Qazaqs know that the world would care little if russia attacked and genocided us, and we still stand with Ukraine. We know that we would share the fate of Chechens, Georgians, Syrians. We still stand with Ukraine.
Ukraine will become EU, we will not, we still stand with Ukraine. Ukranians are Europeans, we are not, we stand with Ukraine. Ukrainians are white, we are vastly not, we stand with Ukraine. Ukrainians are Christian, we are mostly Muslim. We still stand with Ukraine.
“Color” didn’t protect Ukraine from colonialism. russian empire used Ukraine to increase its territory by eradicating Ukrainians either through exterminational policies and assimilation. Same “color” allowed to call them brothers to conceal genocide.
Crucially: Ukrainians stood for Muslim Chechens during their darkest hour, Ukrainians stand for Muslim Crimean Tatars. Ukraine is a colonized and genocided Europe that understands us.
Ukraine is when an elected Jewish leader in a majority Christian country stands for oppressed Muslims.
We don’t want to be victims. We want to be resilient and self-sufficient. We want dignity and equality. Ukrainians teach us how.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Many of us, ex-colonial subjects of the russian empire, had russian friends before the genocide. We didn’t hold grudge for the past. We spoke russian and thought we shared a culture, even if forcefully imposed on us.
For russians, too, went through horrors of stalinism. But during my countless interactions with russians (academics and ordinary people) on the subject, i realized - in addition but also due to colonial differences - we came out from the soviet past with different stories.
Our stories differ: we thoughwe suffered together, but they think that our suffering was necessary to overcome our “backwardness,”their suffering was necessary to “civilize” us. This difference is crucial: we were never equal.
On silence: the great-great- grandfather was sent to Siberian exile for poetry, grandmother was the only family survivor of genocide, grandfather -political prisoner during Stalinism, my parents‘ house was regularly militia raided in late 1980s. I was raised to fear and be silent
Until 1991 I was socialized to feel inferiority because qazaqs were considered inferior in everything to Russians. I felt so and I kept silence.
Silence was my answer to everything: bullying, racism, gender discrimination.
There is an emerging narrative about Russians as helpless victims of a bloody dictatorship, which makes them innocents who should be treated just as genocided Ukranians. This framework rests on an assumption that there is Russian “bad” government and “good” people.
It fails to understand Russian governance system which operates through the practice of “feed and rule” (Tamara Kondrat’eva). Russian governance is conducted through feeding; the loyalty is secured through good life. Moscow is called kormushka, the feeder. Well fed are loyal.
Therefore political imagination and agency is closely associated and tied to consumerism. This is why we had McDonalds and tourist visa outcries, but more silence about the genocide. Does it mean that there is opposition? Yes, small - could grow. Their problem is not only
Michel Friedman, Germany’s famous publicist, son of Holocaust survivors, whose parents were saved by Oskar Schindler, explaned in a recent interview why Schindler was not a hero in Germany after WWII: „there was a collective myth in Germany: I am not guilty, I would have done
something, but what can an individual do against those at the top, they would send me to the concentration camp. Oskar Schindler was a living contra-proof and therefore a big danger
for the legend-making.” He also said that millions kept silent after the WWII, they didn’t out or they didn’t out others. Everyone was complicit and there was a kind of social contract: you keep silence about me and I about you. Silence was Germans’ second guilt.
Today is the remembrance day of the Soviet made hunger in Kazakhstan, which killed up to ca. 40 percent of its population. What unites Kazakhstan and Ukraine is not only borders with Russia, Moscow‘s denial of the two countries‘ statehood, but also
Bolsheviks‘ use of food requisitioning for subjugation, and cultural erasure. Consequence: Kazakhs were an ethnic minority in Soviet Kazakhstan. Speaking and being Kazakh was shameful. Ukraine 2022 sparked cultural emancipation in Kazakhstan, where people learn to appreciate
their language, music, history. Please consider this amateur song remake for the people of Ukraine by ordinary Kazakh people and enjoy the steppe sounds of solidarity instagram.com/tv/CdvtqYEF6rs…