This isn’t solely a Russian culture issue. The British, the French, the German Reich, and the American imperial projects have all done the same, and still do. There is a wealth of literature written by people from the Global South who have been colonized and victimized 1/
by the same European powers that Ukraine sees as anchors of “European civilization” and “freedom” against Russia. De-colonization is a process of introspection as well as excision. These issues run deep, and engagement with and learning from those countries and peoples who have
been colonized and have or are in the process of de-colonizing are crucial. And these voices are often lost in the discussions of de-colonization that I have seen regarding Ukraine. I’m sure I’ll be accused of being a Westsplainer, but I am taking Ukrainians at their word.
Ukraine is in a unique position regarding Europe and de-colonization. It can push Germany, France, Britain to grapple with the legacies and continued consequences of their imperialism. But that requires working with and listening to those people who are in the same position
A dear colleague and I are writing a piece on this together to try to weave in these threads. There is a tension b/t seeking to de-colonize Ukraine and turning to Europe and European civilizational discourse to do so (while being in a position of need like Ukraine is in)
A final thought re: NATO summit and the “be grateful” comment. A study of European colonial treatment of soldiers of color who fought for them in WWI and WWII is a prime example of this. Ukraine must fight for itself, for its survival, not in hopes of achieving a European dream..
Thousands of POC lost their lives fighting for European colonial powers who promised equality and political rights, only to be told it was not their turn or they weren’t European or civilized enough, to be grateful for what they had.
The African troops of France, the Black British from across the empire troops, the African American, Mexican American, and Japanese American troops.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Okay, major developments:
-conformation that Wagner has taken the Southern Military Command District
-Wagner downed a Russian Air Force plane in Voronezh
-Putin called this treachery, Prigozhin said Wagner are the real patriots.
-Rapid advances w/success for Wagner 1/
My tweet from yesterday. I cannot emphasize how surprising it is that Putin allowed Wagner to operate the way it has because of his fear of military-led coups.
For my Western followers, know that there is no winner in this. Prigozhin is a monster. Wagner has committed atrocities in Ukraine, the Central African Republic, and Syria. These are highly trained mercenaries and now includes thousands of violent convicts from Russian prisons.
I have a lot of feelings about this day, both Orthodox Easter and the second month of the Russian war in Ukraine. I am constantly thinking about how this war highlights the myriad of inequities and accepted forms of barbarity in international and western institutions. 1
The slow roll out of sanctions against Russia, the limited sanctions against Russian oligarchs, the continued European purchasing of Russian oil and gas show how the needs and demands of capital trump the human. 2
The extent of Russian atrocities against Ukrainians mirror Russian atrocities against Syrians and Chechens. The weapons killing Ukrainians killed Syrians first. Yet, so many found themselves surprised. 3
"The Devil's cleverest wile is to make men believe that he does not exist." This is Russian imperial history. I don't have time to go over ALL of Russian colonization and imperialism, so here are some highlights: 1/n
Siberia: Siberia is home to a myriad of indigenous groups who practice(d) pagan and naturalist religions. Throughout the 16th-19th centuries, the Russian imperial state used settler colonialism to Russify these areas and to force the indigenous peoples to become Orthodox.
The Caucasus: Home to dozens of peoples incl. Muslims. This region was last Russia colonized (19th c.) in a brutal, violent series of conflicts that sought to destroy the Islamic faith and practices of the people who called it home. Native languages were oppressed. 3