This well-known image was taken in the Holy Land over 100 years ago. According to postcards it appeared on, it shows an elderly man “examining his great-grandson in a Bible Lesson.”
But who are they?
1/10
The image was used on the cover of “Hasidism: A New History.”
The book says it shows “A Hasid of the Chabad dynasty and his great-grandson in Hebron, 1910–1921.”
2/10
So who is the patriarch in the image?
R. Mordechai Dov Ber Slonim (1840–1919), seen here in another photo, was the son of Menucha Rochel Slonim, who was the granddaughter of the Baal HaTanya (and, incidentally, my great-great-great-great-great-grandmother).
3/10
The portrait was taken by Russian-born Shlomo Narinsky, who immigrated to Jerusalem in 1906 and opened a photography studio.
On that day, he snapped several photos of the Slonim family: A family portrait, a photo of RMDBS himself, and the one of him and his great-grandson.
4/10
The famous family portrait shows four generations of the Slonim family (L-R):
Yaakov Yosef Moshe, Eliezer Dan, Mordechai Dov Ber, Menachem Mendel Shmuel, Schneur Zalman, and Levi Yitzchak.
5/10
The youngest boy in the photograph, Levi Yitzchak, was the one pictured with his great-grandfather.
He later became a rabbi in South Africa and had two children, Chaya and Meir. Below, Meir visits the Hebron Heritage Museum in 2016.
6/10
Interestingly, the National Library of Israel misidentifies the boy as the older brother, Eliezer Dan, and includes a worksheet relating to his life in the image page at web.nli.org.il/sites/nli/engl…
7/10
Eliezer Dan is known for standing up to the murderous Arab mob in Chevron in 1929.
He was butchered along with his wife and eldest son; the younger one, 1-year-old Shlomo, miraculously survived with just a scar on his forehead, and died in 2014.
8/10
Here are the three Slonim family images, one more time.
9/10
And to own a beautiful piece of this history, check out the awesome artwork by @IlanBlock:
10/10
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
An iconic image: A group of Jewish soldiers in the German Army gather on a frosty Chanukah in 1916 to kindle the menorah and warm themselves by its light. But who is the chaplain in the center?
I believe I have the answer.
I began by looking for pictures of German-Jewish military chaplains, or feldrabbiner (usually Reform clergy).
There weren’t that many, so I figured that the man in the Chanukah picture was bound to have been photographed elsewhere.
Lo and behold, a match:
So who was the intrepid feldrabbiner?
Siegfried Klein was born in Rheydt, Germany, in 1882.
He pursued rabbinic studies at the Hochschule für die Wissenschaft des Judentums in Berlin, and got his PhD at Freiburg on the topic of “Death and Burial in the Tannaitic Era.”
In 2018, Kestenbaum auction house unveiled an oil painting by Josef Edward August von Gillern (1794–1845), a well-known German artist.
They said it was a portrait of the Rav Moshe Sofer (1762–1839) that had been in the possession of a family descended from the Chasam Sofer.
But not everyone agreed.
Some claimed that the man didn't resemble the recognized image of the Chasam Sofer. And a Judaica expert who first attributed the work to von Gillern said there wasn't enough evidence to substantiate the claim that Rav Sofer was the painting's subject.
Samuel Palache (c. 1515–1616) was a merchant, diplomat, and privateer. While he definitely did exist (and lead a remarkable life), he is often heavily romanticized as a "pirate rabbi", often titled "Harav".
But I'll focus on one anecdote.
The story goes that every time he entered a shul, he was asked to shed his weapons belt (based on Shulchan Aruch OC 151:6).
He refused, announcing, "I have vowed not to remove my sword until I have avenged the blood of my brethren from the King and Queen of Spain".
This anecdote is mentioned in Hebrew Wikipedia, as well as articles about him online and in print publications...