1/ People who are freaking out about the poll that found nearly 1/2 of Black folk don't think it's "OK to be white" (or don't know if it is) are distorting what's beneath that perspective. It isn't 'genocidal' (as per Matt Walsh's silly hot take), or 'hate' (as per Scott Adams)..
2/ For many Black people -- and right wingers would know this if they knew more of them or ever discussed these issues with them -- whiteness is a state of mind. Indeed, Dick Gregory famously said that 50 years ago. His point: the dominant mentality of "white" was a problem...
3/ First bc it was the mentality that undergirded the subordination of Black people in America (among others), and was created for that purpose (Europeans hadn't been white in Europe -- we became that for a reason, and it was a bad one)...
4/ And what Gregory was also saying (and it's a perspective shared by many Black folks today, including, I'm betting those who would answer the poll question that way), is that people who are white don't always adopt the white mentality, and sometimes POC actually DO...
5/ So, what makes "being white" not OK to many is that it too often comes with a certain set of political and ideological assumptions, but it doesn't HAVE to. And anyone who rejects that mindset that has historically done so much harm, is just fine. But if you adopt it?...
6/ That's the problem...not being white per se, but what comes with that far too often.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1/ Those who critique the AP African American Studies curriculum for “lacking balance” or being too left leaning, obviously don’t understand the Black experience, but they also don’t understand how academic disciplines work. A 🧵 to explain the silliness of their position...
2/ African American Studies is a discipline like Sociology, Economics, Anthropology, Art History, etc. Those disciplines have pedagogies, theoretical foundations, and experts — and often they have an ideological lean as well. Why?...
3/ It's not bc of bias but because either the people who enter the discipline have an ideological lean, or because the scholarly production from the discipline leads in that direction organically...
A 🧵The idea that institutional racism is a myth because "there are no laws mandating racist mistreatment," as in the days of segregation, is the silliest hot take ever. Only a deliberately obtuse person could believe this...please follow for an explainer on why it's absurd...
2/ First off, historically, that would mean there was hardly ever institutional racism in the U.S. outside of the American South (which is ridiculous) bc most of the North/West maintained racial subordination more through informal customs/practices than legal apartheid...
3/ So, for instance, real estate brokers created residential segregation in places CA early in the 20th century, and the Midwest, mostly through professional practices imposed on members internally, w/o the force of law per se, which compelled them not to sell to certain people..
1/ Scott Adams was just looking for a reason to bash Black people. It had nothing to do with that Rasmussen poll. If it did, at worst he would have condemned the Black folks who ostensibly disagreed it was “ok to be white…” not all Blacks…also that poll is absurd…
2/ the fact that almost 1/2 of Black folks either disagreed or weren’t sure about the “its ok to be white” question is that it’s a common catchphrase spouted by overt white nationalists. So agreeing with it can seem to many to endorse those who use it that way…
3/ as such it makes sense for black folks to be ambivalent about it or wonder “what’s this really asking/measuring?” Finally, given the history of the concept of whiteness (a category created ONLY for the purpose of Euro supremacy/domination) their reaction also makes sense…
Donald Trump says Atlanta is the most dangerous city in America ("By far!") in terms of per capita crime rates. But no...it's the 94th most dangerous. Well behind Mobile, AL, Pine Bluff Arkansas, Springfield, MO, Anchorage, Alaska, Daytona Beach, FL, Salt Lake and Billings MT...
2. Gee, I wonder what it is about ATL that makes Trump think this lie will work with his uneducated fan base? Yeah, it's the part where Atlanta is a Black metropolis. Because racism always works, facts be damned...
Ah, the data-illiterate rantings of a failed Gubernatorial candidate and former judge (well, on Moral Court, anyway). How and why is this hot take wrong? Let me count the ways...follow below...this is a thread bc facts take longer to explicate than nonsense does...
(2) So, putting aside what Biden said or how you interpret it, let's deal with Larry's rebuttal. He presents data on homicide and overall violent crime to suggest "hey, if anyone is targeting someone bc of race it's Black-on-white, not white on Black." But this is disingenuous...
(3) The homicide and violent crime data he presents is not for crimes with bias motivations, whether they are Black on White (BW) or white on Black offenses (WB). So comparing hate related violence to regular crimes is apples to oranges...
(1) If you wonder why we insist that racism is systemic, or if you say we should just focus on class, not race, when it comes to inequality (a common argument of the white left), consider recent evidence on infant/maternal health from CA...
2/ According to groundbreaking research, which you can find here: nber.org/system/files/w…, racial disparities in health outcomes for infants and mothers are NOT mostly about economics, but rather, the cumulative effects of racialized injustice (what we call systemic racism)...
3/ There's been plenty of evidence to this effect before of course. So much so that you'd have to be willfully ignorant or incredibly committed to white denial, or silly class reductionism, not to know about it. But the new research is especially telling...