Matthew Sheffield Profile picture
Jun 19 17 tweets 5 min read Twitter logo Read on Twitter
🧵 American politics is severely distorted by an extremist form of reactionary Christianity which originated in the former Confederacy.

And yet this fact is almost never mentioned by mainstream media journalists, even when they are covering the events these people host. 🧵
This failure to tell the full truth originates in the "both sides" fallacy of MSM reporting, but how it manifests here is especially dangerous to democracy and for people who get sucked into this reactionary culture.
I'm going to use this article as an example, but I am not trying to single out the author because, alas, it's extremely common.

It's a well-written report from the recent Turning Point USA Young Women’s Leadership Summit washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/2023…
The first thing to understand about Turning Point USA is that it's basically an evangelical cult run w an iron fist by grifter Charlie Kirk.

@MatthewBoedy is the person to follow if you want to get very in-depth. Here's a @TheoryChange overview flux.community/matthew-sheffi…
The evidence that Kirk is a radical reactionary who hates the majority of Americans, believes that LGBT people are Satan's servants, and is obsessed with the rapture is overwhelming.

And yet these facts are never mentioned in reports about TPUSA's activities.
You cannot get a speaking slot at a TPUSA event if you don't submit to or advance Kirk's reactionary religious agenda.

MSM reporters know this is true. But they are loath to mention this because it's impolite. Instead, the use the circumlocution "culture war."
You hear the term "culture war" incessantly in MSM reporting. But there is no culture war. Instead, what we have is a small core of ever-radicalizing Republicans who hate the overwhelming majority of people who support religious pluralism, racial justice, and LGBTQ rights.
Reporters who want to tell the truth about TPUSA events need to disclose these facts. The Young Women’s Leadership Summit was nothing but rage against modernity by totalitarian Christians.

But in the WaPo piece I linked, this is only hinted at obliquely.
The word "Christian" is mentioned only 3 times in this very long article. That's burying the lede.

It's the equivalent of writing about the Muslim Brotherhood and barely mentioning islam.
TPUSA is literally telling young women to drop out of college, get married asap, abandon birth control, and start churning out babies.

That was the underlying goal of the entire conference. But if you read the article above, it only hints that this happened.
Confederate Christians have finally realized that they cannot convince most people. They cannot recruit so they must reproduce.

The radical right is openly trying to out-breed everyone else. TPUSA is a breeding program. This event was about turning attendees into baby factories.
Understanding that the Republican Party has been overrun with Confederate Christians is the real "red pill" in American politics.

@kalihollowayftw did a fantastic job detailing why it is Confederate Christianity here: thedailybeast.com/this-juneteent…
For professional journalists who were brought up in what @jayrosen_nyu calls the "view from nowhere," accepting that the 2nd largest political party is owned by Christian fanatics goes against everything they were taught.

They're desperate to deny this.
But the Republican Party cannot be saved. It must be destroyed electorally. FDR's biggest achievement was militarily crushing the Axis. A close second was how he crushed American reactionaries.

The GOP cannot be saved. Individual Republicans can be salon.com/2023/06/07/ame…
Reactionary ideologies do not believe in facts because they have an inverted epistemology. They think truth comes from "first principles" rather than observing reality.

A party operating with that assumption cannot be reasoned with. flux.community/matthew-sheffi…
This broken epistemology is also shared by secular libertarians, incidentally.

See this @TheoryChange episode I recorded with @willwilkinson for further details theoryofchange.flux.community/p/theory-of-ch…
I've got to move on now but will add an essay version of this thread later today. Thanks for sharing!

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Matthew Sheffield

Matthew Sheffield Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @mattsheffield

Jun 16
Thread: The first rule in GOP politics is that you should never believe right-wing media. Donald Trump forgot this & it's why he could spend life in prison.

In the past, Trump didn't believe rw media. But now he's taking advice from Tom Fitton. flux.community/matthew-sheffi…
There are basically three groups in Republican politics: 1) The (mostly ignorant) voters.
2) The activists & propagandists. They promote Republican pols, attack Dems, and motivate the voters. True believers.
3) The inner circle. These people are totally cynical operators.
The Republican inner circle or elites know the public hates the party's anti-government agenda. It's why they work so hard for gerrymandering and unlimited billionaire campaign spending.

This is the group Trump came from originally. But he's gradually been pulled to level 2.
Read 19 tweets
Jun 8
Part Robertson, the antisemitic Christian supremacist who was one of the founders of the religious right, has died. He was 93.

He never got to become the Republican presidential nominee, but his vision for the party completely triumphed.

apnews.com/article/pat-ro…
Regarding his antisemitism, see this piece on Robertson and "New World Order" conspiracism middlebury.edu/institute/acad…
Among the many terrible things Robertson did in life was his decades of persecuting and lying about queer people. Here's @RightWingWatch's clip of Robertson claiming that gay men wear rings to infect people with AIDS in order to kill them
Read 14 tweets
Jun 5
Thread: How the "fanfiction left" creates a politics of failure while taking home millions from the far right.

This is a summary of the latest @TheoryChange episode featuring David Masciotra.

Continue here, or click through to watch, read, or listen: theoryofchange.flux.community/p/theory-of-ch…
As most people know, the right has evolved into a minoritarian politics that loves failure and hates the public.

But a similar thing is happening in some quarters of the political left. Social media has enabled the rise of what Masciotra calls the "fanfiction left."
The internet is filled with fanfiction, stories and books set in other people's universes where fans can have characters and stories operate the way they imagine them to, rather than their authors.

But while fanfiction stories are simple fun, fanfiction politics is harmful.
Read 20 tweets
May 26
1) "Reactionary extremism" is the best term to describe the far-right attitudes that keep the Republican party in business, but a second-best term for them is "Confederate Christianity."

There are other useful terms for this, but I think they exclude too much...
2) Standard-issue conservative Christianity has nothing to do with the Confederacy per se, what we are dealing with presently is obsessed with the Confederacy, and it's why you see such obsessions over obscure monuments to traitors.

Normal conservatism shouldn't care about them.
3) What happened, however, is that as anti-government extremists affiliated with Barry Goldwater began turning their attentions toward boosting Republicans (previously, they pursued multiple parties) in the former Confederacy, it changed who they were and what they wanted.
Read 17 tweets
Apr 18
🧵 Dominion and Fox have settled, we'll see what the details are shortly, but undoubtedly, there will be apologies, hopefully at least one on every Fox program for multiple months.

Let's review what we've learned in the meantime...
1) The lawsuit has proven that Fox's critics were right from the beginning about what it was and is.

Fox is not news. It's a political propaganda operation whose purpose is to manipulate and monetize fundamentalist Christians and uneducated people.
Fox was created by Republican media consultant Roger Ailes who never for a moment abandoned his efforts to advise and control Republican politics.

All of these efforts to use Fox as a political tool continued after Ailes was fired for sexually assaulting women.
Read 15 tweets
Apr 16
Thread: The U.S. is stuck in a doom-loop with a shrinking minority of far-right activists tearing down democracy.

But abstract warnings of "norms" or "democracy at risk" won't work.

In the latest @TheoryChange, I talk with @Tim_Shenk about what can. flux.community/matthew-sheffi…
Our conversation is centered around Tim's important new book, "Realigners: Partisan Hacks, Political Visionaries, and the Struggle to Rule American Democracy."

Check it out here: us.macmillan.com/books/97803741…
Realigners is a history of political change in the United States, starting at the very beginning. That's important because in order to change the game, you must first learn all of the rules. Far too many people today w/progressive views refuse to do this work.
Read 14 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(