1/ Over the more than 50 years affirmative action's morally squalid and racist practices were in place, how many white and Asian applicants were denied admission in favor of less qualified black and Hispanic applicants? I was likely one of them, and maybe you were, too.
2/ Years ago, I applied to a top law school, and was rejected.
My GPA: 0.3 points higher than average GPA of blacks admitted
My LSAT: Higher than the average at this school
Average LSAT of blacks admitted: MUCH lower than my score and the white average
3/ My undergrad degree: In a program ranked #1 in nation.
Also: I had received academic awards, had a book published by an academic imprint as an undergrad, had glowing recommendations from well-known scholars.
4/ A few years after I was rejected, the admission records of the law school leaked, and the data appeared in the media. There was a stat I've never forgotten: About 1 out of every 7 blacks admitted dropped out. The white drop-out rate was essentially zero.
5/ So dozens of qualified white and Asian applicants who would have graduated had they been admitted were denied admission in favor of black admits who dropped out because they had no business being admitted in the first place.
6/ The way that liberals in the media processed the information in this leak is what drove me from the left and toward the center. There's something deeply disordered about the American left's moral compass and sense of fairness.
6/ Overwhelmingly, it wasn't disadvantaged BIPOCs benefiting from affirmative action, but rather middle-class ones who attended good K-12 schools. And yet liberals pretended not only that affirmative action was social justice but also that whites and Asians were not harmed.
7/ Of course it's entirely possible I wouldn't have gotten into that law school even if there hadn't been affirmative action. But over 90% of the black applicants who got in under AA wouldn't have either.
Bottom line: More capable whites and Asians would have been admitted.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1/ The most perfect (and almost unbelievable) metaphor for affirmative action: The lives of Allan Bakke (a white guy who challenged racial quotas at UC Davis) and Patrick Chavis (a black guy admitted to UC Davis under affirmative action the year Bakke was rejected).
2/ After Bakke won his SCOTUS case in 1978 (which ended the use of *overt* racial quotas in university admissions), he finally was accepted at UC Davis medical school. He graduated and eventually began practicing medicine. He kept a low profile, and didn't give interviews.
3/ Years later, the NY Times, still stinging from Bakke's victory, published a long and glowing account of a “thriving” black UC Davis medical school graduate named Patrick Chavis, noting how he had benefited from the school's old affirmative action quota system.
(3) We should avoid studying genetic differences in behavior between individuals
(4) Race and ethnicity are social constructs, without scientific or biological meaning
(5) Indigenous “ways of knowing” are equivalent to modern science and should be respected and taught as such
"Biology faces a grave threat from progressive politics that are changing the way our work is done, delimiting areas of biology that are taboo and will not be funded by the government or published in scientific journals, stipulating what words biologists must avoid..."
Conservative follows me but then can't believe that someone who isn't a conservative might have a view that's different from one of theirs. Surely, it must be because I'm "trying" to conform to some artificial notion of what I am, rather than just expressing what I truly believe.
This kind of comment — which I get a lot — baffles me. Why do people assume that someone who sometimes has views which seem conservative, and other times liberal or "moderate", is only being sincere when expressing views conforming to their own. It's a weird kind of narcissism.
Or maybe it's because they can't transcend a hard-wired partisan bias that convinces them that views existing outside their own range on the political spectrum aren't legitimate, and therefore can only be accounted for by insincerity, indoctrination, or some ulterior motive, etc.
1/ The mean IQs of various racial/ethnic groups in the US from the ABCD study (2016-2018):
Northeast Asians, 110-112
Asian Indians, 103
Filipinos, 102
Whites, 100
Middle Eastern, 96
Black African, 90
Native American, 90
US Black, 83
I'll discuss some details below.
2/ The study tested ten-year olds. You can see that some of the sample sizes were small. You can put less faith in the averages drawn from these samples. But the sample sizes for whites and US blacks were large, and those results can be trusted.
3/ The study draws largely from the NIH Toolbox, which is a fluid intelligence-loaded instrument. This is not a dataset of weakly g-loaded test results.
At a 100 meters quarterfinal at the NCAA East Regionals yesterday, Cole Beck became the fastest white man in history.
Take a look at the clip and I'll talk about the significance of this, and also about something anomalous that's going on in track and field.
If you've followed me for awhile you probably already know that I'm interested in a subject that people aren't supposed to be interested in: Performance differences between population groups.
These show up most conspicuously in IQ, sprinting, and long-distance running.
When Virginia Tech's Cole Beck broke a race barrier in sports yesterday — becoming the first person of wholly European ancestry run 100 meters in under 9.9 seconds (his time was 9.87) and only the third to go below 10 seconds, it got zero coverage in the media.
"Whiteness institutionalizes lies and dishonesty."
Every study I've seen finds a strong positive relationship between "whiteness" and honesty — whether it's citizens returning wallets, companies resisting bribes, or governments fighting corruption.
Ms. Shah came all the way from one of the most corrupt and racist countries in the world to lecture white people from her perch in Canadian academia about their lies and dishonesty.