Scott Hechinger Profile picture
Feb 15, 2023 18 tweets 12 min read Read on X
Injustice happens in empty courtrooms. But a growing movement of volunteer court watchers is showing up & documenting what they see. This powerful short film-"The Court Watchers"-tells the story. *Score by Fiona Apple. Narration by Jesse Williams.*

Watch:
"The Court Watchers" film starts w/ Fiona Apple courtwatching. As she has for last 2 years. Virtually in PG County, MD court.

"There are 4 screens in front of me. Lawyers dressed in suits. A judge in a robe. Then a person in an orange jumpsuit. I'm watching a bail hearing." Image
Fiona Apple explains how bail hearings operate. "Within two days of arrest, people are brought before a judge. Who'll decide whether they'll be released or incarcerated in jail while their case proceeds.

These decisions can mean life or death. And they are made within minutes." Image
The story of Court Watch in PG County, MD begins w/ Carmen Johnson. Sitting in court. The lone court watcher.

"Injustice happens in empty courtrooms. I knew I had to be a court watcher. Words that are spoken are only in the air. Words that are recorded remain for all to see." Image
On that first day of court watching, now Director of @courtwatchpg, Carmen Johnson, sat in court for 6 hours, writing and watching. witnessing everyday injustices large and small.

All consequential. Image
The CourtWatch.org film turns to the Constitution. Public court access is a RIGHT.

"The principle of courts open to the public was inscribed in the Constitution by the nation's founders who themselves suffered injustice behind closed doors during British Rule." ImageImageImageImage
The purpose behind the Constitutional right to open courts today is significantly undermined: "The demands of modern life & the face paced legal jargon used in the courtroom, means the public can't truly access what happens in court.

There's no check on unseen injustice. Image
Here's where Court watching comes in as the most important action anyone can take.

"Groups across the country seek to train a legion of volunteers to attend hearings & learn language & process of court. To take notes, amplify injustices they witness, & hold power accountable." Image
Once COVID struck things got even more dire. But in Prince George's County, MD-like other places-people could attend & watch court virtually, making it more accessible."

"Ordinary people from across the country from all across the country started to volunteer w/ @courtwatchpg." Image
Courtwatching is important work. Bond hearings could be a fork in the road. Determining not only one person's future, but:

That of generations that followed. Image
Courtwatching is intentional, process-oriented, & strategic about how information is shared w/ decision makers & the public.

Courtwatching looks like accountability letters to prosecutors & judges, reports & policy memos, data & media advocacy (traditional and social). Impact. ImageImageImageImage
The impact of Courtwatching is & has been profound. Prosecutors & judges are aware of their presence. Accountability letters change behaviors in the courtroom.

Court observations lead to awareness raising, critical civil rights lawsuits, & most importantly, freedom & safety. Image
Courtwatching is a growing national movement. "The Court Watchers" film & CourtWatch.org is the product of a national community of volunteer courtwatchers & courtwatch programs.

The film includes some of their voices: ImageImageImageImage
Fiona Apple is a real one. Courtwatching for 2 years. Speaking out about injustice more than even her music. Lending her talent to create her first ever score for this film.

Yes, most of us know her as a Grammy-award winning singer-songwriter. But she *is* a courtwatcher. Image
Today, the @washingtonpost is out with a major story on this Courtwatching campaign and film, the origin story, the importance of courtwatching, how Fiona Apple got involved as a courtwatcher partner, and this new campaign & video. Read here:washingtonpost.com/dc-md-va/2023/…
Tomorrow – February 16 – join Fiona Apple and Carmen Johnson on Washington Post Live for a conversation about courtwatch and how their work inside of courts furthering transparency and accountability supports public health & safety.

RSVP here: washingtonpost.com/washington-pos…
Take action. What you can do. 1. Please share this film with everyone. 2. Visit CourtWatch.org to learn more & volunteer to learn how to become a courtwatcher. 3. If you have ideas about how to get the word out please email connect@courtwatch.org.
Proud of my org Zealo.us for launching this campaign & film. Huge shout out to @MediaTankFilm & @VariantAdvocacy for directing/producing. @iJesseWilliams for your voice. Fiona Apple for your dedication & music. And, of course, @DrCarmenJohnso1 & @courtwatchpg. ImageImageImageImage

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Scott Hechinger

Scott Hechinger Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ScottHech

May 18
READ: A woman was forced to give birth in Brooklyn criminal court 2 nights ago on a courtroom bench. Shackled. All while courtroom personnel gawked.

And the judge ultimately refused even to dismiss her case--trespassing on her own rooftop. This is "justice" in America. More: Image
Image
Image
Image
As a public defender, I spent hundreds of hours in this exact same courtroom in Brooklyn. Arguing for simple justice. Often being scoffed at for trying.

People in crisis. In pain. Passed out. Shaking in fear. Some barely able to stand. Hands shackled. And yes, pregnant women.
Our job as public defenders was to try to slow things down and snap the courtroom actors out of their hypnotized state of callousness. Pay attention to the person standing next to us as a person.

Not just another number.
Read 5 tweets
Feb 16
If true, the implications of DHS seeking identifying data behind social media accounts that track or criticize ICE go far beyond “speech” and “privacy.”

We’re talking about core constitutional structure — how far the government can go to monitor dissent. Thread:
Start with the obvious: the First Amendment.

Criticizing a federal agency is not a fringe activity. It is protected political speech at the very heart of the Constitution.

Targeting critics is not neutral enforcement. It’s viewpoint-based scrutiny.
But this is also a Fourth Amendment issue.

Bulk requests for names, emails, phone numbers, identifying data tied to online accounts begin to look less like targeted investigation and more like digital fishing expeditions.

That raises serious questions about unreasonable search.
Read 15 tweets
Jan 9
I’ve seen ICE’s exact justification before: turning a moving car into a supposed deadly weapon after the fact. To justify extreme force.

In 2018, as a public defender in Brooklyn, I defended a man charged with attempted assault on that basis.

More:
The officer said he had to “jump out of the way” and could have been killed. Sound familiar?

Fortunately we found surveillance video.

It showed the officer was never in danger—my client pulled away, and as in Minnesota, the officer was safely to the side of the vehicle.
When prosecutors saw the video, they didn’t just dismiss the case.
They indicted the officer for perjury.

He was ultimately convicted and sentenced. Image
Read 7 tweets
Nov 26, 2025
This may be the most important post you read today.

As ICE invades American cities & commits brutal acts of violence, below is a shareable film series written *by immigrants for immigrants* on how to safely defend against ICE.

Feeling helpless? Here’s something you can do to help. Read on:
Protect your neighbors from ICE. Share:

🚨If ICE is outside your door, don’t panic & remember: YOU HAVE RIGHTS. Don’t open the door. Ask to see a warrant. ICE can’t enter w/o one.

All 5 videos. 8 languages. At .

Watch and share: wehaverights.us
Protect your neighbors from ICE. Share:

🚨 Rights don’t just stop at the doorway. If ICE makes their way inside of your home remember: YOU HAVE RIGHTS.

All 5 videos. 8 languages. At .

Watch and share: wehaverights.us
Read 7 tweets
Nov 4, 2025
As a public defender in Brooklyn, I spent years in courtrooms watching lives decided in minutes—with no one watching, listening, or caring. So many voices went unheard.

That’s why Teen Vogue’s politics team mattered so much. And why their loss hurts. 🧵
hollywoodreporter.com/business/busin…
“More police aren’t the answer to rising violence in Chicago.” — Public Defender

This piece called out fear-based policing and asked what safety rooted in care might look like.
teenvogue.com/story/rising-c…
“More police aren’t the answer to rising violence in Chicago.” — Public Defender

This piece called out fear-based policing and asked what safety rooted in care might look like.
teenvogue.com/story/rising-c…
Read 21 tweets
Aug 25, 2025
Trump announced today he's ending “cashless bail” in DC & threatening cities across the country. It’s all based on fear—not facts. I was a public defender for a decade. I work with orgs across the country.

Here’s what’s really true about bail, crime, & safety. 🧵
Everywhere that’s reduced pretrial jailing—even modestly—has seen the same outcome: more safety, more freedom, and massive cost savings. That’s not spin.

It’s data, across wildly different jurisdictions. justjournalism.org/page/bail-refo…
We know why pretrial freedom works: when people are free, they keep jobs, care for families, get meds, access housing, go to treatment. Pretrial incarceration doesn’t solve problems—it creates them.

And freedom doesn’t mean danger. It means opportunity. gatheringforfreedom.org
Read 14 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(