I get benefit from Spengler but ultimately don’t recommend him to most. It takes a certain pedantry to like him
But the key lessons are both clear & more important than anything else I see: (1) that certain things are no longer possible & (2) the West is DIFFERENT
The first is a too much of a pill for many to swallow, so they won’t swallow it. We will get endless fix-alls, snake oil, magic potions and there will always be an excuse as to why [thing] did not work. Chasing symptoms is another eternally popular genre of “solutions”
2nd is a tough pill to swallow because we admire the past &want to see ourselves in ancients, &because we want to cling to the fantasies that any collection of white men can just conjure up a machine civ any time in the future, &there’s nothing unique about WESTERN huwhyte man
These are insurmountable obstacles to his work being widely embraced, beyond token nods
Candidly I think Oswald was so popular in interwar Germany only because they had just received the biggest splash of grim reality in human history to date, from the recent war & its aftermath
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
I find Dune interesting. The world building is interesting. I even like some of the psychology he gets fixated upon. But an editor speeding things along and challenging him on some of his indulgences would have been better
Entire chapter: Gurney learns a bunch of shit the reader already knows, he scowls and plays a dumb song on balliset
Next chapter: Baron Harkonnen is still fat, still likes sex with boys
Next: Jessica thinks something to herself for the 10,000 time - it’s the sign of ADEE-ASH!
Yet I still enjoy Dune because it was so different and had a coherence to its vision
First thing to know is that “honor” is a BARBARIC concept that gets slowly warped as a civ carries on, often getting blended with “duty” (seen in Rome, Victorian era)
Honor at its barbaric core revolves around insult to ur sense of self/integrity
Duty is an obligation related to an org/fam/social structure-it is to commit to thing beyond urself
A savage can have honor but duties are often alien to him. At the end of a civ, men can understand duties but honor fades -we find it alien
If minor twatter beef went to pistols
u would be shocked. Look at the minor insults that led to famous duels…
One movie above all will show u the difference: The Duelists by Ridley Scott.
Both men NEGLECT their duties to their fellow soldiers to preserve their honor. There CAN BE a TENSION between duty&honor!
Of course there was fraud, of course some big wins still happened - but ppl must remember the historically bad fundamentals here and what that should have resulted in
There were no Presidents on coins until the 20thC - &other than Lincoln (1909) it was all a creation of Great Depression. In Prog Era we decided that we needed to be a proper Imperial power & therefore needed a proper Imperial mythos. So the “Founding Fathers” cult was fabricated
Now I love my homeland, this is the Land of Providence, but the truth is from the new gov-established cult we got a revised, partially-fabricated history, new coins, Mt Rushmore civil worship site, new term of reverence: “Founding Fathers”, etc
“Making shit up” has a long and storied Imperial history. Romans fabricated huge chunks of their history and were roleplaying having divine ancestors all the way to the end
It is understandable, but wrong, that many can ONLY see Christianity as promoting weakness -they were brought up in some form of this in church, as we have for centuries now. Or they get it from reading bookcels who were
So when they read of Alaric pausing pillage for Easter
When they read of medieval CONQUERING kings building magnificent lofty cathedrals at massive expense
When they read of Hernan Cortes, who uncovered his head and bowed whenever addressing a priest
They see it all as PARADOX or else cope that such men didn’t “really” believe
But the fact is the ameliorating, humbling aspects of Christianity are wisdom. Any leader knows hubris is a THREAT - A LEADERSHIP FAULT - eg even a simple troop leader knows humility is critical. Ppl see Gen Patton as swaggering figure & ignore that he prayed morning & evening…