The kind of activism and mobilization we saw in Mumbai for Aarey Forest and Pune for #VetalTekdi, in the US, would have shut down those projects super fast. Cos the system here gives its citizens ways to push back against leaders.
Indian system is about compliance.
Indian system says, here are IAS babus, very smart, cos chosen by older IAS babus who we all have to agree are very smart cos that exam is so tough! And we have elections for just 3 posts - MP, MLA, local representative. Everything else, we will only decide.
In NYC, I vote for a dozen or so different posts in a 2 year cycle.
Twice! Cos primaries.
That means almost everyone with any power doing anything, is still answerable to voters in a much more direct way than in India, where we get only 3 votes every 5 years.
If you attend community board meetings for NYC, you will see how much say and how much sway politically engaged citizens have.
It's not all lollipops & rainbows.
But it's real participative democracy for those who want to participate.
Indian system just doesn't have that!
I say NYC cos that's where I saw it first.
But that's how things operate everywhere in the US.
Lots of posts that run the machinery of the state are up for elections. In addition to MP, MLA, local representative. Twice.
It makes things messy too. But the arc tilts progressive.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Full day after Kandula tried attacking the White House, the details revealed suggest a combination of mental health issues & residual Sanghi Nazi apologia.
The "plot" was too stupid to have any chance of success. Suggests either delusions or suicidal thoughts.
With @sjacobtalk leaving NDTV, feels like someone just switched off the lights on my youth, like Sam at the end of Cheers.
For a few months now, I've been expecting her to leave. And you can see why that clip was the last straw.
But I don't wanna talk politics in this moment.
I just want to observe a moment of silence for the complete and total end of NDTV, an organization that played a big role in my life from as far as I remember! From world this week to star news to NDTV through all these tumultuous years.
It felt like family. Maybe too much!🙈
I've watched all these folks for, wow, at least 20 years now! From Prannoy to Barkha to Rajdeep to Nidhi to Arnab to Ravish to Sonia to Vishnu to Srinivasan to Sarah and so many others. They have all been an integral part of my growing up. No matter where some of them ended up.
"POTUS gave a polite hint to Modi that demands from his staff & businesses for state dinner tickets are getting excessive & he should rein them in cos white house staff has other duties too. But clueless modi & his people turned it into a compliment. 🤦"
Haha typical! 🤣🤣
"There were 7000 guests for the South Korean state dinner and we thought that was too much to handle. The Indians apparently want to double that number so their media can say, highest ever attendance at a state dinner."
"the White House switchboard is sick of the sheer volume of calls from random Indians saying they want an invite and they know Modi personally. We can't wait for this circus to be over. These are not serious people, man!"
For example "I have an early morning flight. Yaar please will you make that amazing half fry egg? I always break the yolk. 😭"
Then his parents visited one time & we were chatting about this and that and his mom was surprised to hear me say he was helpless in the kitchen!
She said what nonsense, we have taught him the basics, and he's fried many eggs. He's just a lazy guy who is great at fobbing off work. When I brought it up with him, he was proudly amused of how much he had made me cook by pretending to be bad at it.