⚠️ UPDATE — Here is the latest on what we know so far about the death of Princess Bajrakitiyabha on Wednesday and what will happen next. You can also read the post on Facebook: facebook.com/zenjournalist/… 1/26
The latest information from royal sources is that the palace may try to keep her artificially alive on an ECMO machine at Chulalongkorn Hospital for days, maybe even until after New Year, at which point they will turn off the machine and announce she has died. 2/26
They're worried that if New Year festivities are cancelled and the tourism & hospitality industries take another hit at this crucial time of year, after all the pain they suffered during the pandemic, it will further inflame anti-monarchy sentiment which is already rampant. 3/26
In the meantime they will try to stir up royalist sentiment in Thailand by asking people to pray for her, even though everybody in the regime knows she will never recover. 4/26
This ghastly charade has already begun, with Vajiralongkorn visiting Chulalongkorn Hospital four times yesterday, and once today with Suthida. By now a crowd of prostrating royalists has been assembled to chant "Long live the king!" whenever he arrives. 5/26
Prime minister Prayut Chan-ocha and his cabinet have also visited the hospital to give symbolic offerings to a portrait of Bajrakitiyabha and sign a book of condolences. 6/26
The military is orchestrating vast North Korea-style displays of devotion with large groups of uniformed soldiers kneeling to pray for her recovery. Buddhists and Muslims across the kingdom have also been told to pray several times a day. 7/26
This is all just a dishonest charade because Bajrakitiyabha is dead.
Her brain was starved of oxygen for hours. Her heart & lungs are not working. She is being kept technically alive with an ECMO machine, but by any sensible definition she's been dead for two days already 8/26
The only question is how long it will take for the palace and the regime to tell the truth to the people of Thailand. 9/26
Bajrakitiyabha died on Wednesday afternoon during a Royal Thai Army event, the Working Dog Championship contest. CPR was attempted for at least an hour without success as she was taken to Pak Chong Nana Hospital. By the time she arrived at the hospital she was already dead. 10/26
However, because of her royal status, efforts continued at the hospital to try to revive her, even though it was clear that it was hopeless. 11/26
Meanwhile, Vajiralongkorn rushed to the hospital in a military helicopter, and the best intensive care medical helicopter in Thailand, HS-BHQ, was sent to Pak Chong too.
By the time Vajiralongkorn arrived it was clear his daughter was dead, and he broke down and wept. 12/26
But he demanded that efforts must continue to save her and the doctors and medical staff didn't dare disagree. So this went on for hours. 13/26
Eventually a decision was made to bring her back to Bangkok, so in the early hours of Thursday HS-BHQ took off from the hospital in Pak Chong and flew back to Bangkok Hospital, flanked by military helicopters. 14/26
Bajrakitiyabha was then taken to Chulalongkorn Hospital by road, which would have wasted even more time. Chulalongkorn does not have helicopter landing facilities which is why they had to land at Bangkok Hospital then transfer her by road. 15/26
By the time Bajrakitiyabha arrived at Chulalongkorn Hospital she'd had no heartbeat or brain function for more than 10 hours.
Chulalongkorn Hospital doctors didn't dare declare her brain dead until much later on Thursday. 16/26
But because she is being kept artificially alive on an ECMO machine, she is technically not dead, even though there is zero prospect of recovery. 17/26
Doctors initially assumed she had a heart attack, but have now concluded that she suffered a subarachnoid haemorrhage in her skull that then caused her heart to stop beating.
The palace now just has to decide when to take her off the machine and announce her death. 18/26
There is plenty of precedent in the Thai monarchy for delaying announcing a death until the opportune moment.
Bhumibol had been comatose and kept artificially alive for months before the machines were switched off in October 2016. 19/26
His older sister Galyani died during December 2007 but her death was only announced on January 2, 2008, because the regime wanted to avoid disruption to the New Year celebrations. 20/26
In the current political climate, it's very unlikely that the mourning period will be long or strict, it would be madness for the palace or regime to try and inflict a mourning lockdown on the kingdom just as it emerges from covid lockdowns. 21/26
The big issue is New Year because if Bajrakitiyabha's death is announced prior to that the various celebrations around the country will have to cancelled. 22/26
Palace factions are also scrambling to figure out a new succession plan. Dipangkorn has autism and can never reign alone, Sirivannavari is hated and not a credible candidate, so exiled son Vacharaesorn Vivacharawongse may be rehabilitated and become Rama XI when X dies. 23/26
The palace and regime want to delay the announcement of Bajrakitiyabha's death for at least two weeks, but I don't think it will be tenable.
They have been unable to keep her death a secret because I have been reporting it since a few hours after it happened on Wednesday 24/26
The longer they delay telling the truth, the worse they will look when they finally do.
There will also be widespread anger that Thais are being blatantly lied to.
So I hope they reconsider and just let her go. 25/26
Vajiralongkorn is visibly devastated and deserves the right to grieve. But Bajrakitiyabha deserves to die with dignity, not to be kept artificially alive.
Be honest, and let her go. 🙏 26/26
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
⚠️ UPDATE — I have more details from royal and medical sources about what happened to Princess Bajrakitiyabha last Wednesday, and also spoke to a specialist foreign-based ICU and trauma consultant to help interpret the information. 1/
To make this clear once again, I have no personal animosity against the princess, and while everybody knows I am not a fan of King Vajiralongkorn, his grief is clearly genuine and he deserves compassion and understanding right now. 2/13
But the people of Thailand also deserve to be told the truth, instead of being dragged into days or weeks of royalist theatrics to pray for the recovery of a woman who has already been dead for four days according to any sensible definition of what it means to die. 3/13
⚠️UPDATE — Here is what we know so far about the health emergency suffered by Princess Bajrakitiyabha yesterday. While running with her dogs in Khao Yai national park she had a heart attack. She is only 44 years old. 1/9
She was initially taken to Pak Chong Nana Hospital where CPR was attempted for hours without success. Vajiralongkorn rushed to the hospital in a military helicopter. 2/9
A decision was made that the only viable option was to fly her to Bangkok for ECMO treatment, which is a way of keeping people alive when their heart and lungs cannot function en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extracorp… 3/9
A fascinating note written by former prime minister written by former Sanya Dharmasakti in June 1979, while he was head of the Privy Council, details the meddling of Queen Sirikit and the rifts in the palace. 1/14
The note says Sirikit's political meddling was causing severe problems in Thailand and the royal family had become "completely divided". It says King Bhumibol had warned that Sirikit became violent when angry. The situation was getting "getting more serious every day". 2/14
According to the document, Sirikit wanted Bhumibol to abdicate on October 14, 1973, when Thailand's military dictators fled into exile after a student uprising and the country entered a period of democracy. He was persuaded not to abdicate by his advisor Vasit Dejkunjorn. 3/14
How bad are the problems at Thai royal company Siam Bioscience which have derailed Thailand's mass inoculation drive after just a week and caused delays in deliveries to Malaysia, Taiwan and the Philippines (and maybe more countries we don't know about)? Here comes a THREAD 1/15
As is widely known by now, Siam Bioscience is a totally opaque company which has consistently failed to provide even basic information, and the Thai government is routinely lying to cover up problems at Siam Bioscience because they are terrified of offending Vajiralongkorn 2/15
On June 2, Siam Bioscience held a weird ceremony with no journalists invited, presided over by Vajiralongkorn's right-hand man Satitpong Sukvimol with a speech by Princess Sirivannavari's bff Nualphan “Madam Pang” Lamsam, to mark the delivery of the first 1.8 million doses 3/15
My latest #SecretSiam article tells the story of political godfather Newin Chidchob, and it struck me that like a malignant Forrest Gump, he was present at most of the disasters and scandals of recent decades. Here's a THREAD about his shady past secretsiam.news/p/mafia-bosses… 1/16
An early classic episode in Newin's career was when he paid some crooked police to bomb his own house, to try to make him look like a brave whistleblower at risk of being assassinated by his enemies. Professor @bkksnow wrote about it in this paper journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/09… 2/16
In 1995, his vote canvassers were caught with a huge stash of his elections leaflets each with 120 baht stapled to them. The total haul was 11.4 million baht. Newin said he knew nothing about the vote buying antics of his canvassers and escaped charges. 3/16
The @CNN trip to Myanmar was a debacle that produced zero useful information and led to the arrest of at least 11 people whose fate remains unknown. It was a case study in how not to do ethical reporting. Here’s a THREAD about what went wrong 1/24 #WhatsHappeningInMyanmar
I should make clear at the outset that I am a white male journalist and @clarissaward is claiming that criticism of what @CNN did in Myanmar is just coming from sexist male foreigners, so if you think that’s true you can disregard my opinion and ignore this thread. 2/24
Among the most depressing things about the debacle is that CNN & @clarissaward don’t seem interested in learning from mistakes, they are in full damage limitation mode trying to silence criticism so I doubt they will learn any useful lessons about how to do better next time 3/24