William Aird Profile picture
Jul 1, 2023 9 tweets 3 min read Read on X
1/9

EXAMPLE OF Hb-Hct DISCORDANCE

Take a look at the values in the graphic. Without looking ahead in the thread, can you make a diagnosis?
2/9

The patient has ERYTHROCYTOSIS (defined as an increased RBC count) and POLYCYTHEMIA (based on the Hct, but not the Hb).
3/9

What's up with the elevated Hct but normal Hb? Well, there is violation of the 3:1 rule which states that the Hct is normally 3x the Hb (e.g., Hct 45, Hb 15). Stated another way, the MCHC (Hb/Hct) is low, thus there is HYPOCHROMIA.
4/9

We can calculate not only the MCHC but also the MCV (Hct/RBC count). The MCV is only 66 fL, so the patient has non-anemic hypochromic microcytosis.
5/9

To summarize, the patient has erythrocytosis, polycythemia (according to Hct), and non-anemic hypochromic microcytosis.
6/9

We can illustrate the RBCs using a schematic of spun hematocrits.
7/9

This is a patient with newly diagnosed Jak2 V617F-positive polycythemia vera. Many such patients present with concomitant iron deficiency (from increased Fe demand +/- occult GI bleeding).
8/9

It's really interesting to consider that the patient with PV may present with erythrocytosis alone (masked PV), then develop erythrocytosis and polycythemia (+/- iron deficiency) and finally - during a specific window of treatment - polycythemia alone. So cool!!
9/9

When considering the Hb and Hct in polycythemia vera, the Hct is the critical parameter because it is the primary determinant of blood viscosity and thrombotic complications. So, the presence of a normal Hb - as in this case - should not provide reassurance!

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with William Aird

William Aird Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @WilliamAird4

Feb 13
1/9

I’ve long taught a simple framework for hypoproliferative normocytic anemia that I still love:

• nutritional deficiency
• inflammation
• organ dysfunction (kidney, liver, endocrine, marrow)

Clinically useful. Memorable. Teachable.

And it still holds up. Image
2/9

But conceptually, something interesting is happening.

These categories aren’t actually the same kind of explanation.

Nutritional deficiency and inflammation are mechanisms.
Organ dysfunction is different.

And even within organs, not all behave the same way.
3/9

Take kidney disease.

We often say “anemia from CKD” as if that explains it.

And in a way, it almost does.

Because kidney disease sits very close to mechanism:
↓ EPO → ↓ erythropoiesis

It’s only one step away.
Read 9 tweets
Feb 13
1/11

I posted a poll:

A woman with ferritin 10 and Hb 12.2 (baseline 14). How should this be described?

Here’s how you answered:

• non-anemic Fe deficiency: 35%
• Fe deficiency anemia: 32%
• Fe deficiency with relative anemia: 27%
• none: 6%

Really interesting spread! Image
2/11

This tells us something important: clinicians sense a mismatch between definition-based language and physiology-based thinking, even if we disagree on terminology.
3/11

By strict WHO criteria, she is not anemic.
Hb ≥12 in women = normal.

So formally the correct label is: iron deficiency without anemia.
Read 11 tweets
Feb 10
RETICS IN PV

I recently ran a poll asking whether polycythemia vera (PV) is associated with:

• ↑ absolute reticulocyte count
• ↑ % reticulocytes
• both
• neither

The most popular answer was also the best answer: ↑ absolute reticulocyte count. Image
2/10

At first glance, that can feel counterintuitive.

PV is a disease of excessive red cell production, so why wouldn’t the reticulocyte percentage also be increased?

The answer depends on what reticulocytes actually measure.
3/10

Two metrics that are often conflated:

• Absolute reticulocyte count = how many reticulocytes are circulating

• Reticulocyte percentage = reticulocytes ÷ total red cell mass

They answer different physiologic questions.
Read 11 tweets
Feb 2
1/13

I posted a poll asking:

In acute GI bleed anemia, would you give 1 g IV iron regardless of ferritin?

Results:

• 27% yes — anticipate iron debt
• 12% sometimes
• 21% only if ferritin is low
• 41% no
2/13

First, an important acknowledgment:
There is no right answer here.

There are no firm guidelines that tell us what to do in this situation. Reasonable clinicians land in different places.

This is a gray zone where physiology, timing, and judgment matter.
3/13

So rather than argue what we should do, I want to walk through the numbers and biology and explain why some clinicians anticipate iron debt even when ferritin is normal.

Let’s take a concrete example.
Read 13 tweets
Jan 23
1/9

Yesterday I posted a CBC + reticulocyte count and asked for your diagnostic thoughts. Many of you offered great reasoning. The correct diagnosis was hemoglobin C disease.

Let’s unpack why this case is such a good learning example. 👇 Image
2/9

Microcytosis often triggers a reflex binary:
iron deficiency vs thalassemia trait.

That’s a useful starting point. But it’s incomplete. Structural hemoglobin variants (like HbC and HbE) also belong on that list.
3/9

Several people calculated the Mentzer index (MCV/RBC):

75 / 4.0 ≈ 18 → “suggests iron deficiency (ID).”

Important teaching point:

The Mentzer index was designed to distinguish thal trait vs ID. It is not validated for structural hemoglobinopathies like HbC or HbE.
Read 9 tweets
Oct 21, 2025
1/7

A STRUCTURED APPROACH TO NORMOCYTIC ANEMIA

A practical, population, and molecular look at how we reason through normocytic hypoproliferative anemia at the bedside.

(Full TBP tutorial linked below ⬇️)
2/7

1️⃣ The ABC Spine – A Bedside Framework

A: substrate supply (nutritional)
B: regulatory signaling (inflammatory)
C: organ dysfunction (kidney, liver, endocrine, marrow)

We focus here on the hypoproliferative end of the spectrum, where the marrow is not keeping up. Image
3/7

2️⃣ Anemia of the Elderly – A Population Perspective

In older adults, causes divide roughly:

1/3 nutritional 
1/3 inflammatory
1/3 unexplained

Each slice maps back to A, B, or C of the spine. Image
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(