Lee David Evans Profile picture
Feb 28, 2023 34 tweets 13 min read Read on X
It was the shortest election campaign since the war.

And the first since we joined the European Community.

It's the February 1974 General Election, which took place #OnThisDay 49 years ago.

A thread, which I’ll be updating throughout the day with election highlights. 🧵 Image
Before the votes are counted, the key question is how well the Liberals have done.

The campaign very much went their way and Robert McKenzie wonders whether they are on the brink of achieving 25% and making substantial gains.

His swing-o-meter begins rather more modestly. Image
There’s an early sign that election coverage in the past wasn’t always that serious.

Mike Yarwood is in the studio to do impressions and gags.

He opens with “It’s quite pointless winning a seat in the House because it’s quite difficult to find one that Cyril Smith isn’t in.” Image
Boundary changes had given the Conservatives a reasonable advantage on the 1970 election.

Smaller urban seats in London had made way for new seats in more Tory territory, especially the Home Counties.

Here’s the net effect. 👇🏻 Image
David Dimbleby looks back on the campaign.

Former Minister Enoch Powell, who was not standing again, had stunningly urged a Labour vote.

During his speech a disgruntled audience member shouted “Judas!”

“Judas was paid!” retorted Powell with a menacing stare. “Judas was paid!” Image
Labour had been in touch with Powell throughout the campaign, not least to ensure his speech caused maximum damage to the government.

No Labour frontbencher give a keynote speech on 23 February, the day of Powell's remarks, to help him dominate the headlines.

He did.
McKenzie summarises what the pollsters have been saying throughout the February campaign.

Their final average forecast was a slightly increased majority for Heath and the Conservatives.

But the polls also showed the Liberals taking many more votes - but whose? Image
The first news from the counting centres is that it looks like a high poll.

Turnout would be up 6.8% overall in the election, the highest turnout since 1951.

But how did the people vote?

Here come some of the key results… (as Robin Day lights a cigar in the studio). Image
Guildford wins the race to be the first seat to declare.

A young David Howell, who remains in the House of Lords today, is returned.

Tory vote is down. Labour vote is down more. Liberals poll over 30%, the highest Liberal vote in the seat since 1929. Image
Eric Lubbock, whose sensational by-election win in Orpington in 1962 was a heavy blow for Macmillan, appears as a Liberal spokesperson.

Lubbock lost Orpington in 1970. A year later, he took his hereditary seat in the Lords as 4th Baron Avebury, following the death of his cousin. Image
McKenzie shows what a take off in support would mean for the Liberals' number of seats.

The tipping point is c. 25%.

Despite their impressive improvements in vote share, Liberal hopes soon start to fade.

Kingmakers in a hung Parliament looks their best bet for wielding power. Image
We have what I think is the first defeated-candidate-but-future-MP of the night.

Michael Jack loses in Newcastle-upon-Tyne Central. He would go on to be Tory MP for Fylde in Lancashire from 1987-2010.

The victor is Labour's Deputy leader Edward Short, sporting a green rosette. ImageImage
Shadow Employment Secretary Reg Prentice speaks for the incoming government.

Three years later he became the most senior politician to defect from Labour to the Conservatives.

He would become a Conservative MP and peer - as well as a minister in Mrs Thatcher’s first government. Image
Accrington’s result is in.

It’s described by David Butler as one of the first seats the Conservatives could have hoped to gain.

And it’s bad news for Mr Heath. There’s a swing to Labour of over 5%. Image
The first seat from Wolverhampton is declared - Wolverhampton North East.

In the news studio, speculation begins that Enoch Powell’s endorsement of Labour has produced devastating swings against the government in the midlands.

There’s a huge 10.6% swing in the constituency. Image
Enoch Powell’s own seat, Wolverhampton South West, sees a staggering 16.7% swing to Labour.

The Conservatives hold it with a majority just shy of 7,000; Nicholas Budgen would go on to represent the seat until 1997. Image
Margaret Beckett (née Jackson) loses in Lincoln to Dick Taverne.

Taverne had been a Labour MP but left the party and resigned his seat in 1972.

He was re-elected handsomely at the by-election and marginally in Feb 74 as a Democratic Labour candidate. Image
Taverne would lose to Jackson in the October rematch.

She would then herself lose in 1979, to the Conservatives, before becoming MP for Derby South in 1983.

Jackson, now known as Margaret Beckett, remains in the House of Commons; Taverne remains in the House of Lords. Image
The first seat to change hands is Keighley in Yorkshire.

The victor was Bob Cryer on a 1.7% swing.

Cryer held the seat until 1983, losing to the Conservatives. In 1987 he returned to Parliament for Bradford South, a seat he held until his death in a car accident in 1994. Image
“Barbara Castle back in Blackburn. It wouldn’t really be the Labour Party if she weren’t back, but of course she was in some trouble on the 1970 result…”

Castle, MP since 1945, increased her majority from 2,736 to 6,300.

Here she is campaigning with a tin of spam, or similar. Image
Conservative Party Chairman Lord Carrington begins to concede the obvious, describing the results as “disappointing”.

Carrington would be replaced as Party Chairman by Willie Whitelaw, who would lead the party organisation through the forthcoming October election. Image
Doug Hoyle, father of the current Speaker, is defeated in Nelson & Colne at his second time of trying.

He would take the seat in October, lose it in 1979, before becoming MP for Warrington (then Warrington North) from a 1981 by-election until 1997.

He remains a peer. Image
Jeremy Thorpe increases his majority in North Devon from 369 to over 11,000 (on new boundaries).

The next few years would spell disaster for Thorpe as his years of personal misconduct caught up with him.

He would eventually be defeated by the Conservatives in 1979. Image
A stony-faced Heath is returned in the new constituency of Sidcup.

“The look of a man who does not expect to be Prime Minister,” says Alastair Burnet.

Heath is interviewed by David Dimbleby and refuses to comment on the national result. Image
The Liberals had hoped for a breakthrough in Liverpool. They have failed.

Labour are on the up in the city.

The Conservatives lose Liverpool Garston marginally.

How Liverpool politics has changed: a successor seat, Garston and Halewood, now has a Labour majority of 31,624. Image
Labour are doing well - but not well enough.

Wilson speaks of how he has pinned his hopes on gains in Lancashire, Yorkshire, the West Midlands and London.

“But you’re not doing as well in the South are you?”

“Quite true,” Wilson says bluntly, obscured by his own pipe smoke. Image
Two titans of politics speak to Robin Day from Leeds.

Sir Keith Joseph and Denis Healey have both held their seats in the great Yorkshire city.

But colour television doesn’t seem to have made it to the BBC in Yorkshire yet! Image
Wilson addresses Party workers in Huyton in front of a *very* 1970s background.

He celebrates local results and hears for the first time of victory in Bebington and Ellesmere Port.

“I went to school in Bebington,” he adds. He had been a Sixth Former at @WGSB (as I was).
Whilst on stage, Wilson is offered what looks like a pint of ale from one of the party workers.

You can see it being offered as he walks to the microphones (in this image, he's behind Mary Wilson).

Wilson declines - surely he knows the cameras are rolling. Image
On a strong night for nationalist parties, the SNP gain Banffshire in Scotland.

The successor seat, Banff and Buchan, would go on to typify SNP success in NE Scotland, with Alex Salmond as its MP from 1987-2010.

It now has a Conservative MP once again, @david_duguid. Image
The computer (much hyped, discussed and argued over throughout the night) speaks:

There is almost no way for either major party to gain a majority. Image
The late, great David Butler refers to Enoch Powell as “the man whose influence in the West Midlands has produced eleven Conservative losses there. There is no other region of the country where anything like that has happened.”

He calls the West Midlands “Powell country.” Image
A rare event in this election: a Tory gain!

The Earl of Ancram takes Berwick & East Lothian. He would be defeated in October before becoming MP for Edinburgh South from 1979-1987 and Devizes from 1992-2010.

He is today the The Marquess of Lothian and has a life peerage. Image
It's the early hours and first editions are being published.

The Daily Express says "it's one big see-saw".

The rest of the year would show they were right. Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Lee David Evans

Lee David Evans Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @LeeDavidEvansUK

Mar 9
‘Is it possible, Mr Speaker, for Members to rise in their places and stand in silence in support of this protest against disgusting barbarism?’

‘That should be a spontaneous act by the House as a whole,’ the Speaker replied.

MPs then rose and stood. In silence.

A thread.🧵 Image
That exchange took place on 17th December 1942 when Anthony Eden, the Foreign Secretary, told the House of Commons (at the time meeting in the Lords) what was becoming known about the holocaust.
‘I regret to have to inform the House that reliable reports have recently reached His Majesty's Government regarding the barbarous and inhuman treatment to which Jews are being subjected in German-occupied Europe.’

He then told MPs of an international declaration, which said: Image
Read 17 tweets
Feb 28
It was Heath vs Wilson for the third time, with a supporting cast comprising some of the most vibrant figures in post-war politics.

#OnThisDay 50 years ago, the February 1974 election took place.

Here's the story of election night, as told through the BBC's coverage. 🧵


Image
Image
Image
Image
Before the votes are counted, the key question is how well the Liberals have done.

The pundits agree the campaign went their way and Robert McKenzie wonders whether they are on the brink of achieving 25% and making serious gains. Image
Yet the election coverage isn't totally serious: Mike Yarwood is in the studio to do impressions and gags.

He opens with, 'It’s quite pointless winning a seat in the House because it’s quite difficult to find one that Cyril Smith isn’t in.' Image
Read 32 tweets
Feb 27
‘Dalyell, come here!’

The young Tam Dalyell, among the most junior of MPs having been elected in a by-election just a year earlier, turned around to see who wanted his attention.

It was the prime minister, Harold Macmillan.

A thread.🧵
Image
Image
Dalyell had asked Macmillan a question in the Commons, specifically will he:

‘ensure that legislation presented to this House is not drafted in obscure language.’

Macmillan replied briefly by citing the need for precision about complex and technical issues. Image
But Dalyell, a little unsatisfied with the response, pushed back:

‘... is it not also important that we laity should understand legislation?’

Macmillan then gave an answer which was as typically him as any you could find:
Read 10 tweets
Feb 12
Harold Wilson's advice on answering tricky questions:

'You know, it's taken me a long time to realise it, but if you don't like a question all you've got to do is preface your answer with “As I said in the House of Commons...” and everyone goes to sleep...'

A brief thread. 🧵 Image
Wilson went on to say that if you begin your answer that way, journalists don't 'bother to write down what you're saying.'

'I ought to have tumbled to it long before but there's nothing like suggesting it's all stale stuff for distracting attention from an awkward question.’ Image
Wilson would particularly use this technique against the foreign press. During the 1964 election campaign, he answered one question by saying:

'You'll find I dealt with that point very fully in my speech in the defence debate last year'.

And to another, he said: Image
Read 4 tweets
Nov 18, 2023
In the run up to the next election, Labour will hold talks with civil servants on their plans for government.

It's a sensible way to prepare for an election, but the convention is only six decades old.

A thread on the 'Douglas-Home rules'. 🧵 Image
In 1964, two issues made it important that the Opposition and the Civil Service understood each other.

(1) Labour had been out of office for 13 years. Only three members of the Shadow Cabinet (Harold Wilson, James Griffiths and Patrick Gordon Walker) had any Cabinet experience. Image
(2) Labour had a radical agenda for the reorganisation of government, including a new department of economic affairs which would ultimately be led by George Brown (below).

Civil servants wanted to know more - and Labour wanted to prepare the ground for their plans. Image
Read 8 tweets
Oct 18, 2023
Scandal. Seaside conspiracies. Murky consultations. Midnight plots. And a Downing Street showdown.

The events surrounding Harold Macmillan’s resignation #OnThisDay in 1963 had it all.

A thread of the dramatic events of sixty years ago.🧵 Image
Firstly, some context: 1963 had been a miserable year for Macmillan. European rejection, the Profumo scandal and swirling rumours about whether he should resign.

By the summer, Macmillan was beginning to wonder whether he had it in him to fight the next election.
Image
Image
An “unhappy stroke of fate” settled the matter for good.

On the evening of 7th October 1963, Macmillan suffered the symptoms of prostatic obstruction, including excruciating pain and an inability to pass water. Medics rushed to Downing Street to offer relief.
Read 23 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(