NEW. An updated book ban report for the current school year from @PENamerica shows how new state laws are supercharging book suppression in schools, esp in Florida. 𧡠#FReadom#EdScare#BookBans nyti.ms/41DFeJC
As I told @nytimes: "This is much bigger than you can really count... People need to understand that itβs not a single book being removed in a single school district, itβs a set of ideas that are under threat just about everywhere.β /2
Read and share: pen.org/report/banned-β¦
Critically, although the book ban movement began with individuals and groups acting locally, they're efforts have been enhanced by the passage of state laws, which have together created an unprecedented chilling effect on schools, which we @PENamerica call the #EdScare. /3
Ask yourself when teachers & librarians were last so Afraid to give books to students that they suspended access to their entire book collections in one swoop? No, that'd not usual in schools. But such "wholesale bans" are becoming more common. Shutting down whole libraries /4
And the train of new laws continues. Yesterday FL extended the Don't Say Gay provisions through gr12. That law is one of few there that have used fear to drive bans across the state. Many are happening quietly. No one is doing more to shed light on this than @FLFreedomRead /5
Now TN has stepped in with a law heading to Gov Lee's desk to fine and punish publishers if they sell "obscene" books to schools. Like in many laws the sponsors imagine stretching that term to encompass books that contain any sentences describing sex. tennessean.com/story/news/pol⦠/6
Already we've seen in Utah how its new state law allegedly against 'porn in schools' is being similarly stretched, to ban @MargaretAtwood's The Handmaid's Tale, Toni Morrison's The Bluest Eye, or @johngreen's Looking For Alaska among others. These books aren't porn... /7
But that hasn't stopped these mischaracterizations. A similar law is also moving forward in Texas, to force publishers to put new age ratings on books, & threaten punishments if they don't ... with a similar intent to treat any sexual content as illicit /8 dallasnews.com/news/politics/β¦
This is where this is all heading-- increased, direct government censorship of books. Of a kind not seen in the US in generations. Of a kind that the First Amendment is meant to protect against. Join our movement to #FreeTheBooks! Learn more and support: pen.org/issue/free-theβ¦
β’ β’ β’
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
IcYMi. In the flurry of other outrageous news... On top of being first to unconstitutionally censor drag shows, now TN is moving to pass a law introducing felony charges and $100K fines for publishers if they sell obscene materials to public schools 𧡠tennessean.com/story/news/polβ¦
2. Ofc, TN already has laws against distribution of obscene materials to minors. So why this law? Clearly it's got an ulterior motive: to ban books by threatening or censoring publishers.
3. The law will give local DA's and the state AG discretion to determine when a book is 'obscene.' And that's where the sleight of hand is. The bill's sponsor Rep Lynn has a tenuous grasp on what that means, believing any "sexually explicit" content = obscenity. That's not true.
Some are so bent on cracking down on drag, LGBTQ books, or teaching about racism, that they are both passing new laws and enforcing existing ones-- even when there's no evidence of violations.
Undercover cops in the audience determined there were no lewd acts in the drag show, that children were not "exposed" to anything breaking the law. No matter... the Dept of Business and Professional Regulation filed a complaint to strip the venue of its liquor license anyway. /2
Reminds me of Oklahoma! Last July the state board of Ed downgraded Tulsa School District's accreditation status over an allegation that a teacher training about implicit bias violated HB 1775 - the state's "divisive concepts" ed gag order. But... /3 cnn.com/2022/08/27/us/β¦
A new bill in Texas, SB 1443, looks to take the censorship crusade in schools to another level.
It would ban LGBTQ topics and sex from books in schools, prohibit referrals to websites, ban drag or other forms of performance in school plays, & penalize publishers π§΅/1
The first part of the bill details topics to be barred from all books in schools, incl:
- "any any type of romantic or sexual attraction
between individuals of the same sex"
- "transgenderism"
- "sexual intercourse"
/2 capitol.texas.gov/tlodocs/88R/biβ¦
Don't miss the part where it would also BAN referring to websites that contain these topics. Breathtaking when you think about it: could students be referred to a news site? wikipedia? Pretty sure there's a lot of the web that acknowledges LGBTQ people exist and sex is a thing /3
Dig into almost any school book ban in FL, and you find 1 person--or a small group-- filing objections to books en masse, demanding removals. The restrictions on books this vocal minority have gotten are astonishing, precisely b/c they're often enacted without any process /2
Ofc, parents should be able to engage with schools about books & curricula. But schools also have to balance the demands of a few people with the objectives of public education, and the interests of ALL parents. Too often, that isn't happening. /3
Yes, under Utah's new "sensitive materials" law, librarians are being pressured to ban books that include any of a wide range of sexual content, if -- and, this is key -- if the district determines a book has "no serious value for minors."
Here's the list of 44 being banned in Washington County. Many are widely recognized, popular, award-winning literary works. They're being determined to have "no serious value for minors" to appease the vocal activists who want books w/ sex of any kind banned.
Banned book of the day is "And Tango Makes Three" by Justin Richardson and Peter Parnell.
With its true story of 2 male penguins raising a baby, it's been targeted for years. But we @PENamerica are seeing an uptick in efforts to ban it across FL... #FreeTheBooks
In Lake County. the district banned the book specifically b/c of the "Don't Say Gay" law. Note: the law bans "classroom instruction" on gender and sexuality, not library books. No matter. π€·ββοΈ h/t @FLFreedomRead
In Escambia, FL, Tango was one of 100+ books challenged by a teacher, which resulted in it going on backroom shelves for a time and requiring a parental permission slip. The objection? "LGBTQ agenda using penguins", and some key excerpts:
π§π³οΈβππ§ pnj.com/story/news/locβ¦