You've definitely seen it, but you might not have picked up on it: anti-fatness is everywhere in far-right politics. Unfortunately, there's been very little focus on why that is.
🧵Let's talk about it and start a conversation.🧵
One of my goals with #OHREP has been to look at communities targeted by hate which are too often ignored by researchers in our field. The targeting of fat people very much falls within that focus. It's puzzling, because anti-fatness is actually... very prominent in these spaces.
To give you an idea, our team has collected and analyzed over 2900 memes. Of these, a bit over 30 - or about 1% - directly targeted fat people. Most often, that's done through dehumanizing depictions.
Fat people are depicted as less than human, and their bullying as justified.
Don't just take my word for it: just look at these ultra-popular anti-fat social media pages. One's a Twitter page, the other a subreddit. Both have followings in the six digits. Both post content meant to humiliate, including by screenshots from fat people's dating profiles.
Anti-fatness is popular, in traditional hate movements, and also on the General InterWebs. Why is that? There's a few obvious answers. As someone who got bullied all through high school over my weight, I think I'm not wrong in saying bullies love to target you on that basis.
And that's worth saying: far-right movements are movements built by and for bullies. Their participants are mean-spirited, small people with time on their hands and a desire to hurt others. They don't just bully 'outsiders' either - they bully each other all the time.
But it goes beyond that, in my opinion. Fatness is a disruptor of the strict gender roles and essentialist archetypes that are so central to essentially all far-right ideologies. Women are supposed to be thin and meek, men are supposed to be strong and bold, and so on.
This meme we found on a white nationalist Discord server illustrates that point well. Fat people (as well as women and trans folks) are seen as weak, incapable of fighting or surviving in the dystopian nightmare of a future the far-right wants to bring about.
Fatness is also used in far-right propaganda as a floating signifier for modernity. In their eyes, fat people didn't exist until today (???), and are not people: they're examples of the decay of society.
Notice, in that last image, the discretely anti-'race mixing' messaging. Like in previous images, fat people are often targeted alongside other groups, in propaganda. To me, that illustrates how interwoven anti-fatness is with things like anti-queerness and racism.
To those in my followers who are researchers (especially those lucky few with paid jobs in the field): I think we have to ask ourselves why we haven't been more explicit in discussing anti-fatness as a theme in hate movements. Is it unconscious bias? Is it ignorance?
Is it (as it often is) that we make the choice to ignore it, because there's a deadline, because there's a word limit, because your editor doesn't understand why it matters?
Ultimately, whatever the reason, we're letting people down.
I think that as researchers, it's our job to reconsider our methods, to think about what we're choosing to focus on, and to dedicate our efforts towards addressing gaps in literature.
And right now, I think this is a major gap we need to close.
I'm no expert on anti-fatness/fatphobia, and it's entirely possible I'm getting some things wrong in this thread. If you know a researcher who focuses on these themes (or even better, are one!) please reach out! I'm always looking for opportunities to learn.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Some good news this morning - Gabriel Sohier-Chaput, aka 'Zeiger', writer of 1000s of articles for the neo-Nazi website Daily Stormer, has been found guilty of promoting hatred against Jews.
Antifascists had been worried a different outcome was likely. Rather than consider the whole of Sohier-Chaput's writings, the trial was focused on a single article.
Still, even in this one article, Sohier-Chaput calls for 'Non-stop Nazism, everywhere'.
Sohier-Chaput's defense was mostly about poking holes in the prosecution's narrative. Firstly, he claimed this article was in jest, even comparing his Nazi worldview to Homer Simpson (!!!)
On Hatepedia.ca, we listed the Burger King Crown as a contextual hate symbol, meaning that's it's an otherwise innocent symbol which has been co-opted for hateful uses.
How so? Let's go on a journey together, in a short 🧵
1. In October 2020, a man wearing a Burger King Crown boarded a New York-bound flight and screamed anti-Black and misogynistic slurs at another passenger. The incident was caught on camera. nypost.com/2020/10/23/man…
2. Because of his racist and misogynistic actions (and the far-right's obsession with misogynoir), the man has gone on to become a figure of reverence in far-right online spaces.
The laser eyes are the symbolic equivalent of calling someone 'based' - it's a symbol of praise.
I've been teasing this for months, and it's finally here!
As of this morning, our #OHREP website Hatepedia.ca is finally live. We've been working hard for months (and will keep working hard) to build it into an important resource in the fight against hate in Canada.
On Hatepedia, you'll find a few tools we've created to help people make sense of online hate. Most importantly, you'll find a list of symbols used to promote hate on-(and off)line in Canada.
All symbols were found in actual hateful memes, posted on major social media platforms.
This list includes ones you know about, like the Nazi swastika. It also includes ones you might not have known about, like the Black Sun.
It also includes symbols you weren't aware are hateful, because they've been co-opted by hate movements, like Pit Viper sunglasses.
🧵 1. Part of why it’s important to understand the meaning of hate symbols/memes is that they can often tell you a lot about the person displaying them.
Let’s use this fresh basket of Hell as a case study. (Thanks @BaruchelNDG!)
2. There’s quite a bit going on here, so let’s start with one of the images that comes back a lot here.
This is a clown pepe/honkler. It more or less is used to express the belief that we live in a ‘clown world’. It’s a way of calling their opponents crazy, basically.
3. I know it’s a bit ridiculous, but that clown frog is actually pretty meaningful to these guys. There’s a whole worldview behind it. rightwingwatch.org/post/white-nat…
1. Two days after a close associate of theirs was arrested at the Coutts blockade and gear featuring their logo was seized, members of the Diagolon network are on the defensive, with some claiming the movement is nothing more than a joke. Good time for a 🧵 on irony poisoning!
2. First, some context. Diagolon is a fictional country first envisioned by a group of antisemitic streamers, which spans across North America from Alaska to Florida in a more or less diagonal line. It’s meant to represent jurisdictions with fewer COVID restrictions.
3. The de facto leader of the Diagolon network is Jeremy Mackenzie, a podcaster and self-described ‘sit down comedian’, though his body work could hardly be described as comedy, as @antihateca’s reporting can attest. antihate.ca/jeremy_mackenz…