The Cultural Tutor Profile picture
Jan 12, 2023 24 tweets 9 min read Read on X
In the 19th century Paris was torn down and totally rebuilt according to the urban plan of just two men.

It might be considered one of the world's most beautiful cities now, but people at the time hated this new version of Paris... Image
King Louis-Philippe of France was overthrown in 1848 and two years later Louis-Napoleon, nephew of the legendary Napoleon Bonaparte, was elected as France's first ever President.

Three years later he would stage a coup and, as Napoleon III, become France's final monarch. Portrait of Napoleon III by Franz Xaver Winterhalter (1855)
Paris had been for centuries, ever since the Dark Ages, one of Europe's foremost cities.

But, by the 19th century and as described most famously in the works of Victor Hugo, Paris had become overcrowded and ravaged by disease - the urban poor were suffering.
So Napoleon III formed a grand ambition to totally rebuild the city.

The first man he appointed as Prefect of Seine to carry out his plans wasn't up to the task. And so Napoleon turned to Georges-Eugène Haussmann...
He was immensely talented, uniquely determined, and possessed an extraordinary ability to overcome any obstacle in his way.

And he shared Napoleon's vision for a new, bright, clean, and beautiful Paris - a city where working people could lead decent lives. As the Emperor said:
Starting in 1853, Haussman was given free rein by Napoleon to redesign and rebuild Paris.

The core of this urban plan was a system of wide boulevards radiating out from the Arc de Triomphe, intercut by streets and squares, bringing light and better transport to the city.
They annexed the suburbs around Paris, increasing the number of arrondissements from 12 to 20 and the city's population from 400,000 to over 1.5 million.

This was an act of urban planning on a scale never seen before.
They demolished over 19,000 buildings, containing 120,000 lodgings or apartments, and replaced them with 34,000 new buildings containing over 215,000 apartments and lodgings.

They also demolished hundreds of streets; this is what a typical Parisian street looked like before:
To be replaced by spacious boulevards and streets. Whereas the older streets had been as little as 5 metres wide, the new were at least 12 metres and 24 in some places.

Nowhere captured better than in Camille Pissarro's four paintings of the Boulevard Montmartre, from the 1890s.
Haussmann also led the construction of brand new sewers, aqueducts, street lighting, and other public infrastructure.

A reminder of his and Napoleon's deep concern for the working classes of Paris and their living conditions.
As part of this vast construction programme many new, large-scale projects were commissioned, including new town halls for the arrondissements.

The Paris Opera House, the Gare du Nord, and the Church of St Augustine are just three other examples.

Paris was utterly transformed.
Napoleon, inspired by London, wanted to fill Paris with public parks.

Haussmann created the Bois de Boulogne in the west, the Bois de Vincennes in the east, the Parc des Buttes-Chaumont in the north, and the Parc Montsouris in the south.

600,000 trees were planted in 17 years. The Bois de BoulogneThe Bois de Vincennes
But the most distinctive feature of Haussmann's city-wide renovation is the so-called Haussmann Building.

He imposed strict regulations about how the newly constructed buildings along Paris' boulevards must look, including their height, width, and architecture.
Haussmann stressed that they must be built or faced with Lutetian limestone, and ordered that they be repaired at least every ten years.

Hence the uniformity of Parisian architecture - along with its distinctive appearance, balconies and all.
What Haussmann wanted was a city in which buildings weren't individual structures but part of a broader, unified whole.

And it's hard to argue that he wasn't successful.
This is the most remarkable thing about Haussmann's renovation - its authoritarian nature.

Taken out of context, the language and rules and totalitarian power of his vast urban reconstruction project sound almost Orwellian.
Le Corbusier himself proposed the Plan Voisin in 1925. It would redevelop a large part of central Paris with 18 identical skyscrapers complete with comprehensive living and working facilities.

Not so different, in its uniformity and absolutism, from Haussmann's plan.
And yet the result of Haussmann's renovation, backed by Napoleon III and totalitarian in nature, is one of the world's most beloved cities - indeed, Paris has been for a long time and remains the world's number one tourist destination.
But contemporaries hated Haussmann's work.

On the one hand there were political rivals who disapproved of the vast expenditure, and many members of the public who bemoaned the endless years of disruptive construction works.
And many more disapproved of the great plan of Napoleon and Haussmann on moral and aesthetic grounds.

They thought the old Medieval charm of Paris was being destroyed, and that their renovation was an act of modern desecration.

As the contemporary philosopher Jules Ferry said:
The later historian René Héron de Villefosse wrote this about what Haussmann did, accusing him of megalomania and bad taste:
Napoleon was forced to sack Haussmann under immense public and political pressure, but others continued his work and in 1927 the final stage of the plan was complete.

And so the Paris of today was born (with the notable addition of the equally disliked Eiffel Tower in 1889).
A century and a half after Haussmann's dismissal such opposition might seem odd, for there seems to be nothing modern about Paris, notably lacking in skyscrapers and dominated by traditional architecture.

People go there for the reasons Haussmann's opponents derided his work.
And so the story of Paris' renovation is instructive for many reasons.

Foremost among them is that, it would seem, a beautiful city *can* be planned. And, further, that everything old or traditional was once startlingly and even scandalously modern.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with The Cultural Tutor

The Cultural Tutor Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @culturaltutor

Dec 23
Who is Santa Claus? Why does he look like that? And where did he come from?

All these questions, answered... Image
The original Santa Claus, so to speak, was Saint Nicholas (270-343 AD).

He was an early Christian bishop born in Myra, modern Turkey, who became famous for working miracles and helping the needy.

In the 5th century AD Emperor Theodosius II built a church in his honour. Image
One story goes that Saint Nicholas saved three young women from being forced into prostitution by dropping bags of gold through the windows of their house so their father could afford a dowry and have them married: Image
Read 23 tweets
Dec 18
The colour of a street's lighting can totally change how that street looks and feels.

But that's only one example of how the smallest details influence architecture and urban design.

So, from sidewalks to chimneys, here are some more... Image
To heat our homes we use air conditioning or central heating — rather than fires — now.

An obvious but easily missed consequence of this change is that houses no longer have chimneys.

This is one reason new houses so often look strange; they just seem to be missing something. Image
Surely the most famous architectural example of details making a difference comes from Classical Architecture.

The Parthenon in Athens, built in the 5th century BC, has dozens of tiny alterations made to improve its appearance.

Like its tapering columns, called "entasis": Image
Read 23 tweets
Dec 16
"Decem" means 10 in Latin — so why is December the 12th month of the year?

It's a story involving Julius Caesar, a lost month called "Intercalaris", and the longest year in history.

But it begins three thousand years ago with Romulus, the mythical founder of Rome... Image
Romulus was the mythical founder of Rome, supposedly descended from Aeneas, who fled from Troy centuries before.

He and his twin brother Remus were raised by a wolf and, eventually, they fought over the founding of a new city.

Romulus killed Remus — and Rome was born. Image
Legend says that (among many other things) Romulus gave the Romans their first ever calendar.

It had ten months, each of 30 or 31 days, and began in March.

These were the names of those months, either named after gods or after their position in the calendar: Image
Read 18 tweets
Dec 14
Over 2,000 years ago there was a philosopher who believed in atoms, speculated about aliens, created a theory of evolution — and even said religion was just superstition.

Here's a brief introduction to Epicureanism, the strangest (and most controversial) ancient philosophy... Image
Epicurus was a philosopher who lived in Athens in the 3rd century BC.

He refined and expanded on existing beliefs until he had created a definitive philosophy of his own: Epicureanism.

Epicurus also set up a school in Athens, where he taught these ideas, known as "the Garden". Image
In the 1st century BC these beliefs were put into an epic poem by a Roman poet called Lucretius.

This poem, called "On the Nature of Things", is sort of like the Epicurean manifesto.

All quotes here are from On the Nature of Things, as translated by AE Stallings in 2007. Image
Read 23 tweets
Dec 9
The Notre-Dame is France's most famous cathedral, but it isn't the biggest or even the best.

So here are some of France's other (and less well known) Gothic wonders... Image
There's plenty of great Gothic Architecture in Britain, Germany, Belgium, the Netherlands, and other countries.

But France is the true home of the Gothic — just look at Tours Cathedral, say.

And after all, France is where the Gothic first emerged in the 12th century. Image
The first major Gothic building was the Basilica of Saint Denis in Paris.

The lower level of arches below, from the 1140s, marks the beginning of Gothic Architecture and the end of Romanesque Architecture, which preceded it. Image
Read 24 tweets
Dec 5
Which or That, explained: Image
If it even matters, one of the subtlest (and most misunderstood) nuances of the English language is the difference between "which" and "that".

They are similar — both are used to introduce additional information in a sentence — but serve different purposes.
Crucial here is the difference between "restrictive clauses" and "non-restrictive clauses".

A restrictive clause is one that adds information necessary to understand the meaning of a sentence.

A non-restrictive clause is one that adds additional but not necessary information.
Read 17 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(