Yesterday when NM house tax committee debated a bill to raise alcohol taxes to 25¢/drink, alcohol lobbyists urged lawmakers to take up alternate bills that would merely direct existing tax revenues to treatment & prevention. One of them (SB 61) is now being heard in Senate Tax.
The bill, sponsored by Sen. Bill Tallman, D-Abq, would divert revenues to a new Domestic Violence Victims Fund that previously went to general fund: nmlegis.gov/Legislation/Le…
Tallman amends the bill to add a minor tax increase for craft brewers and small wineries.
Now, committee takes supporting comments.
Lobbyist for City of Abq says this is a "very modest proposal" but would have "a substantial impact."
Kathy Elliott, a board member of @DVRCNM, says "we know how domestic violence and substance abuse work badly together" and says they "applaud the effort."
That's it for support. Now opposition.
Dan Weaks introduces himself as lobbyist for Bernalillo County (though notably he also represents winemakers). Says they oppose, prefers alternative bill sponsored by @jerryfornm that will be heard Thursday.
Many cite their support for Ortiz y Pino bill, SB 220 — clearly that is the industry preference. nmlegis.gov/Legislation/Le…
As they oppose there is much polite handwaving, various references to the "scourge upon our society" that is domestic violence and "the noble goal" of eradicating it.
Sen. Tallman makes closing remarks: "We have the highest rate of alcohol caused deaths in the U.S."
"I find it mind boggling that we haven't increased alcohol taxes in 30 years, which means with inflation these taxes are worth a third what they were..."
Speaking directly to his colleagues: "Everybody says...they realize we have the highest alcohol-related deaths...and they feel bad about that—but they don't want to do anything about it." He concludes, "I realize this is probably going nowhere but I find that very disappointing."
Sen. @Carrie_Hamblen, D-Las Cruces, says she is "thinking about small businesses" and this looks like "an incredible nightmare in setting up their point of sale system." Businesses will have trouble converting between volumetric units & differing alcohol content, she means?
It takes 3 votes to move on:
Motion to table: 5-5
Do-pass: 5-5
No recc: 6-4, with Shendo changing votes to "yes."
Final Nos: Brandt Griggs Kernan Sanchez
Final Yeses: Jaramillo Lopez Tallman Wirth Hamblen Shendo
It's a familiar argument to @TobaccoFreeKids, which advocates for higher cigarette taxes. “The tobacco industry uses it all the time," president Matt Myers told me. "The assertion is false." The org published a handout rebutting that specific claim. tobaccofreekids.org/assets/factshe…
Halfway through NM's legislative session, key committees are considering competing bills to alter alcohol taxes. Senate Tax will Tues & possibly Thurs—but first is House Tax & Revenue this AM: nmlegis.gov/Committee/Stan…
The bill considered today, HB 230, is the only proposal that would raise alcohol taxes (to 25¢ per drink). Alternates from @jerryfornm & Sen. Bill Tallman would change where tax revenues are directed but would not affect tax rates, which in NM have stagnated the last 30 years.
Last week HB 230 passed House Health & Human Services Committee 6-4, tho Dem Rep. Tara Jaramillo broke party lines to oppose. She later said she was concerned about its impact on wineries and breweries. Business interests likely front and center today.
The drug killing more people in the US than any other—by a long shot—is alcohol. My latest @nytimes story is about its toll in Oregon, where a small group of people in recovery are fighting a mammoth industry to get policymakers to act. nytimes.com/2022/09/11/hea…
The pandemic spurred huge changes in alcohol sales and consumption that scientists are still puzzling out. I gathered quarterly @USTreasury data on federal alcohol tax revenues and show they rose 8% in FY2021 and have remained a step-change above their pre-pandemic trend.
This heavier drinking seems to have supercharged alcohol-related deaths but they've been rising for decades. In Oregon, even as other causes of death like heart disease and cancer have fallen since 2000, age-adjusted deaths due to alcohol have more than doubled.
One crucial finding from my @NMInDepth investigation into the neglected toll of alcohol is that elected officials who stress science/health in other realms turn a blind-eye on this one.
Lujan Grisham has been steeped in health all her career. She ran @NMDOH from 2004-7, championed a strong public response to Covid-19, sought appointment as Biden's health secretary. But her staff have ignored the science on alcohol. abqjournal.com/1521446/report…
This isn't new. I spoke with 3 former @NMDOH scientists who collectively served governors of both parties back into the '80s. Each said they routinely pushed measures to address alcohol; none found governors receptive to responses broader than DWI. nmindepth.com/2022/an-emerge…
Political contrasts w/ 2013 Manchin-Toomey effort: That negotiation dragged for months but these moved fast—it's been 19 days since #Uvalde! Delay lets status quo retrench. And Toomey had no credibility on guns to cover for other Rs but Cornyn does—a Nixon-goes-to-Moscow moment?
On policy, negotiators seem to have dropped big-ticket items in favor of many small+meaningful wins.
First the fluff: promised investments in school security & mental health are as predictable as they are vague + lacking evidence they will measurably affect gun violence but OK.
To distill @mattyglesias' take: gun politics are bad for Democrats, gun policies aren’t effective enough to be worth the sacrifice, so progressives should just cede the issue in favor of other priorities. Why I think he’s wrong (a thread): slowboring.com/p/national-dem…
In the wake of this election, he’s not the first left-leaning pundit to throw gun violence under the bus — @ericlevitz beat him to it: nymag.com/intelligencer/…
But are gun politics really bad for Democrats? Yglesias argues that reformers’ message invariably collapses into “gun control > gun rights,” which polls poorly and puts them fundamentally at odds with gun owners. But to end gun violence we need not take the path of “gun control.