Hi there, we're back with @LucyHunterB talking about the Scottish Parliament & women. What the GRR Bill has taught us

#FVFWomensFestival
@LucyHunterB Going to look back over the last year & want to start a conversation. #FVFWomensFestival
@LucyHunterB Audience participation! Hands up if anyone attended proceedings in person (some). Hands up if watched online (lots). Hands up if you spoke to MSPs (lots)

Almost all hands up in the end #FVFWomensFestival
@LucyHunterB MSPs here had an opportunity to reach out to a new audience. Scale of response to consultations. People turning up at rallies etc. Women were watching. MSPs did not behave like anyone was watching #FVFWomensFestival
@LucyHunterB Seemed oblivious that they need to convince anyone. No attempt to engage with a wider audience. Women felt frozen out of process #FVFWomensFestival
@LucyHunterB What did we learn? Parliament's working culture: MSPs with young children begging to ask to know when they were going to be able to go to sort out childcare. Getting laughter. Disable MSPs saying their carers were waiting #FVFWomensFestival
@LucyHunterB Carers are vastly underpaid women. The government backbench jeered. Very unpleasant #FVFWomensFestival
@LucyHunterB Actions speak louder than words. Anyone who jeered parents or those asking about their carers should never be believed that they care about women #FVFWomensFestival
@LucyHunterB Plenty of women who feel they can go into the Scottish parliament who feel they can go in and be heard and their voices will be replayed back but for others they are not made welcome #FVFWomensFestival
@LucyHunterB Those who are paid to interact with the Scottish parliament are made welcome. Women are structurally disadvantaged, women more likely to be engaged through voluntary campaigning than through paid work #FVFWomensFestival
@LucyHunterB Professional cultural around holyrood indirectly discriminates against women #FVFWomensFestival
@LucyHunterB We heard repeatedly women's views dismissed, distorted and misrepresented. "women have an issue with maleness" but we were repeatedly told we had an issue with trans. #FVFWomensFestival
@LucyHunterB We couldn't cut through to the governing coalition, the labour party or the lib dems that our safety or fairness matter. Or that our ability to set boundaries or say no matters #FVFWomensFestival
@LucyHunterB Something has changed in the last month but we have a mountain to climb. The ability for us to set boundaries and say no. We couldn't get into the room with the bill committee. #FVFWomensFestival
@LucyHunterB ^or most of the conservatives #FVFWomensFestival
@LucyHunterB To discover a persons sex matters when it is a risk to the FM's reputation matters is beyond commenting #FVFWomensFestival
@LucyHunterB People attending parliament for the first time expected more dignity, better questions. #FVFWomensFestival
Someone from the audience: Was a political naif, didn't discuss politics when young, receiving an education and edification. Expectation of parliament was high #FVFWomensFestival
5 minutes after arriving was stripped off in a broom cupboard had t-shirt removed and put t-shirt in bag. Expected seriousness of purpose and gravitas. #FVFWomensFestival
Expected a definition of terms! Astounded by how little evidence I heard. Heard self-interest and no credibility. A crashing disappointment. Mealy mouth mantra. Nothing to inspire me to believe they have our interest at heart #FVFWomensFestival
Now @LucyHunterB again: you reorganised your lives to come and thank you. Thank you for everyone who have supported us. TALK TO EACH OTHER #FVFWomensFestival

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Forth Valley Feminists

Forth Valley Feminists Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ForthFeminists

Feb 4
Does a vibrator count as pelvic exercise? @GussieGrips Do orgasms help your pelvic floor. THEY HELP MORE THAN YOUR PELVIC FLOOR. You need cheering up. #FVFWomensFestival
@GussieGrips No science to back it up for sure. But sports science principles? Doing something better than nothing! Do a single person study and see how you crack on #FVFWomensFestival
@GussieGrips If we want boys who grow up not to be "accidentally abusive because they go their sex-ed from porn then maybe we should be teaching them about female pleasure and vibrators. #FVFWomensFestival
Read 5 tweets
Feb 4
Q. for @LucyHunterB are the government holding off strengthening the equality act because of S35.

I think people invest too much in the government having a strategic approach. #FVFWomensFestival
@LucyHunterB I don't think there was a great strategic plan, I don't think they want to amend the equality act. The EHRC have said where we are is fine, small numbers. #FVFWomensFestival
They came in behind scotgov to argue that GRC legal sex would superceded biological, before the Scot GRC change #FVFWomensFestival
Read 4 tweets
Feb 4
With the conversion bill there will be casualties @MagiGibson. Have to try and get more input to it. As a former teacher and as a parent I took my duties very seriously & so did the Scot education system #FVFWomensFestival
@MagiGibson Scot Education system has slipped. You need to have a say, a full say on what happens to your child. Parents in England are taking children out of the schools they're in so the schools won't damage them #FVFWomensFestival
And @GussieGrips is now saying that we already have casualties - child detransitioners. MSPs were in tears listening to their stories.
Read 4 tweets
Feb 4
Q. for Susan Smith @ForWomenScot. Is the press complicit? the Scotsman defamed JK Rowling. This week NS finally asked the tough questions and flip-flopped. #FVFWomensFestival
@ForWomenScot Once you get down to basics its indefensible. Some print media has been good but very little forensic examination on the TV and a lot of people get their news from TV #FVFWomensFestival
@ForWomenScot One of the things about the Tavistock was that it appeared on Newsnight, and then you see it enter into the national consciousness #FVFWomensFestival
Read 5 tweets
Feb 4
Is repealing the GRA the only way to stop this @marstrina No. Men have been trying to simulate women for a very long time, you won't end that. #FVFWomensFestival
@marstrina To overturn a law has to sue. GRA: would be very difficult to conceive of a test case. It was brought in by a fudge. It was to prevent issues with marriage, which is technically made redundant by marriage equality but 20 years is a lot of water under the bridge #FVFWomensFestival
@marstrina Now @PankhurstEM says we absolutely must overturn the GRA. Service providers are terrified that they cannot turn away men because of the GRA. Also, it's a pointless piece of legislation because we will hit back with the Equality act etc. #FVFWomensFestival
Read 7 tweets
Feb 4
Q for @MagiGibson and @Gillian_Philip are you aware pre-school books are pushing GI?

Magi. Yes, I find this very troubling. Should be about incl. but don't need to intro children to these notions. Why are we talking to children about these notions? #FVFWomensFestival
@MagiGibson @Gillian_Philip Children can grow up and play with their pals without us getting at them with all this stuff.

#FVFWomensFestival
@MagiGibson @Gillian_Philip @Gillian_Philip Agreee with Magi, children's books should represent the variety of human experience. But this is a confusing thing for a kid to be told that you can change sex. #FVFWomensFestival
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(