With all the talk about external defibrillation stemming from the #DamarHamlin case, I thought I’d offer a short thread about how it was invented. (1/n)
In 1947, the American surgeon Claude Beck successfully used electrical defibrillation for the first time in an operating room, on a 14yo boy in Cleveland who went into cardiac arrest following a chest operation. (2/n)
The boy survived. Beck later wrote that defibrillation was a tool for saving “hearts too good to die.” (3/n)
The world’s first successful *external* defibrillation for cardiac arrest, the technique used to save Hamlin, occurred at Johns Hopkins in 1957. (4/n)
William Kouwenhoven, a professor of electrical engineering, had worked on external defibrillation for decades, mainly in rats and stray dogs. By 1957, he had assembled a defibrillator in his research lab on the 11th floor of the Johns Hopkins Hospital. (5/n)
That March, a 42yo man arrived in the emergency room at 2 AM complaining of indigestion. He was actually having a heart attack, and while undressing, he collapsed in ventricular fibrillation. (6/n)
The admitting resident, Gottlieb Friesinger, had heard about Kouwenhoven’s defibrillator and raced upstairs to get it while an intern attempted to resuscitate the patient. Friesinger persuaded a security officer to let him into Kouwenhoven’s lab, where he picked up... (7/n)
the hefty device, nearly 200 lbs, and wheeled it to the ER. With one electrode at the top of the breastbone and another just below the nipple, he delivered two shocks to revive the dying man. It was the first successful emergency defibrillation for cardiac arrest. (8/n)
Kouwenhoven’s research produced an unusual and unexpected side benefit. In experiments on dogs, Guy Knickerbocker, a grad student in Kouwenhoven’s lab, noticed that blood pressure rose slightly when defibrillator paddles were pressed into position, even before... (9/n)
any electricity had been administered. Knickerbocker showed that pressing on the chest can compress the heart and cause blood to temporarily circulate, thus increasing blood pressure. His observation set the stage for the introduction of chest compressions during CPR. (10/n)
In a nice twist, the discovery serendipitously benefited Knickerbocker personally. In 1963, his father underwent successful CPR during cardiac arrest after a heart attack. (11/n)
Later, in 1961, a group led by Bernard Lown at Harvard incorporated a timer to synchronize the defibrillator with an EKG to avoid delivering shocks to the heart during the vulnerable period. (12/n)
But external defibrillators were unwieldy, and the shocks they delivered—in the rare cases when patients were still conscious— were painful. Moreover, they relied on bystander administration, hardly infallible during an emergency. (13/n)
Therefore, the goal became to miniaturize, automate, and implant defibrillators inside the human body. That’s a thread for another day. (14/n)
By the way, every hour in the United States, 40 people suffer an out-of-hospital cardiac arrest, as Hamlin did, mostly because of ventricular fibrillation. Fewer than 1 in 10 survive. 90 percent don’t even make it to the hospital alive. (15/n)
Ethnic minorities and lower socioeconomic communities fare the worst, perhaps because of a lack of access to external defibrillators and a lack of education in bystander CPR. (16/n)
During the past several decades, mortality from cardiac arrest has actually decreased, in part because of community-based emergency rescue programs using defibrillators and CPR. (17/n)
People have to be trained in how to use a defibrillator. There should be one available and ready for use in public venues. People should also learn how to administer CPR. It can be the difference between life and death. (18/n)
BTW, if you enjoy this mix of science and history, please check out my new book, My Father’s Brain, coming out April 11. Science and history along with a very personal story. Pre-order if you like. amazon.com/My-Fathers-Bra…
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Since there’s been so much talk about commotio cordis with regard to #DamarHamlin, I figured I’d give a short explainer.
Commotio cordis was discovered by a guy named George Mines who worked in Montreal in the early 1900s. By a cruel twist, it was also the reason he died. (1/n)
Mines determined that there is a narrow period in the cardiac cycle— a “vulnerable period,” he called it, about 10 milliseconds in duration— during which a stimulus—an electrical shock or even a punch to the chest—can cause a perfectly normal heart to fibrillate and stop. (2/n)
To show this, Mines developed an apparatus to deliver single electrical shocks via taps of a Morse key to electrodes placed on a rabbit’s heart. In a number of instances, he found that “a single tap of the Morse key if properly timed would start fibrillation.” (3/n)
There is a vulnerable period in the cardiac cycle. A blow to the chest during this period can cause cardiac arrest. Happens to healthy young athletes every year. It's one of the worst things I've seen as a cardiologist.
If this is what happened to Damar Hamlin, he needed an AED on the field. Chest compressions can help, but what he needed most was a defibrillator.
The condition is called commotio cordis (cardiac contusion).
See: Link, Mark S., et al. “An Experimental Model of Sudden Death Due to Low-
Energy Chest- Wall Impact (Commotio Cordis).” The New England
Journal of Medicine 338, no. 25 (1998): 1805–11.
The morgue was inside Brooks Brothers. I was standing at the open-air triage center at the corner of Church and Dey, right next to the rubble of the World Trade Center, when a policeman shouted that doctors were needed at the men's-wear emporium inside the 1 Liberty building.
Bodies were piling up there, he said, and another makeshift morgue on the other side of the rubble had just closed down. I volunteered and set off down the debris-strewn road.
It was the day after the attack. The smoke and stench of burning plastic was even stronger than on Tuesday. The road was muddy, and because I was stupidly wearing clogs, the mud soaked my socks.
My father died last Friday. His body was cremated today.
A short thread to commemorate a man who meant so much to me.
2/ For a few years now, dementia had taken his memory away. But he always said, “It’s not what you remember, but what others remember about you.” And so, allow me to share a few things I remember about him.
3/ He was a collection of contradictions:
A loner who craved recognition.
A decorated scientist with no small share of prejudices and biases.
I wrote about the hidden toll of the #coronavirus pandemic in an essay in the @wsj. Since it’s behind a paywall, I’ll summarize it below: wsj.com/articles/the-h…
For the past few weeks, hospitals across the world, including hospitals in Detroit, Atlanta, Boston, Milan, Madrid, and my own in New York, have seen massive drops in the number of heart attack cases. 1/
The downturn seems to be true for a range of medical conditions. Case volumes have plummeted for appendicitis, gallbladder infections, obstetric emergencies, and strokes, to name just a few conditions that reliably appear in emergency rooms in non-pandemic times. 2/
1/ As epidemiologists explain about the #coronavirus#COVID2019 (or indeed any epidemic), the rate of spread R = D x O x T x S (explained below). We want to drive R as low as possible so the epidemic will die out. How do we do that?
2/ Some things we can’t control right now, others we can. D is the duration of the infection. Longer someone is infectious, the more spread. If we had a treatment, we could lower D. But we don’t (right now).
3/ S is the susceptibility of the population. Higher the S, the more spread. If we had a vaccine, we could lower S. But we don’t (right now).