Today the government of Israel has taken an action which entails de jure annexation of the West Bank.

A thread.
An agreement was signed today between the Minister of Defense and the minister in his office, Bezalel Smotrich, for the transfer of governmental powers in the West Bank to the latter. Although the administrative authorities transferred to him do not include /2
some military operational powers, this is a dramatic change in the structure of governance over the occupied territory. Very broad administrative authorities pertaining to the majority of the governing powers in the West Bank are being transferred into hands /3
that are not of the military commander of the occupied territory. From now on, those powers will be held by the minister in the Ministry of Defense, who will de facto serve as the governor of the West Bank. /4
According to the agreement, the governor will be authorized to appoint officials in the Civil Administration and COGAT who exercise civil authorities, the legal advisors who will advise them, and he will be solely responsible for formulating policy. /5
The agreement includes two clauses aimed at obfuscating the transfer of powers by presenting the governor's alleged subordination to the Minister of Defense, but according to the document, the cases in which the Minister of Defense can override the governor are extreme cases /6
and even when this is done, the military commander of the West Bank will be bypassed, as he no longer holds authority.
The agreement also states that the governor will work to deepen the powers of the Israeli governmental authorities in the areas of Israeli settlements /7
a process which will promote the unification of government powers and geographically expand their direct legal authority in the West Bank. Or, in other words: stretching Israeli sovereignty beyond the Green Line. /8
The agreement also states that the governor will lead a process of expanding the dual legal system so that Israeli legislation by the Knesset will be applied more fully than it is today to the Israelis in the West Bank. /9
International laws of belligerent occupation state that an occupied territory will be temporarily administered by the occupying force (that is, the army) which, along with security considerations, will be obligated to promote the interests of the occupied people. /10
Transferring powers to Israeli civilian hands is an act of de jure annexation because it entails removing power from the occupying military and placing it directly in the hands of the government - this is an expression of sovereignty. /11
The bottom line is that the agreement signed today is simultaneously a giant leap of legal annexation of the West Bank and an act of perpetuating the regime’s apartheid nature.


• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with Michael Sfard מיכאל ספרד

Michael Sfard מיכאל ספרד Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @sfardm

Feb 23
היום ביצעה ישראל פעולה שמשמעותה סיפוח משפטי, דה יורה. שרשור.
היום נחתם הסכם בין שר הביטחון לשר במשרדו, בצלאל סמוטריץ', להעברת סמכויות שלטוניות בגדה המערבית לידיו של סמוטריץ'. העברת הסמכויות לידיו אמנם אינה מלאה לגמרי אבל מדובר בשינוי דרמטי של מבנה השלטון בגדה. /1
כוחות ניהול ומינהל רחבים ביותר הנוגעים למירב הסמכויות השלטוניות בגדה, עוברות בהסכם זה לידיים שאינן של המפקד הצבאי של השטח הכבוש, ויוחזקו מעתה בידי השר שבמשרד הביטחון שישמש הלכה למעשה כמושל של הגדה. /2
המושל יוסמך על פי ההסכם למנות את הפקידים במנהל האזרחי ובמתפ"ש אשר מפעילים את כל הסמכויות האזרחיות ואת היועמ"שים שייעצו להם, ויהיה אחראי לבדו לגיבוש מדיניות.
ההסכם כולל סעיפים שמטרתם לערפל את העברת הסמכויות ע"י הצגה של כפיפות כביכול של המושל לשר הביטחון. אלא שעל-פי המסמך /3
Read 8 tweets
Aug 14, 2022
This morning brought with it the confiscation of solar panels in a village of cave dwellers in the south of Mount Hebron and eight families will have to face the heat of August without water pumps, without fans, without cooling devices and without the possibility to charge >>
mobile phones.
The commander of the military force that confiscated the panels warned the team of angels from the @CometMe organization that installs renewable energy electricity systems for the weakest of the most vulnerable communities in the West Bank, that he would return >>
in two days and if he saw that they had installed new panels - he would confiscate them too.
All morning Adv. Kela Sappir and I tried to convince the relevant attorney at the West Bank region's legal advisor's office to put some sense into the heads of the commanders and maybe >>
Read 5 tweets
May 5, 2022
Yesterday, on the eve of Memorial Day and almost secretly, the Israeli Supreme Court published its ruling regarding the legality of the eviction orders of thousands of Palestinians living in the south Hebron Hills in an area declared as a firing zone (No. 918).
The court rejected the residents' petition thus ending proceedings Lasting more than 20 years in which the danger of deportation hovers over thousands of Palestinians living in the declared "firing zone".
The ruling rejected the claim that the prohibition of forcible transfer set forth in international law is customary and binding. Judge Mintz ruled that this was a treaty norm, that is, one that expresses agreements between states but is not enforceable in a domestic court
Read 11 tweets
May 5, 2022
אתמול, יום הזיכרון, כמעט בחשאי, פרסם בית המשפט העליון את פסק-דינו בנוגע לחוקיות צווי הפינוי של אלפי פלסטינים החיים בדרום הר חברון באזור שהוכרז כשטח אש (מס' 918).
בית המשפט דחה את עתירת התושבים ובכך סיים הליכים שנמשכים למעלה מ-20 שנים בהם מרחפת סכנת הגירוש מעל אלפי פלסטינים /1.
בפסק הדין דחו השופטים את הטענה שאיסור העברה כפויה (forcible transfer) הקבוע במשפט הבינלאומי מחייב את בית המשפט. השופט מינץ קבע שמדובר בנורמה "הסכמית", כלומר כזו שלא נטעה אחיזה בנוהג מחייב אלא "רק" הוסכם עליה באמנות המבטאות הסכמה בין מדינות אבל לא מחייבות את בית המשפט /2
מעבר לעובדה שמדובר בפס"ד קשה שעלול לגרום לאסון הומניטארי, ההנמקה הזו הכופרת בכך שאיסור גירוש והעברה כפויה היא כלל מנהגי של המשפט ההומניטארי, היא לא פחות משגיאה משפטית בסיסית מביכה. כל כך בסיסית שאפשר לומר שמקבילתה במדע המדינה היא לכפור בטענה שחופש ביטוי הוא עקרון של דמוקרטיה /3
Read 9 tweets
Nov 8, 2021
THREAD: On October 19, Israeli Defense Minister Benny Gantz declared six well-known Palestinian human rights/civil society groups “terrorist organizations.” Below I outline key points critical for anyone attempting to understand the recent Israeli government designations.
These organizations have earned our trust. They have garnered legitimacy through decades of critical work and are critical of both Israeli and the Palestinian Authority abuses of rights. I know the work of some of them personally, I know people who work there, and I trust them./2
Israel’s goal is to stop these NGOs’ political work, such as support for Int. Crim. Court investigations; security allegations act as cover. The “evidence” for links to terror wouldn't hold up if exposed to the public, so the gov withholds it by invoking security privilege. /3
Read 17 tweets
Mar 1, 2021
Does the desert love camels? According to the Israel Nature and Parks Authority (INPA), the answer is no.
Listen to a story that only INPA can come up with.
[Thread trans from Hebrew by @SolSalbe] /2
A client of mine and of Hagai Benziman, a Bedouin named Salman who lives in an unrecognised village in the Negev Mountain Reserve, copped an indictment from the INPA for "harming a nature reserve" because ... his camels grazed there. /3
How do camels that have lived in the Negev for thousands of years harm the reserve; you ask? Well, says INPA, because they drink the onagers’ [wild donkey/ass]. You got it? The onagers we brought in during the 1980s to repopulate the Land of Israel /4
Read 12 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!


0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy


3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!