April 6th, 2023: @Twitter has been randomly shutting down API access for many apps and sadly we were affected today too. Hopefully we will be restored soon! We appreciate your patience until then.
How can you identify when a movement is verging on terrorism?
In his 2005 book on the psychopathology of terror, ex-FBI agent Joe Navarro defined "violence or the threat of violence intended to exact compliance from a population."
These are 7 warning signs to watch for:
/1 Uncompromising Ideology
Terrorism emerges from rigid ideologies that reject accommodation. Alternative views are intolerable. Persuasive ideas or evidence do not shake beliefs and may harden them.
/2 Intractable Mind
The mind of a terrorist is stubborn. It feeds on the "intoxicating elixir" of others' closed-minded ideas and thoughts.
Such people are often bitterly argumentative, unyielding, and unpleasant.
/3 Frustration
As the rigid ideology causes social rejection and withdrawal, the terrorist increasingly bonds solely with the like-minded. They share rage at those who ignore or oppose their ideology.
In this echo chamber, paranoia and hatred fester.
/4 The Lost
As philosopher Eric Hoffer observed of mass movements, many followers are the weak, discarded, and disaffected of society.
The ideology, and the clarity and solidarity it gives, fills this void.
/5 Opportunists
Others attracted to mass movements, including terrorism, see in them an opportunity to commit crimes or depravities while cloaked in the claimed legitimacy of the movement.
/6 Radical Intolerance
Terrorist ideologies have had many different goals in history. In the end, they resemble one another by seeking not incremental reforms, but annihilation of "the problem" they fear and hate.
/7 Magical Thinking
Unbending, violent ideologies ultimately cause adherents to experience the belief that the destruction of what they despise or hate will, in one swift blow, cure the ills of the world.
Found this thought-provoking? My mission is to empower people to be free from forces that want to control them. Follow me @bfcarlson for more, and consider signing up for my newsletter. bfcarlson.com
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
I love this thought experiment Marshall McLuhan proposes to novelist Tom Wolfe in 1970. What would happen if all the media—even and especially this platform—shut off for one week?
Stick around for his provocative explanation of why all news is fiction.
“Most news is literally fake because it has to be made, then selected.”
News is a product that must be manufactured. Materials are selected from what is available. Then crafted to make an attractive item for sale.
I know this is true because I did it as a journalist.
News “are fictions…they are made, literally. Created.”
At its best, news like fiction is inspired by and faithful to reality. Like fiction, it is limited by the conventions of its form. Like fiction, it takes reality and adds drama, conflict, heroes, and villains.
Philip K. Dick, scifi visionary, died 41 years ago in a state of ruin. But his predictions of AI, predictive policing, and virtual reality have come uncannily true. In 1977, Dick reflects on his surprising emotion upon discovering he was being harassed by the FBI and CIA.
If you found this interesting, please follow @bfcarlson for more on thinkers like PKD. And consider subscribing to my newsletter where I go deeper on how ideas of the past shape our future. Hope to see you there. Bfcarlson.com
The break-in at PKD's home in San Rafael, CA occurred Nov 17, 1971. Those who knew him marked this as the point where he began to live more in his own mental world. The damage appeared to him motivated by malice —to send a message— not theft.
In the CIA interrogation manual, it lists coercive techniques used to break someone's will. They include:
- Isolation
- Dependence
- Inducing guilt
- Preying on fear
- Disrupting sleep
- Robbing basic dignity
- Depriving of natural light
Sounds like social media addiction.
The source of these techniques is the KUBARK interrogation manual. Sensory deprivation from real world stimuli was found to be particularly effective in alienating someone from themselves and making them malleable to exploitation.
The key to getting someone to betray himself is to give him a way to violate his beliefs without feeling ashamed. Once he has done, so, he will seek reasons to justify turning against those he was once loyal to.