In the previous thread, I covered Field Marshal S.H.F.J. Manekshaw’s life, from his family and childhood to joining the Army in the first batch of the IMA—The Pioneers; his young officer days with the Royal Scots and 4/12 FFR; he took 9 bullets and was awarded the Military Cross+
in 1942 during the World War II. From 1943-46, he moved every few months— attended the Staff College Course in Quetta, posted as Brigade Major to Razmak Brigade in North Waziristan, posted to 9/12 FFR in Burma under Gen W.J. Slim’s 14th Army, appointed the Directing Staff at the+
Staff College in Quetta; assisted with the rehabilitation of over 10,000 Japanese troops as a Staff Officer in Indo-China (now Vietnam); after a six month lecture tour of Australia he was posted to the General Headquarters as GSO1 in MO-3, responsible for perspective planning.+
Now I will try to cover his coveted military career from independence and partition era to becoming the Army Commander (Western and Eastern). I will make a separate thread on his tenure as the Army Chief, 1971 war and the Field Marshal.+
The British Government announced its decision to grant independence to India in February 1947, and just after three months decreed that the country was to be divided in two nations of India and Pakistan.+
This meant not just drawing new boundaries but distribution of assets, including those of the Army.
The Armed Forces Reconstitution Committee was formed on June 16 and it directed:
•Two-thirds of all physical assets would remain with India and+
one-third would be apportioned to Pakistan.
•Regiments, units and sub-units with Muslim majority troops would be assigned to the Pakistan Army while Hindu and Sikh regiments would remain with the Indian Army.+
Teams worked overtime to separate the files of military establishments and the service records of personnel that would soon belong to Pakistan. Redistribution of the operational plans was a challenging task since they are not made in isolation.+
In March itself when there indications that the country would be partitioned, Manekshaw’s Directorate, MO-3, began sorting maps and plans of territories that would become part of Pakistan from those that would remain with India. To keep the records complete he had the foresight+
to get copies made of all material marked for Pakistan.
On August 14, 1947, Indian officers hoisted a farewell at the Delhi Gymkhana Club for their comrades who would soon leave for Pakistan.+
A silver trophy with a Hindu and a Muslim soldier, both training their guns at a common foe was presented by Maj Gen K.M. Cariappa, the senior-most Indian officer, to Brig A.M. Raza, the senior-most Pakistani officer.+
Pakistan and India became independent nations on August 14 and 15, 1947. On August 17, the British unveiled the border, the Radcliffe Line, drawn by Sir Cyril Radcliffe, that now divided the two countries. This triggered a mass migration of 10-12 million people.+
Muslims from India moved to the new homeland, Pakistan, while Hindus and Sikhs from what was now Pakistan, left for India. People were forced to leave their homes, their wealth and the land they had possessed for generations.+
This resulted in the outbreak of communal frenzy and riots, mainly in the region of Punjab. The Army was called out as hordes of refugees poured into Delhi. MO Directorate assisted the civil administration in maintaining law and order.+
On other hand, the 565 princely states ruled by Maharajas had to be settled. The British had given the Maharajas autonomy to govern their states as long as they acknowledged suzerainty of the crown. These states were not officially part of the British Empire and therefore+
the Maharajas were required to opt for India or Pakistan by signing an Instrument of Accession. Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel was deputy prime minister and held the additional appointment of ‘Minister of (princely) States’. VP Menon was secretary in the ministry.+
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
In a lecture at Defence Services Staff College, Wellington on Leadership and Discipline; 11th November, 1998, Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw speaks on his role in 1962 war and was he in a position to do something about the situation?+
“In the 1962 war, I was in disgrace. I was a Commandant of this Institution. Mr. Krishna Menon, the Defence Minister, disliked me intensely. General Kaul, who was Chief of General Staff at the time, and the budding man for the next higher appointment, disliked me intensely.+
So, I was in disgrace at the Staff College. There were charges against me I will enumerate some of them-all engineered by Mr. Krishna Menon. I do not know if you remember that in 1961 or 1960, General Thimayya was the Army Chief.+
In 1972, there were talks that the Army Chief, General S.H.F.J. Manekshaw, was in line for a promotion to the rank of Field Marshal in recognition of his remarkable contribution in Indo-Pak War of 1971. However, it was also in common knowledge that the Defence Minister Jagjivan Ram was against this proposal and had previously stated to the Press that the Indian Army would never have a Field Marshal or a Five-Star General. The wait stretched for months. It seemed like Manekshaw was paying the price for bypassing the Minister when the latter had once asked the reason for not implementing “Caste-based Reservations” in the Armed Forces.+
The book, A Soldier Recalls, by Lt Gen S.K. Sinha (he was the Deputy Adjutant General at the time) gives interesting insight, he writes:
“Relations between Jagjivan Ram and Manekshaw had not been too good. They had a confrontation on the issue of reservations in the Army for Scheduled Castes and Tribes. The Army was and still is, the only department of Government, where there is no reservation for any caste, though members of Scheduled Castes are recruited as soldiers in fairly large numbers. Class composition of regiments do amount to reservation for certain communities. However, this is more in the nature of preserving old traditions by continuing with the recruitment of certain traditional classes with a long military background.”+
“The bulk of the Army, however, is not affected by class composition and recruitment quotas are allotted to States on the basis of their population, for eligible candidates, without any caste or other consideration.
Jagjivan Ram wanted reservation for Scheduled Castes in the officer cadre. Manekshaw felt that by doing so we would be compromising on efficiency and with India facing constant threats to her national security, it would be inadvisable to take such a step. He mentioned that recruitment to the officer cadre should be solely on the basis of merit. Candidates from Scheduled Castes should be given special coaching and other facilities to enable them to compete”.+
In a lecture at Defence Services Staff College, Wellington on Leadership and Discipline; 11th November, 1998, Field Marshal Manekshaw speaks on his role in 1962 war and was he in a position to do something about the situation?
“In the 1962 war, I was in disgrace. I was a Commandant of this Institution. Mr. Krishna Menon, the Defence Minister, disliked me intensely. General Kaul, who was Chief of General Staff at the time, and the budding man for the next higher appointment, disliked me intensely.+
So, I was in disgrace at the Staff College. There were charges against me I will enumerate some of them-all engineered by Mr. Krishna Menon. I do not know if you remember that in 1961 or 1960, General Thimayya was the Army Chief.+
He had fallen out with Mr. Krishna Menon and had sent him his resignation. The Prime Minister, Mr. Nehru, persuaded General Thimayya to withdraw his resignation. The members of Parliament also disliked Mr. Krishna Menon, and they went hammer and tongs for the Prime Minister in Parliament.+
On 28 April 1986, in the Ashoka Hall of Rashtrapati Bhavan, the 87-year-old General Kodandera Madappa Cariappa was invested with the rank of Field Marshal and presented the baton by President Giani Zail Singh.
The book titled Field Marshal K.M. Cariappa written by his son, Air Marshal K.C. Cariappa (Retd), gives a detailed account of the event. He writes:
It was a particularly memorable event for us in the family. His two surviving brothers Nanjappa and Bopaiah had arrived from Kodagu to be present at the Investiture Ceremony. The Ashoka Hall was filled to capacity by the high and the mighty of the land. Father was in his dress uniform, something he had not worn for many, many years. He wore, as always, narrow pointed shoes.+
At that time he was being treated for a particularly painful toe on his right foot. In fact at home he would always wear a shoe on the left foot, but allowed himself to wear a slipper on the right. He would often be in excruciating pain, but always maintained a stiff upper lip. For the investiture he would not hear of not wearing a shoe on his swollen foot.+
He arrived at Rashtrapati Bhavan where he was received with due ceremony, and ushered to the special chair where he was to sit alone till after the investiture. He refused to use a walking stick though he limped heavily, nor did he accept the arm proffered by an ADC. The arrival of the President was heralded by the traditional fanfare when we all stood up; the National Anthem followed.+
Today, let us remember Field Marshal SHFJ ‘Sam’ Manekshaw on his 110th birth anniversary.
Born into a Parsi family in Amritsar, the community had migrated from Persia to India to avoid religious persecution, first landed as refugees in Gujarat. Sam’s grandfather, Framji, was a teacher in Valsad; Morarji Desai, a freedom fighter who later would go on to become Prime Minister of India being one of his students.+
Sam’s father, Hormusji, born and raised in Valsad went on to study medicine at Grant Medical College, Bombay where he met and fell in love with Hilla Mehta. After a long courtship the young Hormusji dashed off his savings to propose to Hilla and they got married in 1899. His medical practice did not fare him well and the couple strived to make ends meet.+
His friends suggested he move to Lahore since there was a shortage of medical practitioners. With their firstborn, they boarded the Frontier Mail at Bombay Central Railway Station and after 2 days arrived in Amritsar. Sam describes, his mother who lived all her life in Bombay was distressed at sight of tall, well-built Sikhs standing on the platform.+
India-Pakistan delineation teams headed by Lt Gen Premindra Singh Bhagat, PVSM, VC and Lt Gen Abdul Hameed Khan, SPK, SQA, met at Wagah and Suchetgarh to demarcate the Line of Control of J&K along the entire length on the map, in accordance to the Shimla Agreement.
Pakistani troops laid down their arms and surrendered to India for secession of East Pakistan as the new nation of Bangladesh. Indira Gandhi and Z.A. Bhutto met in Shimla to wrap up outstanding issues and after a prolonged negotiation, Shimla Agreement was signed in July 1972.+
The Agreement called for the disengagement of troops on either side of the international border to be completed within 30 days of its coming into force. In the case of J&K, Cease Fire Line would henceforth be known as the Line of Control (LOC). The troops would remain on the LOC resulting from the cease fire of 17 December 1971. This being the case, the LOC had actually to be delineated on the ground, detailed maps had to be prepared, conflicting claims resolved.
Despite having an upper hand, India failed in getting a formal sign-off by Bhutto to recognise this as an international border. Nor did we seek a permanent solution to the Kashmir issue.+
A high-powered team was appointed by both sides. Lt Gen P.S. Bhagat, PVSM, VC, was named as the representative of the Chief of Army Staff, India. On the team also were Maj Gen M.R. Rajwade, VSM, MC, his Chief of Staff; Maj Gen I.S. Gill, PVSM,MC, Director of Military Operations, Army Headquarters. All three were veterans of World War II, highly decorated soldiers. The other members were Col C.M. Sahni, Lt Col M.S. Chehal, VSM and Lt Col B.M. Tewari.
The Pakistani team was led by Lt Gen Abdul Hameed Khan, SPK, SQA with Brig S.M. Abbasi, Col Mahmud Shaukat, Col Syed Refaqat, TQA; Lt Col M.M. Afsal Khan and Lt Col Ahmad Saeed.+