump it, we may have to burn some of it.
Um…
The Gas Generator Cycle.
A small quantity of the pressurised fuel & oxidiser flows are tapped, brought to a small combustor, vaporised, ignited then expanded through a turbine that powers the fuel and oxygen compressor cycles.
Inevitably the gas generator can't run with a completely nominal fuel:oxy mix, as it would get so hot that it would melt the turbine blades, so typically a gas generator will trade off some efficiency and run fuel rich to power the turbopumps.
-Why not oxy rich? Because fuel has a higher specific heat at constant pressure (Cp) and so you need less mass flow through the gas generator if it's fuel rich than oxy rich, meaning more useful propellant goes to the main combustor & nozzle that moves the rocket.
So the upside of a gas generator cycle is relative simplicity and robustness, which is why it's used on the most reliable rocket motors around, the SpaceX Merlin. The downside is that you trade away efficiency by throwing away some of your propellant, meaning that the tyranny of the Tsiolkowsky rocket equation will kick you where the sun don't shine.
Staged combustion attempts to address this, by taking either a fuel rich or oxy rich preburner, operating at a much higher flow volume than a standard gas generator, and routing the hot gases that leave the turbine straight to the combustion chamber so that they're not lost. This not only increases the average propellant exhaust velocity (since none of it is lost) and therefore efficiency, but also allows a lower average temperature in the preburner and turbine, since there's a higher volume throughput instead.
On the flipside you must deal with hugely increased engineering complexity, an increased potential for feedback control problems between the different parts of the engine, and also a much higher pressure preburner, since it will still need to deliver high working pressures to the combustion chamber after the losses of the turbine and injectors.
The Soviets got there first, and some of their genius manifested in the Russian RD180 oxy-rich staged combustion engine, which was bought by the Americans and used in Atlas rockets for many years. Its unique oxy-rich staged combustion cycle was efficient but not without drawbacks, as high temperature gaseous oxygen is brutal to exposed metal surfaces, demanding an enamel coating on many parts of the engine.
Last month Rolls-Royce won the UK's small modular reactor competition to develop and build SMRs in the UK. It could be a new dawn for nuclear power.
But who else was in the competition, what was special about each design, and which is your favourite?
An SMR thread…
What's an SMR?
A small modular reactor is a way of beating the brutally high capital costs of building nuclear power: By simplifying assembly (modularity) and minimising subsystem size so almost all of it is factory built you harvest industrial learner effects and low costs.
Boiling water vs pressurised water reactors.
All designs in this list are either PWRs or BWRs, the most common reactor styles today. I've a thread on the basics if you need it, but otherwise on with the show!
In April on a mountain in Chile the Vera Rubin observatory gathered first light, and this telescope will be world-changing! -Not because it can see the furthest… but because it can see the fastest!
The Vera Rubin telescope thread! The value of speed, and unique technology…
Who was Vera Rubin?
She first hypothesized the existence of dark matter, by observing that the rotation speed of the edge of the galaxy did not drop off with radius from the centre as much as it should. The search for dark matter, and other things, will drive this telescope…
Does it see a long way?
Yes, but it’s not optimized for that: The battle of the big mirrors is won by the Extremely Large Telescope which, yes, is meant to see a long way. Vera Rubin is not that big, but that doesn’t matter because it has a different and maybe better mission.
Rotating detonation engines: Riding the shockwave!
A technology that could revolutionise aviation, powering engines with endlessly rotating supersonic shockwaves. It could bring us hypersonic flight, super high efficiency and more.
The detonation engine thread…
Almost all jet engines use deflagration based combustion, not detonation, but while fuel efficiency has been improving for decades, we're well into the phase of decreasing returns and need some game-changing technologies.
One is the rotating detonation engine (RDE).
To understand the appeal of RDEs, you need to know that there are two forms of combustion cycle: Constant pressure, where volume expands with temperature, and constant volume, where pressure goes up instead.
Most jet engines use constant pressure. RDEs use constant volume.
As a new graduate I once had to sit down and draft an engine test program for a subsystem of a new model of Rolls-Royce aero engine. It was illuminating.
So here's a thread on some of the weirder things that this can involve: The jet engine testing thread!
Fan Blade Off!
Easily the most impressive test: A jet engine needs to be able to contain a loose fan blade. In the FBO test, either a full engine or a fan & casing rig in low vacuum is run to full speed, then a blade is pyrotechnically released.
Frozen.
The Manitoba GLACIER site in Northern Canada is home to Rolls-Royce's extreme temperature engine test beds. Not only must these machines be able to start in temperatures where oil turns to syrup, but in-flight ice management is crucial to safe flying.