I wrote this letter recently to my friends in the antiwar and anti-nuclear movements. I see it’s being circulated, so I’ve decided to share it here. For all of you working on these issues, thank you, and please keep going!
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Pundits are out praising my father as a way of denouncing @Snowden, @xychelsea, Assange, and modern whistleblowers by comparison. Daniel is on record vehemently rejecting praise of him used for this cynical purpose. Media, please at least mention that fact. --Michael E. 🧵⬇️
For example, the day my father died, @nytdavidbrooks and @CapehartJ were out making what Daniel called the "Good Ellsberg, Bad Snowden" comparison, which Daniel constantly denounced:
.
Brooks: "I think most leakers are wrong. I thought Edward Snowden was terrible. But Daniel Ellsberg shows that you can do it right." Capehart: unlike Snowden, "Daniel Ellsberg should be considered a hero, because he... stood up for his beliefs and his value system" (continued)
💯 Daniel absolutely rejected what he called the "Ellsberg Good / Assange, Manning, Snowden Bad" media narrative that used him as a foil against them. Any journalist advancing this story should at least have the honesty to note that Daniel thoroughly rejected it -Michael E. 🧵⬇️
Daniel had particular scorn for @Gladwell's 2016 piece advancing this tale, using Daniel as a foil against @Snowden. He considered Gladwell intellectually dishonest for failing to mention Daniel's rejection of this view, which he had given to Gladwell. newyorker.com/magazine/2016/…
(As an aside: I showed Daniel "The Bomber Mafia" by @Gladwell, curious what he thought of it, since he covered the same period in "The Doomsday Machine." Daniel flipped through it for a few minutes, set it down, and said, "This is a children's book; he's out of his depth.")
From @MichaelEllsberg: Dad used to joke that his "retirement plan" was federal prison. But he was only half-joking. In 2021, he dared the government to put him there, in his final act of civil disobedience, at age 90. Via @charlie_savage: nytimes.com/2023/06/18/us/…
Here are links to the actual pages of Daniel's final "leak." These have not been formally declassified. My understanding is, anyone who downloads these and doesn't hand them over to the government is technically in violation of the Espionage Act: ellsberg.net/quemoy/
Biden should drop his appeal to extradite Julian Assange and dismiss all charges against him, on the new disclosures that Assange has been subjected to the same governmental crimes that led to the dismissal of my own prosecution half a century ago. 1/ news.yahoo.com/kidnapping-ass…
2/ These governmental crimes include illegal, warrantless surveillance, conspiracy to "totally incapacitate me" and--in the words of my judge--"bizarre events" that "offend a sense of justice." All of these apply exactly to the just-revealed crimes against Assange.
3/ Here is Judge Matthew Byrne's statement dismissing the charges against me and Tony Russo, on May 12, 1973. AG Garland should take similar action on Assange this week. And if that doesn't happen, the UK High Court should dismiss the appeal. / nytimes.com/1973/05/12/arc…