The Supreme Court today delivered its much anticipated verdict on the #MaharashtraPoliticalCrisis. The SC has unanimously held that the the Governor was justified in inviting Mr. Shinde to form a Government with the support of the BJP (contd.)
Mr. Thackeray’s resignation as CM even before undergoing the floor test, rendered the matter purposeless even before it began. The Court has observed that owing to Mr. Thackeray’s resignation, it is unable to restore status quo as it does not have the powers to undo a resignation
Importantly, the Court has also referred the decision in the Nebam Rebia case, strongly referred to by the Petitioners, to a larger Bench. The Court has stated that the situation that arose in the Nebam case, did not actually arise in the present case.
This decision has also stalled the Petitioners’s attempts to malign the Election Commission as biased and curtail its powers. The Court has asserted that the ECI cannot be prevented from determining which group the symbol of the Shiv Sena should be granted to
As noted by the SC itself, this matter, which has taken up an immense amount of the Court’s time and resources, was a purely academic exercise; visibly undertaken to soothe the Shiv Sena’s ego and salvage past glory
The pointlessness of the matter is bolstered by the fact that the Maharashtra Government, under the able leadership of CM Shinde and Deputy CM Devendra Fadnavis, has already begun efficiently functioning
Importantly, Mr. Thackeray’s final act of betraying the people’s mandate has fallen flat; as both the Apex Court and the people of Maharashtra have made their resounding decision, revealing that the crisis was not within Maharashtra, but the top rung of the Shiv Sena itself.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Senior Ministers of AAP held a press conference today with the sole purpose of misleading the public, so as to save face before their electorate. In doing so the party has un-shockingly stooped to a new low of misinterpreting Court orders.
Senior Ministers have made a twisted reference to observations of the District Court allowing the bail application of Gautam Malhotra. They have brazenly announced that the Court has held that that the ED and CBI cases against AAP are “bogus”.
They have falsely alleged that the Court has absolved their Minister of serious charges under the PMLA. When in fact, in the order rejecting Mr. Sisodia’s bail the Court has said he is the “brain” behind the liquor policy conspiracy (order attached)
The fuss surrounding the release of #TheKeralaStory, is the latest revelation of hypocrisy by a predicted group of compulsive contrarians. Despite the desperate hoo-ha being created to stall its release, courts have stood firm.
It is one thing that those objecting the release dishonestly routed their way to the Supreme Court by filing an application in an unconnected matter; but another thing that their submissions were (knowingly) in full ignorance of past precedents upholding free speech.
Ironically, this past precedent is a “cause” that this group of persons usually seek to champion. However, this latest episode of hypocrisy is yet another example of the comfortable convenience that kicks in when the law is against personal interests and goals.