Antipoverty Centre Profile picture
Aug 15 15 tweets 5 min read Twitter logo Read on Twitter
🧵
Today we publish our #PunishmentForProfit report, with support from @GetUp.

93% of people say "mutual" obligations harm their mental or physical health. We expected a strong response to these questions, but these figures surprised even us.

READ HERE: https://t.co/631wLvs0yApunishmentforprofit.org
Two people in a park on a sunny day. They are holding a hand painted sign that says "$7 billion in contracts to torture the poor.
@GetUp Some highlights.

85% said a job agency had made a mistake or done something that caused a problem with their payment.

97% said ‘mutual’ obligations are not useful. #PunishmentForProfit People looking for work need help not harm. This report documents the failures of our welfare compliance regime and the privatised employment services industry, and offers a vision for supportive employment services designed by unemployed people for unemployed people.
In total, 591 people contributed to the 2 surveys this report is based on.

56% reported having a disability & 18% identified as trans.

These cohorts are over-represented, which reflects the significant employment barriers & discrimination experienced by people in these groups.
The employment services system costs $4 billion a year.

In the first 7 months after Workforce Australia launched, job agencies reported fewer than 1700 "6 month outcomes" of people being in education or employment.
“The public is out of pocket $4 billion a year while (un)employment providers make millions in profits rorting the system. It’s an open secret that it fails us. It’s time for Labor to back up its words with action." – Jay Coonan, report co-author from the Antipoverty Centre “There is no version of “mutual” obligations that isn't degrading. There is no version of “mutual” obligations that isn't intrusive. There is no version of “mutual” obligations that isn't controlling.  “The welfare system is killing people. Scrapping “mutual” obligations is long overdue. The government must abolish penalties then work with unemployed advocates to create a safe and genuinely supportive employment service.  “Only 2.3 percent of employed people we surveyed found a job with the help of an employment services provider. We need to scrap “mutual” obligations and design a public em...
“We are committed to repeating ourselves with newer and more damning data for as long as it takes,” – @jezheywood, @AusUnemployment President “Volunteer and underfunded advocacy groups like the Antipoverty Centre and the Australian Unemployed Workers’ Union spend thousands of hours each year supporting our communities to defend their rights and dignity, and writing beautifully detailed and comprehensive reports telling the government the same simple truths: mutual obligations are a punitive system built on flawed and cruel ideology.  “We are committed to repeating ourselves with newer and more damning data for as long as it takes decision makers to acknowledge this reality and put a stop to this human misery machine.”
@jezheywood @AusUnemployment “A superior approach would be abolishing mutual obligations and enabling job search support for all people seeking employment.” – @terese_smfa, Single Mother Families Australia CEO “People locked out of the workforce, cycling in and out of paid work, or underemployed would benefit from a radical overhaul of Workforce Australia. A superior approach would be abolishing mutual obligations and enabling job search support for all people seeking employment.  “Removing the punitive and onerous demands would produce savings that could be reinvested into an enhanced participation fund for social security claimants. Creating a new model that is community-led, responsive to local workforce needs and well-placed to meet the aspirations of each community.”
@jezheywood @AusUnemployment @terese_smfa “The findings of this report clearly demonstrate the devastating harm caused when vital social programs like employment services are outsourced to private companies.” – Chido Dunn, @GetUp Campaign Director “The findings of this report clearly demonstrate the devastating harm caused when vital social programs like employment services are outsourced to private companies who care much more about profit than they do about people.  “The Albanese government knows that the current system is broken and that it needs to change. This means we have a real opportunity to push Labor to enact ambitious reforms. It’s gone on for too long, and the Australian public wants to see an end to the waste and the cruelty.”
@jezheywood @AusUnemployment @terese_smfa @GetUp Tomorrow the @AustralianLabor national conference will open with "An economy that works for everyone" as the first item on their agenda.

But millions of people left behind in the current economic climate are excluded or ignored in the conversation about our future. Screencap of Labor conference agenda with a circle around "Chapter 1: An economy that works for everyone"
@jezheywood @AusUnemployment @terese_smfa @GetUp @AustralianLabor We call for an end to the political influence of organisations that donate millions in return for billions in contracts. 1.93 out of 5: APM score from 62 ratings submitted to the AUWU app by people in employment services. $701,838: Political donations since 2011. The Coalition received $334,433 and Labor $385,315. $787 million: Value of current published employment services contracts. $644.9 million: FY22 revenue in Australia. Global revenue was $1.33 billion. $940 million was from employment services. $4.53 million: FY22 remuneration of CEO Michael Anghie. APM founder Megan Wynne received a salary of $750,000 and performance bonus of $487,500.
@jezheywood @AusUnemployment @terese_smfa @GetUp @AustralianLabor We call for an end to forced labour programs like Work for the Dole and subminimum wage jobs that exploit people in poverty for the profit of so-called charities. Employment services have been a valuable cash cow for Salvos, which has the fourth largest Workforce Australia caseload of around 50,000 people a year. 348 Salvos stores locations throughout Australia generated $18 million in profit that was put back into Salvation Army programs.
@jezheywood @AusUnemployment @terese_smfa @GetUp @AustralianLabor Our report features contributions from dozens of people in employment services who contributed to this research. Dozens of stories are on our website with more to come in the next few weeks: https://t.co/uB1ADrEP5Kpunishmentforprofit.org/tag/survey/
Quote from Keiran, a survey participant from Victoria: Give people money and they will make a life for themselves. Keep people in poverty and they will have more barriers to work. And you’ll have all the excuse you need to spend more on cops and jails. None of what you are doing has any efficacy so why did Labor make halving the waiting time for work for the dole their first change to the system? Why punish people for systemic failures of neoliberalism? Your policy is insane and you should feel bad for perpetuating it.
@jezheywood @AusUnemployment @terese_smfa @GetUp @AustralianLabor We are incredibly grateful to every person who has shared their experiences with us, both formally and informally.

There will be more to come from our contributors, including a series of papers authored by people who attended our employment services workshops. List of report contributors
@jezheywood @AusUnemployment @terese_smfa @GetUp @AustralianLabor Our work is not done until the safety net is safe and liveable.

This research continues. If you have had to do "mutual" obligations to get a Centrelink payment, we encourage you to contribute.

Help us break the poverty machine #BTPM ✊

DO THE SURVEY: https://t.co/F6WQkjHX76apcentre.formstack.com/forms/coercive…
Cropped image of a sign held by a person in a park. It is hand painted and says "Break the poverty machine"
@LorikeetMusk @GetUp Should be readable now, but presumably fixing that will cause some other problem 😂

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Antipoverty Centre

Antipoverty Centre Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @antipovertycent

Jun 20
The bill that that will lock income control (CDC, Basicscard etc.) in Australian social policy is set to be debated today. The bill is likely to pass as both the coalition and ALP agreed that it should pass. So what does it mean? 👇 🧵
1. It's voluntary now, right? NO! Biggest myth. Income management in Australia is not a voluntary program. It is a mandatory program if you live in the NT and select locations in NSW, Vic and QLD.
2. Cashless Debit Card is gone, a win! NO! The coalition CDC might be gone, but the ALP have the 'Enhanced Income Management' card, which is exactly the same thing under a different name.
Read 10 tweets
Apr 18
The economic exclusion committee has released its report, you can read here... all 99 pages. will post highlights below 👇

ministers.treasury.gov.au/ministers/jim-…
Has called for an increase, but not a figure.. not promising. It is also worth noting that these two recommendations are nothing new and have come from previous reviews on tax and social security. Recommendation 1 The Govern...
Doesn't come to a conclusion on what is an acceptable poverty line, and says that "further analysis should be undertaken" and that the current pension rate is the best available...

we have consistently advocated for henderson line + new measure of poverty and will continue to The current level of pensio...
Read 19 tweets
Apr 18
🤨 this is the issue with "lived experience". it has become a tick box exercise that is watered down and misused to deny people with direct and recent experience of having a voice to advocate for systems change.
a 'lived experience' person is trained to talk about how it feels, and not what we want to change. lived experience is a buzz word for the "adults" in the room, they misappropriate it to take power from us by giving us a manufactured platform.
it is a selective process, whereby they further perpetuate harm through "deserving" and "underserving". it's all about messaging, it's never about our lives and it is never about systems change, it's all for high paid advocates to score a "win" with our lives.
Read 4 tweets
Dec 13, 2022
Back from lunch.

We've got National Council for Single Mothers and their Children represented by @AradiaSayner and @Terese_NCSMC

@Foodbank_SA represented by Sarah Davies

@JFAPurpleOrange represented by Cathy Cochrane, Elizabeth Farrant and Tracey Wallace.
@AradiaSayner @Terese_NCSMC @Foodbank_SA @JFAPurpleOrange “37% of single-mother families live in poverty. 42% in a sole parent family are in poverty. It is gendered.” – @Terese_NCSMC #PovertyInquiry #BTPM
@AradiaSayner @Terese_NCSMC @Foodbank_SA @JFAPurpleOrange “Half a million women who fled gendered violence now live in poverty. The choice is safety or poverty. 90,000 people wanted to leave but couldn't because of money. 10,000 a year leave and return for financial reasons.” – @Terese_NCSMC #PovertyInquiry #BTPM
Read 70 tweets
Dec 13, 2022
Now we're going to hear more from real experts.

People actually experiencing poverty will give statements, followed by Lisa Courtney from the Murray Mallee GP Network.

Thank you and solidarity to all sharing their expertise ❤️✊ #PovertyInquiry #BTPM
First up, Jennifer.

“I have been living on Centrelink most ofmy life. It started because my partner left and I was left to raise children on my own. Back then it was supportable to rent and feed my children. It was a struggle but doable.” #PovertyInquiry #BTPM
“Indexation to payments has not kept up for anybody. I became the victim of homelessness because and it was legal. My landlord just decided. I had nowhere to go and an 8 year old. I took him on 'holiday' and he didn't know we were homeless.” – Jennifer #PovertyInquiry #BTPM
Read 47 tweets
Dec 12, 2022
Morning! Time for another #PovertyInquiry hearing, this time in Murray Bridge SA. You can listen here: aph.gov.au/Watch_Read_Lis…

We're again overstretched – follow #RobodebtRC updates via @maximumcuddles, @DarrenODonovan, @SquigglyRick and everyone on the @not_my_debt list. #BTPM
@maximumcuddles @DarrenODonovan @SquigglyRick @not_my_debt @RossWomersley @SACOSS @AntiPovertyN_SA "The issues in Murray Bridge aren't different to those in other regional towns. These have been prevalent for a long period of time. We should recognise the resilience and capacity of communities to work together on these issues." – @RossWomersley #PovertyInquiry #BTPM
Read 63 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(