The best thing written about James Baldwin is the essay "Jimmy" by Otto Friedrich (1929-1995), a German-American journalist who knew Baldwin in Paris. Baldwin was the best man at his wedding. The piece is brutal. amazon.com/Grave-Alice-B-…
Apparently the young James Baldwin spent a lot of time talking about his novel but not producing much. He never paid for anything and casually appropriated other people's possessions—like this girl's typewriter.
When Friedrich criticized him for never producing anything, Jimmy called him a hack. "Better a hack writer than a nonwriting talker.”
In 1950, as a favor to Jimmy, on a visit to New York City Friedrich took Baldwin's mother out to dinner. In return, she invited him and his fiance to her house for dinner, where they met Jimmy's relatives and ate spare ribs and potato pie in her Harlem kitchen.
In time Friedrich & Baldwin grew apart. Attempts to contact Baldwin through his agent were ignored. Jimmy did once accept an invitation to dinner at Friedrich's house in Long Island but canceled last minute, infuriating Mrs Friedrich, who had been laboring in the kitchen all day.
They met one more time, many years later. In 1977, Friedrich was working at TIME magazine. Baldwin came in to do a kind of racial sensitivity lunch for the editors.
"Perhaps the best way to explain is to tell you that I have been in your kitchens. My mother was a cleaning woman, you see, and sometimes when I was child she would take me with her. So I have seen your kitchens, you know, but you have never seen mine."
"I could not help thinking, 'No, Jimmy, that isn't true. I'm the one who has been in your kitchen, eating spare ribs and potato pie, and you know nothing about mine.' But I knew my place and said nothing like that."
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
I'm glad @edwest wrote about the Stephen Lawrence case, because it's baffling to me that Britain's most famous racist incident, which supposedly proved their police "institutionally racist," was probably not a hate crime and involved no police misconduct. edwest.co.uk/p/britain-is-i…
Stephen Lawrence, the son of Jamaican immigrants, was killed in an unprovoked stabbing in 1993 while walking home late at night with a friend. A gang of white suspects were accused but the courts failed to convict due to lack of evidence. Excerpts from this book follow:
The same gang had stabbed a white boy unprovoked just a few weeks earlier. “Neil said to Mattie something like ‘Did you call me a wanker?’ When Mattie said he hadn’t, Norris pulled out ‘what looked like a miniature sword with about a nine-inch blade’ … Stacey asked what was going on. Dave replied ‘Shut up you cunt,’ stabbed him and ran off.”
Amazing used bookstore find: an oral history of the U.S.S. Indianapolis disaster (made famous by the Jaws monologue) as told by survivors.
“On the fourth day, a boy from Oklahoma saw the sharks eat his best friend, and I suppose that was more than his brain could stand. He took his knife, which was about 12 inches long, placed it in his mouth (like Tarzan in the movies), and started chasing sharks. They would stay just far enough ahead of him that he couldn’t touch them. He would go under for long periods at a time, making us wonder whether he would come up. I don’t know how long this went on, but sooner or later, I noticed that he wasn’t around.” —Sherman C. Booth
“While we were in the raft, I looked at the sailor next to me. He was dark from all the black oil and we didn’t recognize each other. He turned out to be my best friend from Hurley High School, Charles Bruneau, gunners mate, third class, Fourth Division. We had joined the navy together. He was in bad shape and did not say a word. I put my arm around him to hold him up. He stopped moving. I called Dr. Haynes. He said, ‘Charles is dead.’ We had to put him overboard. I never had the heart to tell his parents he almost made it. I told them I did not see him.” —Lloyd Barto
Interesting piece on the lawyer for the Scottsboro Boys, who, apparently, in his earlier career as a New York defense attorney, won acquittals for many clearly guilty people including Al Capone. But the article repeats some common misconceptions about the Scottsboro case itself.
It is usually said the Alabama jury convicted the nine solely on the word of Victoria Price, who claimed she was hoboing on a freight train with Ruby Bates when a dozen black boys climbed in from another train car, threw some white boys out of the moving gondola, and raped them.
But the prosecution had more than that. Multiple eyewitnesses along the train route saw the fight in the gondola car. One farmer saw the ejected white boys walking down the track, faces bloody. Another saw into the gondola for a second just as a black figure threw a woman down.
Not many people know that if Congress had not passed the Civil Rights Act of 1964, Chief Justice Earl Warren was prepared to step in with a Supreme Court decision that would have accomplished much the same thing. A thread from Boomers. 1/7
The cases Bell v. Maryland and Barr v. City of Columbia involved sit-in protests at private lunch counters and hinged on whether the owners’ actions in removing the protesters were unconstitutional under the 14th Amendment as they would have been if it had been gov't property./2
Chief Justice Warren thought so. He believed the public/private distinction collapsed the moment the owner called the police. “To say that the policy is merely ‘private’ ignores the fact that without the State it could not survive,” he wrote in an unreleased draft opinion./3
Hilarious account of a Western-sponsored training seminar for NGO workers in Serbia. The trainers really did not like it when one man stepped up during the team-building exercise to coordinate the tasks. They kept badgering the group to feel bad about not being more egalitarian.
“Was there someone that felt … suppressed? Somebody that did not feel like an individual?”
“No, we did not feel like that.”
One of the team-building tasks was to cover one person in toilet paper.
“Nobody was frustrated? Uncomfortable? You, Vesna, you were wrapped with paper because they said you were the shortest … was it ok?”
“Yes, I found it normal so we use less paper and it would be faster.”
We had an amazing 2023 at @amconmag. As an editor, I'm always looking for pieces that couldn't be published anywhere else. TAC has a unique mission and a special contribution to make. Lots of articles this year hit the mark—here are a few examples: /THREAD
10. @JuliusKrein's review of Sam Gregg genuinely advanced the debate over “market fundamentalism” and the New Right. The last third of the piece is a sweeping retelling of a century of economic history, which made a lot of pieces fall into place for me: theamericanconservative.com/the-last-gasp-…
@JuliusKrein 9. BLM and antifa took over a slice of Seattle and declared it an “autonomous zone” called CHAZ. Within days a teenager was murdered. Nobody cared. Jonathan Ireland wrote this indignant essay about it: theamericanconservative.com/a-murder-in-ch…