Jean Grey Profile picture
Jan 16, 2023 36 tweets 30 min read Read on X
The Dark Phoenix Saga has been framed as a cautionary tale centered on how, as Lord Acton once wrote, "absolute power corrupts absolutely." However, it is a tragedy that illustrates the cumulative effects of grief, abuse, trauma, dissociation, and addiction. 1/36 #XSpoilers Image
Technically, the "saga" begins after the X-Men battle Magneto, and Jean and Beast believe the rest of their teammates to be dead. Unbeknownst to them, however, the others have been transported to the Savage Land and believe Jean and Beast to be dead. 2/36 ImageImageImage
Jean is grief-stricken by the seeming death of her teammates—her chosen family— which leaves her feeling alone and displaced. Her guilt over not being able to save them causes a surge in her power and she unintentionally reads Xavier's mind. 3/36 ImageImageImageImage
This, coupled with the death of her teammates, causes her great pain and soon after she decides to leave to the school to gather her thoughts and feelings. Her grief is compounded by failing to connect with her friend and former roommate Misty Knight before traveling abroad. 4/36 ImageImage
As an aside: Chris Claremont figures Misty prominently in Jean's personal life, both in-story and in later backstories. She is the first person to whom Jean reveals her feelings of dissociation, fear of her growing power, and that she died before being reborn as Phoenix. 5/36 ImageImageImageImage
Additionally, throughout various scenes and backstories, Claremont hints at the increasingly intoxicating quality of Jean's newfound abilities. At one point, she notes to herself, "My power—it's hitting me like a drug...I've never felt such ecstasy." 6/36 ImageImageImageImage
After Jean vacations abroad for a period, she visits Muir Island to stay with Moira McTaggert, to whom Xavier introduced Jean during her prepubescence, before the X-Men were formed. Jean tells Moira she should have died and buckles under the weight of her guilt and grief. 7/36 ImageImageImageImage
Later, Moira assesses Jean's abilities, and both women express their worry about her capacity to handle her growing power. This prompts Jean to quietly reflect on her life and travels since dying and being reborn as Phoenix. 8/36 ImageImageImageImage
We learn Wyngarde, in the guise of various people, began stalking and quietly grooming her at the height of her grief and is keeping tabs on and increasingly manipulating her. Wyngarde's role as perpetrator in this story is pivotal though, unfortunately, often overlooked. 9/36 ImageImageImageImage
An unsettling backstory that takes place prior to Jean visiting Moira underscores the grooming and abuse to which Wyngarde increasingly subjects her. Claremont wrote this story to spotlight Wyngarde's perpetrations and add context to Jean's later post-traumatic breakdown. 10/36 ImageImageImageImage
Still grappling with grief, guilt, and trauma behind the X-Men's seeming death, Jean is vulnerable to Wyngarde's deceptions. Capitalizing on this, he has her mugged, sequesters her on an island, and introduces himself to her as a handsome, helpful local. 11/36 ImageImageImageImage
Throughout the story, he ingratiates himself with and seduces her. His advances leave her vacillating between feeling cautious, guilty, a sense of total abandon, and, ultimately, terror. "I'm a human being—I'm Jean Grey!" she screams before fleeing from him. 12/36 ImageImageImageImage
Back in the present, It is clear Wyngarde is eroding Jean's inhibitions. Later, his assaults intensify, and he begins gaslighting her with increasing frequency. He transports her psyche to an unfamiliar era and place for the first time, which makes her question her sanity. 13/36 ImageImageImageImage
She barely has time to register that the X-Men are alive before Wyngarde thrusts her into a series of disturbing scenarios in which he tries to trick her into killing a man and convinces her he is her lover. Her shock and despair underscore the cruelty of his abuse. 14/36 ImageImageImageImage
Jean and Scott soon reconnect, though she keeps the "timeslips" she has been experiencing and the distress they cause her to herself. Finally, Wyngarde transports her psyche to their illusory wedding before she surrenders to his illusions, indicating he has worn her down. 15/36 ImageImageImageImage
Later, after feeling Kitty Pryde's "stark terror," Jean kills a group of Hellfire Club henchmen who pursue her. Her empathy-fueled fury perhaps represents her own unconscious lashing out at Wyngarde's abuse. She nearly figures out his scheme but is interrupted by Scott. 16/36 ImageImageImageImage
Before Wyngarde takes complete control of Jean and pushes her to commit her darkest acts, her morality and inhibitions continue to dissipate. She also becomes more indulgent in her power and sexuality, which Wyngarde has undoubtedly encouraged. 17/36 ImageImageImageImage
Finally, Wyngarde's persistent gaslighting and physical perpetrations result in Jean's complete dissociation and transformation into the Black Queen. Ricocheting between grief, terror, and intoxication, she has not had a chance to reflect on and process her experiences. 18/36 ImageImageImageImage
Jean's dissociation is underscored by the fact that she does not recognize her friends, whom she ridicules and attacks, and adopts an ideology and personality not her own. Scott notes, "She's flirting with [all the men]. Mastermind's given her the instincts of a minx." 19/36 ImageImageImageImage
Wyngarde's total control of Jean is further emphasized when Scott discovers that, even when communicating with her through the psionic rapport they share, she does not recognize him. It takes the shock of watching him seemingly killed to gradually awaken and infuriate her. 20/36 ImageImageImageImage
Finally, Jean confronts Wyngarde. One can interpret her saying to him, "You tailor[ed] your illusions to fit my most private fantasies," as indicating he only manifested her desires, but this is an oversimplification of his abuse. First, Jean's thoughts are still clouded. 21/36 ImageImageImage
Second, Wyngarde's degradation of and perpetrations against Jean—and other women—should not be overlooked, considering the pernicious effects such abuse and trauma can have on victims. Far from simply granting Jean her wishes, he forces and grooms her to accept his own. 22/36 ImageImageImageImage
As previously noted, Wyngarde tailored his illusions to fit his and the Hellfire Club's historical antebellum notions, ideology, and aesthetics, not Jean's. Her hunger for love and power, which are base and instinctive human desires, was exacerbated by her grief. 23/36 ImageImageImage
Coupled with the layers of defeat and despondency John Byrne imbues Jean with here, Claremont's dialogue and exposition alert the reader that this is not a woman simply fighting off her desires but reeling from trauma and physical and psychological abuse. 24/36 ImageImage
By the time Jean transforms into Dark Phoenix, the cumulative effects of the grief, intoxication, and violations she has endured overwhelm her. Her rage is symptomatic of a post-traumatic stress breakdown, wherein she lashes out in a fight and flight response for survival. 25/36 Image
Moreover, Phoenix's raison d’être is to create life and destroy what it deems crude, corrosive, or obsolete, which is what Wyngarde's perpetrations were to her. Her turn towards destruction can be interpreted as equal parts instinctive duty, self-defense, and dissociation. 26/36 ImageImageImageImage
"By striking you down, I cut myself free of the last ties binding me to the person I was," Jean says above. Only Ororo intuits her "pain [and] great sadness." Ultimately, Jean's rage and "lust" are borne from her desperation to escape the anguish of being violated. 27/36 Image
Her fury and hunger for an intoxicating relief from despair thrust her into deep space and prompt her to consume a star. Before she realizes it, she unintentionally destroys a star system and planet inhabited by a civilization comprised of billions of living beings. 28/36 ImageImageImageImage
In the clip below (go to 1:50), Claremont clarified that Jean’s destruction of D’Bari was unintentional—“by accident”—and all the more tragic as a result. 29/36

Moreover, Claremont notes that Jean emerged from being "sucked up into this Black Queen personality"—"a cruel, decadent trip"—and was "overwhelmed," "reacting, not acting," and "not sane." He implies she had "diminished capacity," a legal term for psychological distress. 30/36 ImageImage
After Jean unintentionally destroys D’Bari and defends herself from a Shi’ar cruiser that tries to subdue her, she heads to her childhood home. Even in a dissociated state, she craves the comfort and security of her family, but they are frightened of her, which hurts her. 31/36 ImageImageImageImage
As her friends intervene and try to help her, Jean vacillates between rage and despair, much like a victim in the throes of a post-traumatic breakdown or an addict struggling to control their cravings. At one point, she begs Wolverine, “Finish me with your claws.” 32/36 ImageImageImageImage
Finally, with Jean’s help, Xavier subdues her using a “network of psionic circuit breakers,” essentially tranquilizing her. After the Shi’ar capture the X-Men and agree to let them fight for Jean’s life, Jean and Scott reflect on what has happened and is about to transpire. 33/36 ImageImageImageImage
During the battle, Scott is attacked by the Shi’ar, and “the cry of shock and grief and terror that well[s] within [Jean] shatter[s] the psychic restraints.” She begs to be killed, feeling she will never be rid of Dark Phoenix, before fleeing and finally committing suicide. 34/36 ImageImageImageImage
In the end, Jean was stripped of her agency and autonomy, abused and traumatized, transformed into someone and made to do things both foreign and abhorrent to her. She could have lived to become a god, but it was the weight of her pain and the unspeakable that killed her. 35/36 Image
And ultimately, it was Jason Wyngarde and the Hellfire Club's hunger for absolute power that not only corrupted them absolutely but also drove them to violate, corrupt, and shatter a young woman in the prime of her life. 36/36 Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Jean Grey

Jean Grey Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Jean_RED_Grey

Jan 18, 2023
This moment is so impactful and on track for Jean because of her decades long history of looking out for and trying to save Madelyne. #XSpoilers

1/6 Image
After being deceived by Scott, Hank, Bobby, and Warren for months following her return from stasis, and finding out Scott had a wife and child who he’d abandoned for her, Jean admonished him and urged him to go back to them. #XSpoilers

2/6 ImageImage
Later, she sacrificed her soul to Mephisto to save Madelyne and Nate, to relieve Scott of his guilt and so that he could be with his family. Mephisto referred to Jean’s soul as “rare and wondrous” and released her. #XSpoilers

3/6 ImageImageImageImage
Read 6 tweets
May 31, 2022
The Dark Phoenix Saga has been primarily framed as a cautionary tale centered on how, as Lord Anton once wrote, "absolute power corrupts absolutely." However, it is really a story that illustrates the cumulative effects of grief, dissociation, addiction, abuse, and trauma. 1/31
Before the 'Saga' begins, Jean is grief-stricken by the seeming death of her chosen family, which leaves her feeling alone and displaced. Her anguish is compounded when she fails to connect with her friend and former roommate Misty Knight before traveling abroad. 2/31
As an aside: Claremont figures Misty prominently in Jean's personal life, both in-story and in later backstories. She is the first person to whom Jean reveals her feelings of dissociation, fear of her growing power, and that she died before being reborn as Phoenix. 3/31
Read 32 tweets
May 29, 2022
I don't see or feel Sadie Sink as Jean. She has the strange, cold and otherworldly look I associate more with the Stepford Cuckoos. Canonically, Jean is meant to be striking and exude warmth. Cockrum and Byrne modeled Jean after Farrah Fawcett and Raquel Welch, respectively. 1/3 ImageImage
2/3 Check out this article on Dave Cockrum and John Byrne's visual inspirations for Jean as Phoenix.

cbr.com/x-men-phoenix-…
3/3 I've always favored @jes_chastain and have grown intrigued by the possibility of Victoria Pedretti as Jean. ImageImage
Read 4 tweets
May 28, 2022
A dying Jason Wyngarde (Mastermind) sends Jean a letter asking her to visit him. After she, Iceman, and Bishop do, they are transported to a new reality in Wyngarde's mind via an "involuntarily psionic link" he establishes. From Uncanny X-Men Annual #17 (1993):

1/4 ImageImageImageImage
2/4 In this new reality, each team member's dream-turned-nightmare comes true. Jean lives happily with Scott and their children Rachel and Nathan, who later attack and accuse her of being a bad mother. Jean explodes and defends herself with formidable fury. ImageImageImageImage
3/4 She soon realizes that Wyngarde wants to make amends for the abuse he perpetrated against her during the Dark Phoenix Saga. She telekinetically transports an unwilling Bobby and Bishop out of the astral plane and Wyngarde's mind—an unheard of and nearly impossible feat! ImageImageImageImage
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(