We're at the fourth of five hearings of a new IL State Senate Committee on the Chicago Elected Representative School Board and will try to live tweet as the spirit moves us & the wifi & battery life allow...ilga.gov/senate/committ…#ERSB
This series of hearings is about creating a map of districts for the board seats, eventually 21 will be elected, but in Nov 2024, 10 members will be elected, remaining 11 to be appointed by the mayor. More background here: ilfps.org/ersb_hearings_…
If you're tuning in from home, the hearing hasn't started yet. About 25 people here incl Senator Hunter (on the committee) and Senator Cervantes (not on the committee)
@robertmartwick@ElgieSims@LLCoolK_4@senvillivalam@SenPacioneZayas Some background from Sen Lightford: HB290 passed bill to create ERSB in spring 2021. First election of 10 members will be in Nov 2024 to four year terms; 11 members appointed to two-year term. Then in Nov 2026, remaining 11 members elected to four year term.
@robertmartwick@ElgieSims@LLCoolK_4@senvillivalam@SenPacioneZayas Enriquez: We opposed HB2908 because it disenfranchised our community. We don't think Sen Villanueva's bill to allow non-citizens will pass. We should have had same voting methods as LSCs and not "put politics in it"
Enriquez: Give our community equal racial representation or kill this process and replace it with LSC-style voting system
Klein, staff attorney for MALDEF (Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund) which has been involved in voting district maps since the 1980s
Klein: Latinos are 29.8% of Chi pop, 27.2% of Chi voting pop, 46% of CPS student population. It's a civil right to have Latino community to have sufficient representation
Klein: Schedule of this hearing isn't sufficient--only one virtual hearing and 4 in-person were on weekdays
Klein: Please provide interpretation for some of the future meetings (i.e. for non-English speakers). Please make data public that is being used for the hearings.
Klein: Hold more hearings with sufficient advance notice. Please release draft map and then have another hearing for more input.
Next speaker is from Educators for Excellence (ed reform group that submitted statement with KidsFirst, etc: ilga.gov/senate/committ…)
She wants a smaller board -- CPS board with 21 members would be much larger than most boards in US [Ed note: read our explanation of why the board is this size here: ilfps.org/ersb_hearings_…]
Also says board members should be compensated and should be campaign finance rules to make it possible for working class candidates to run
Also says: non-citizen Chicagoans should also be allowed to vote
Next up Kurt Hilgendorf, @CTULocal1: Map should meet all state and federal voting rights requirements, should be equitable and representative of city
Next up speaker from Stand for Children (also supports reducing size of board to 9 members along with KidsFirst, etc)
Stand for Children rep: Size of board is problematic because it will make it "messier" and filled with "political factions"
This will distract from focus of superintendent for running school district. School board members should be paid, but we need fewer if we are going to pay them.
Next up: CPS alum from Benito Juarez HS and (maybe?) was a student rep on the LSC. Principal would refuse to show the LSC the budget. Couldn't count on LSC to get hold of the budget. Northside schools & students given a fairer chance because they have more resources
That was the final speaker. Chair Lightford closes things out.
Or not! One last speaker from the audience: Chris Bridges from CLCCR asks if there's any comments or reflections on what the committee has heard
Lightford: we are just doing listening for these sessions and will discuss things after all the hearings.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Reminder that US News rankings of high schools primarily based on *test scores* will inevitably rank schools whose admissions policies primarily use *test scores* highly
There are in fact more meaningful & thoughtful ways to evaluate (and not rank!) students and schools
Good place to start: Massachusetts has done some school quality evaluation work via the Massachusetts Consortium for Innovative Education Assessment: mciea.org/school-quality…
Rep Margaret Croke's HB 303 is an attempt to prevent CPS from shifting to equity-driven budgeting by protecting schools with selective admissions policies. Here's the set of SEHS & HS w/ Academic Centers' Opportunity Index measures:
As you can see there's a big range in indicator score and Opp Index score. A high Opp Index means school is less resourced & has higher need student body (among other things). See p. 4 here cpsboe.org/content/action…
Lane, Payton, Jones, Northside have the lowest OI of high schools in CPS, w/ Whitney Young close behind--but these are similar to Amundsen, Lincoln Park, Von Steuben & Lake View, 3 n'hood high schools and a magnet docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d…
Sidenote: hearing notice was posted yesterday: Apr 15, 2024 12:30PM - And HB 5766 content was moved to HB 303 HFA1 with Rep Croke as sponsor sometime yesterday as well.
(We learned about the amendment & hearing late last night...)
You can file slips in the House until the end of the committee hearing, so there's still time to file one for today's hearing (and also tomorrow's.) Details here: ilfps.org/action_alert_o…
Content of HB 5766, bill to put moratorium on selective admissions schools in CPS, has been modified (slightly) & introduced as amendment to HB 303. Can file witness slip to OPPOSE for hearing today (& one tomorrow?) Instructions & more info in thread below 🧵
Real talk on the transition to a fully elected board: the desirability of a fully elected board in January 2025 vs January 2027 has varied over the course of the past several years!
In Jan. 2021, when a fully elected school board was (possibly!) in reach, and the proposal on the table was six years hence, supporters of an elected board thought that was ridiculous.
An orderly transition from mayoral appointed to fully elected needs time, but not six years. That proposal passed in May 2021, meaning a five and 1/2 year transition. Which lots of pro-elected board groups (us included) were unimpressed with.
Trib story this week on vouchers and Catholic school closings also featured Christian school on Chicago's West Side which was in top 5 recipients of voucher $ last year, Chicago Hope Academy. Here's a closer look at Chicago Hope Academy... 🧵 chicagotribune.com/2024/02/08/wit…
"At Chicago Hope Academy...more than 1/2 of the students attend through tax credit scholarships. Hope Principal & Pres Ike Muzikowski said the school has committed to keeping each student enrolled, taking it upon themselves to raise the $$ for roughly 130 students on scholarship”
Both voucher use & enrollment has increased at Chicago Hope Academy since Invest in Kids started in 2018-2019 school year, but voucher use is up 400% (20 to 116), enrollment is only up by about 25% (246 to 302) during the first five years of the program: