I was asked by @jm_mcgrath at 22:12 how much our recommendations would cost businesses. Want costed options for your business to provide 6 air changes per hour? Here are 9 options. 🧵
2. PC Fan CR Box. Tower of Power. The advantage is that it takes up less space and it's quieter. Those advantages come with a cost. 480 CFM. $390 (CAD). Or DIY - approx. $250. Use 1 per 500 sq ft.
Educate yourself before going down this path. Using the Trillium would be $3000 for every 500 sq ft. & 30-60 ACH. I think Sterilray is around $4k (CAD) and can be used every 1000 sq ft (not positive).
This might not get you to 6 ACH, but could add in around 2 ACH in addition to existing ventilation. For 2000 sq ft, I'd estimate an extra $250-300/year.
$0.1-0.2/sq ft./year
9/11
8. Doubling ventilation
I referenced this study. $40/person/year. Payback is 6.5-7.5k per year. $160 back for every $1 spent. Like I said, “orders of magnitude”. Would likely add 2-3 ACH and get you up to 4-5 ACH.
These hospital outbreaks need to stop. Vulnerable people deserve protection. We've laid out clear plans on how to prevent these healthcare acquired infections. 🧵
Here's the ventilation guidance.
- No targets
- No requirements
- Misinformation about short range transmission
It's just saying "do what you can". BTW, when is ventilation "inadequate"? They don't say.
If you want to know what a real plan looks like...
2/5
1. 6 air changes per hour in shared spaces using ventilation, filtration or UVGI. 2. Comply with minimum ventilation requirements as set out by ASHRAE and CSA. 3. Monitor CO2 to confirm compliance. You can find what the CO2 levels should be here: ospe-calc.herokuapp.com
Hosting a Wedding or Large Party.
How to ensure clean air and make it #DavosSafe 🧵
The full layered approach is vaccines, rapid tests, masks and clean air. I'm focusing here on clean air. The other steps can also be used.
1/7
Do as much outside as possible.
The bigger the venue, the better. More space and higher ceilings means better dilution and lower risk.
Your three tools are ventilation, filtration and UV. We'll go through them one by one.
2/7
Ventilation:
Find out what you can about the ventilation. Ask if they can increase it during the gathering and ensure it is scheduled properly and not in auto. If there are windows or doors, try to open them. If there are ceiling fans, turn them on.
3/7
It's one place where you have to remain indoors for an extended period of time without a mask. There are ways to reduce risk. It's important to be able to assess risk as well. Here is what I look for.
1/12
Before I go, I ask the following questions:
- do you have HEPA filters in every room?
- do you have barriers between rooms?
Those are the two things I need before I go.
I also ask if they know anything about the ventilation and they usually answer they don't.
2/12
When I go, I bring my CO2 monitor and check to see if I can hear the ventilation or check the thermostats to see if they are "on" and not "auto". If they are in auto, I let them know. If the CO2 > 800 ppm, I won't go back.
The box fan CR box is the cheapest way of cleaning air and can be scaled up. It's the best option in large spaces. The most important aspect is equity: it makes clean air available to everyone. The sound is > 47 dB. It's tolerable in many places, but not all.
IMO, we need a better box fan with a built-in shroud and quieter noise at 43 dB or so.
The PC fan CR box is ultra-quiet and the best long term solution. It's more difficult to DIY and if you purchase one, it isn't cheap. Currently, it is best for residential settings.