People keep asking when the right will wake up and denounce their worst reactionaries.
It’s not same scale, but progressives have a similar challenge. When will we stop letting our most reactive, anonymous people define us?
2/ I am a progressive. I’m so much of a progressive, I ran for congress on universal health care, working class economics, addressing structural racism, and completely legalized marijuana and sex work.
The difference isn’t in our ideals, it’s in our behavior.
3/ I literally do not know a single person doing actual work on the left that it's at their wits end about the crazies.
I literally do not know a single person doing actual work on the left that doesn't have some degree of trauma from abuse by our own side.
This is not tenable.
4/ Here’s the truth. Your behavior has destroyed the mainstream perception of progressives. We’re not seen as champions of the working class.
We’re seen as a bunch of self-righteous assholes. You are in the business of division, not subtraction, and over the most petty nonsense
5/ Every single person on the left I know with actual power I know is tired of your bullshit. I’m inviting you to grow up.
There is not going to be a moment where you scream and people on the right and center have an epiphany and realize you are right and they are wrong.
6/ If you are serious about change, you have to work for it. The same way every other successful progressive movement in history has worked for it.
You say you want a glorious revolution, but it's the normie Democrats showing up to canvas and phonebank. It's why they win.
7/ Another thing. We need to learn to let things go. Every difference in perspective is not a crisis. We amplify every minor disagreement like it’s a moral failing.
Politics is about addition, not subtraction. We have to work with people who see the world differently.
8/ My hand are not clean on this. I've certainly done my share of reactionary, non-constructive bullshit on Twitter.
But, I also think that gives me credibility to publicly say, "This is not working. We have to do something different."
9/ And here’s why I’m speaking up now.
I think you are vulnerable.
I think people are tired of the drama, the bullshit, the moral indignation over small differences. This is the moment we can have a culture shift if people speak up.
10/
The left has always had to work twice as hard as the right. We have to be twice as strategic, and we’re punished twice as hard for mistakes.
This Twitter activism bullshit is cancer. And I am done being bullied into silence over it.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1/ Just going to put a few things on the public record.
There a deeply unpopular woman representing herself as a feminist on Twitch and YouTube whose behavior is so deranged, I feel an ethical responsibility to publicly say, “This is not feminism. This is narcissism.”
2/ Generally, I don’t go after other women.
But this behavior has included falsely accusing a high profile man of child rape, transphobic tirades, and whole litany of deeply dishonest behavior.
And I told her this on YouTube to her face last night.
3/ When I look at the most popular shows on Twitch/YouTube, I don’t see enough adults with experience in media making reasoned, credible arguments about feminist issues to younger people.
And I think that’s why feminism feels less relevant to some of them. Ergo, when I get… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
1/ A tiny, sad man made a conspiracy theory about my friend @notsoErudite’s graduate education and professional background. The claims were utterly baseless. She claps back hard in this video.
But I want to talk about why this was so wrong.
2/ Was talking to a speech therapist friend of mine. Like @notsoErudite she has an undergrad, a masters and professional expertise to work in a clinic.
And she told me there’s no lie that someone could tell about her that would hurt her more than questioning her education.
3/ And it wasn’t just because she worked hard for her degrees. It was because she cared so much about being taken seriously as a professional.
When you watch a @notsoErudite video, and she mentions a study, she usually links to her sources. She’s VERY open.
When a tactic fails, if you’re serious about winning - you regroup, consider what needs to change and implement it.
I was one of the more vocal people supporting the Hogwarts boycott. I still believe it’s the right thing to do. But I’m increasingly doubtful it helped.
2/ Trans people deserve a world where gamers support the community and the media supported trans dignity. I wish we had that world. We clearly don’t.
We can take time to mourn that, but then we need to figure out what’s next.
Here’s the silver lining.
3/ I’ve never seen the trans community gather as solidly behind a goal before. That is, in itself, a huge win.
So, in my view, we should coalesce behind a new goal and put all our effort into it - like gay men did on gay marriage.
I think the cohort of Porsche people that love those cars is much smaller, and the engineering quality is also much worse - making them more expensive to keep running compared to a 911.
So you have an asset more expensive AND less valuable. Not a great investment.
🧵 Want to engage with you in good faith on this because I agree. Trans-rights legislation should be the primary focus. Let’s think through that argument.
The problem is, there is no real organization in the United States advocating for that.
2/ @HRC has a horrific history on trans issues. I know people that work there, and I’m not trying to insult them. But they are always going to be institution that puts gay men first.
Democratic Party will do lip service on trans issues, but there’s no serious legislative push.
3/ So, where does that leave trans people? Poverty is a serious problem for the community, so they can’t just fund lobbying. They can’t garner favor with legislators.
Basically, a small, highly vulnerable population is left with no real tools to fight for itself.
Superficially, Luke Skywalker and Harry Potter have a lot in common. Both are born special. Both are thrust into generational conflict. Both have abusive families. Both are self-inserts.
But, Star Wars and Harry Potter have very different messages.
To my mind, Star Wars is ultimately a story about duty and sacrifice at the expense of the self. Leia, Han, Obi-wan and even Luke are all forced to make choices that require a deep cost.
This is far less true with Harry Potter. Those characters are mostly presented as victims.
What Harry feels is always right, and it the system around him that is wrong. It’s all about his self-discovery. They do what they want and it always works out.
One presents the DUTY as the highest principle. The other presents the SELF as the highest principle.