Ok guys, it’s time for me to tell you about something very enlightening that I read in a book recently:
75% of people would rather being knowingly wrong and blend in, than be right and stand out. And there’s a well known psychology experiment that proved it. 🧵
The book is ‘Atomic Habits’ and has nothing to do with masks or avoiding neurotropic viruses, but there was a section explaining that if we want to change our habits, we should hang out with people that have the habits we wish to adopt. Bc humans are wired to do as the pack does.
Needing to be part of “the pack” is key here. For much of human history, being accepted by the pack or tribe was *essential* for survival. A lone human would not have survived very long. As the saying goes: The lone wolf dies, but the pack survives. 🐺
It’s not just humans either. A study found that if a chimp that had learned an effective way to crack open nuts as a part of one group, then changed to a group that had a less effective strategy, the chimp would adopt the less effective method so they could blend in.
Anyway, back to humans. A psychologist in the 50s designed an experiment where a subject was put in a room with a group of actors (not knowing they were actors) and shown a card with a line and a second card with a series of lines and asked to match their line to the similar one.
First there would be a few rounds where everyone agreed on the right answer. But then a couple of actors would start to choose the wrong answer. If it was just 1-2 actors doing this, it wouldn’t change the subject’s choice.
But if the majority of the other people in the room chose a wrong answer, and everyone seemed to be in agreement, the vast majority of subjects would eventually deliver answers that *they knew were wrong*. They ran this experiment many times, many ways. 75% of people would crack.
The normal behavior of the tribe overpowers the desired behavior of the individual.
The push to “end the pandemic” through behavioral manipulation has relied heavily on this aspect human psychology. The human survival instinct to blend in with the tribe was very successfully weaponized to get people to act against their own interests.
That’s why we get surveys where >50% of people are in favor of masking but <20% actually do it. That’s why PH often uses mandates to change behavior. And also why we won’t have any as long as the decider class decides that we are to pretend covid is a cold and carry on.
Public health has changed a lot since covid. Here’s a really concrete example of that. In 2019, PH in Montreal published a really detailed list of places people were exposed to measles: bus routes, malls, walmart, etc. In 2024? The list is just healthcare, schools + the airport.
Why the sudden change in what information is made public? I highly doubt that *none* of these measles cases exposed people anywhere else. Did any of them go to a pharmacy or grocery store or coffee shop or hockey rink? And if so, why aren’t any of these locations being published?
Not publishing these locations means 1. people don’t have the opportunity to protect themselves and others post-exposure and 2. the fact that people are actively being exposed in the community (not just clinics and airports) is not being made explicit for the public.
@Penelope19920 @jvipondmd As soon as the IPAC email goes out letting everyone know they need to wear masks, everyone wears masks. If IPAC decides everyone has to wear respirators, then everyone wears respirators. This actually isn’t hard at all. Why leadership would make it seem like it is, is baffling.
@Penelope19920 @jvipondmd They lean on hand wave-y concepts like mask fatigue when I have never once received a survey asking me how I felt about masking. None of this is evidence based. Since 2022, they seem to be making decisions based on “feels”.
@Penelope19920 @jvipondmd Do you know what happens in hospitals when HCWs get hand washing fatigue? They hire people to patrol the wards and make sure we’re washing our hands when we’re going in and out of patient rooms. They don’t give us hand washing breaks and just let c.diff run wild for a while. 😒
StatCan just dropped a bombshell report on LC. This is the most important figure. It highlights that the risk of long term symptoms is cumulative, it increases with increasing number of infections. By 3+ infections, 38% report long term symptoms — that’s 1 in every 2.6 people. 🤯
Right now 1 in every 9 Canadians has long covid. 80% have symptoms for longer than 6 months and 50% just never recovered.
We’re in our *3rd* post-lockdown viral respiratory season and admissions for viral resp illness+pneumonia are 6 standard deviations above the historical average. I do not understand how so many reasonable people haven’t figured out that the “immunity debt” scapegoat is disinfo.🧵
It’s not the lockdowns, it’s the covid. Covid damages immune systems. Catching covid makes people more susceptible to catching other infections. Immunity theft, not immunity debt. A thread of evidence:
This study found that the risk of RSV infection needing medical attention was 40% higher in kids that had covid vs those that didn’t. Both in 2021 and 2022. Yes they checked twice.
“We report a consistent increase in the risk of persistent symptoms after reinfection compared to first infection. All post-acute symptoms mentioned in the WHO clinical case definition appeared more common after reinfection than after a 1st infection”
‘RoBuSt HyBriD iMmuNiTy’ 🤪
Yet another study showing that more infections = more morbidity. Can we like warn people maybe? Feels like something people might want to know. nature.com/articles/s4146…
“Escalation of commitment: A human behavior pattern in which an individual or group facing increasingly negative outcomes from a decision, action, or investment nevertheless continue the behavior instead of altering course.”
I’m very optimistic that vaccine/treatment breakthroughs + better air hygiene standards will change the game at some point. But I’d also like to point out that preserving one’s short and long term health is an endgame in and of itself. It’s the endgame for so many things we do…
The endgame of exercise? Health.
The endgame of limiting alcohol? Health.
The endgame of treated tap water? Health.
The endgame of tossing spoiled food? Health.
The endgame of cooking meat to temp? Health.
The endgame of washing your hands? Health.
The endgame of screening and checkups? Health.
The endgame of carseats and seatbelts? Health.
The endgame of helmets? Health.
The endgame of brushing your teeth? Health.
The endgame of condoms? Health.
The endgame of indoor smoking bans? Health.